Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Cuilin

Cuilin

Joined May 2016

So many books,📚so little time. 🕰 From Cork, Ireland 🇮🇪 living in New England, USA #BookedInTime #NoPlaceLikeHolmes #WhatTheDickens
reading now icon
Sense and Sensibility by Jane Austen
reading now icon
The Return of Sherlock Holmes by Arthur Conan Doyle
reading now icon
Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy
reading now icon
Lark Rise to Candleford by Flora Thompson, H. J. Massingham
reading now icon
Les mis?rables by Victor Hugo
blurb
Cuilin
Pirates | Matthew Craig
post image

#BookedInTime @Cuilin

In February we head out into the wild seas and against all rational advice we search for pirates. 🏴‍☠️
Q1. How is the Tudor times going?
I read Dissolution and loved it. Cromwell made an appearance.
Q2. Do you have a book in mind yet for Pirates?
I‘m bringing a list to the library, Libby.

Answers in the comments. As always, everyone is welcome.

AllDebooks I've yet to start my Tudor pick. I love pirates, can't wait. I've selected 1d
See All 32 Comments
BarkingMadRead I still have to start my Tudor book! I will check and see what my pirate pic is! 1d
Karisimo This might be a bit of a stretch for the category, but it‘s one I really enjoyed about a female pirate with some magical elements 1d
Cuilin @Karisimo oh I never got to finish Amina as I had to return it to the library. I liked what I got to read. 👍 1d
Cuilin @AllDebooks sounds good. There are two Irish female pirates that I‘m interested in learning more about. (Anne Bonny and Gráinne Maol) I wonder if they show up in your book. 1d
Cuilin @BarkingMadRead lots of time. 1d
Bookwormjillk Pirates are fun! I‘ll have to do some research! I have a bunch of library books due then on to the Tudors! Thanks to a longer than usual winter break and then a snow storm I‘m back on the struggle bus this month! 1d
ChaoticMissAdventures I am going a bit rogue (fitting for pirates month!) and reading the nonfiction book 1d
Cuilin @ChaoticMissAdventures lol love it!!! Read it last year. Great book. 1d
Amiable I‘m halfway through “Dissolution” now. 1d
Jess861 There aren't many pirate books at my local library. I'm going to give the tagged book a go just because it's what they have. Not sure how much I'll like it though. 1d
Jess861 My Tudor pick was definitely something. Never quite read anything like it. 1d
AllDebooks @Cuilin I'll keep an eye out for them and let you know 😊 1d
Cuilin @Bookwormjillk I‘m getting closely acquainted with Hoopla and Libby. 1d
Cuilin @Amiable Are you liking it? 1d
Cuilin @Jess861 I guess it depends on the writing style, but the actual story of the Sacking of Baltimore is really interesting. I‘m from that area of Ireland so it‘s a story I‘m familiar with. Looking forward to hearing your thoughts on this one. 1d
Cuilin @Jess861 I just read your review. 👍 1d
Jess861 @Cuilin I'm very interested in the story itself but you are right about the writing style. It seems like one bad thing after another and I'm hoping it's not all war and fighting. Not that it makes a book bad but just not my personal preference. 1d
Deblovestoread In my efforts to look to my shelves first I‘m also going a bit rogue by choosing 1d
dabbe @Amiable Are you liking it? 🤩 1d
dabbe So glad you loved DISSOLUTION! 🤩 #shardlakerocks 1d
dabbe Got all of these on our spreadsheet! We're now up to 20 categories!

Here's the spreadsheet link: https://shorturl.at/0zvFs
1d
rubyslippersreads I‘m behind on the Tudor era, but if it‘s not too much trouble, I‘d like to change my book to 1d
rubyslippersreads @AllDebooks @BarkingMadRead I‘m glad I‘m not the only one who‘s behind. 😄 1d
Itchyfeetreader I am plodding on with my Tudor book - I feel like I have read so much in this period I almost feel like i have read it before but I have not! For feb I am going YA with the tagged book 3h
julieclair Can‘t wait to start my Tudor book! For February, I‘m either going to read Blackbeard the Pirate or this one about Grace O‘Malley now
julieclair Link to the StoryGraph Challenge for anyone who would find it helpful: https://app.thestorygraph.com/reading_challenges/2cdac7b0-0085-4e6b-b601-f63cbd6... now
50 likes32 comments
blurb
Cuilin
Sherlockian | Graham Moore
post image

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes #TheGameIsAfoot

Fellow Sherlockians, in a blend of Sherlock‘s encouragement and rationality I will say as you embark on this challenge to remember that success often favors the prepared mind. Approach with your keen intellect, and you shall navigate through the obstacles with clarity. I have every confidence in your abilities.
Click on the link, first highest score wins

https://forms.gle/AHEhXXU3gwmSsvph9

36 likes5 comments
blurb
Cuilin
The Adventure of the Abbey Grange | Arthur Conan Doyle, Sir
post image
Librarybelle It really does point to the lack of confidence in the Justice system at the time (and dare I say this carries over into today). 6d
dabbe The jury (Watson) is not impartial; he's completely enamored with Lady Blackenstall: “Seldom have I seen so graceful a figure, so womanly a presence, and so beautiful a face.“ The judge (SH) thinks he's given Hopkins all he needs to solve the case, knowing he won't because as @Librarybelle eloquently pointed out, they always fail in solving any case. 6d
See All 6 Comments
CogsOfEncouragement There would be no justice or aide of any kind for an abused wife from the law. Still difficult to get any in 2025.

They were much more upset about his setting a dog on fire as that was hushed up with difficulty. If it had been a neighbor's dog, it would have been an even bigger issue, but it was Mary's. SH knew this abuse would only continue. He's dead now, what's done is done, if the police can't figure it out, that's fine.
6d
CatLass007 At that time a woman was practically the property of her father or other male relative, then her husband. It‘s still difficult for women in this day and time but it‘s not quite that bad. 6d
AnneCecilie Holmes will at the end of the day do what he thinks overall is the right thing. There were some talk about the difference between the police and him: “what I know is unofficial, what he knows is official. I have the right to private judgment, but he has none. He must disclose all, or he is a traitor to his service.” 5d
31 likes6 comments
blurb
Cuilin
The Adventure of the Abbey Grange | Arthur Conan Doyle, Sir
post image
Librarybelle I hardly ever figure out anything, so I probably cannot answer this well! I would not have zeroed in on the wineglasses, so I‘m not sure that was fair play or not. The mystery of this was a lot lighter than other stories we‘ve read. 6d
dabbe I find it interesting that Holmes & Watson let Crocker, Elizabeth, and Theresa go free--even though they named the Randall gang as the murderers (who were conveniently in the US). They were willing to let the gang hang for a murder they did NOT commit. Doesn't that make them look bad in the eyes of the law? Is it okay for them to do that because the gang was bad already? Lots of morality issues in this one IMHO. 6d
See All 7 Comments
CogsOfEncouragement The ladies hoped to conveniently pin this on known baddies in the area. They are clear of it though, it will go unsolved now.

I don't know anything about wine, so those clues were no help to me, and I didn't think about the kind of knots used to link it to a seaman, I thought maybe it looked like they tied up the chair with no one actually in it and SH could tell that.

I was impressed/entertained that the mastermind was the devoted nursemaid.
6d
CatLass007 The nursemaid mentioned the Lady‘s brother so I thought he might have been the killer. That was the red herring. I thought when Holmes went to the shipping company he would discover the brother, not a man in love. Was Holmes showing his romantic side? 💘😂 6d
eeclayton @CatLass007 I suspected the brother, too. It made a lot of sense, with both women eagerly shielding him. 5d
AnneCecilie I never guess the solution to any mystery but I feel like the older mysteries are less fair than newer ones. We were left with the wine glasses. The wife being a foreigner seems to be a trope that Doyle uses. 5d
26 likes7 comments
blurb
Cuilin
The Adventure of the Abbey Grange | Arthur Conan Doyle, Sir
post image

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes

The game is afoot!! General thoughts and impressions?

(I will be attending a class today so may not have much access to my phone but will check in with discussions later).

Librarybelle In some ways, he‘s the same Holmes, doggedly searching for a truth only he can puzzle out. Not accepting the almost flawless first explanation is in character with him. But, he also shows empathy—or his version of empathy— with the unmasking of the real scenario. We‘ve seen his version of justice before; the fact that he asks for Watson‘s opinion as the “jury” makes this unusual. I think I said “wow” aloud when I read that. 6d
See All 10 Comments
Read4life @Librarybelle I remember also being surprised when he asked Watson‘s opinion as jury. 6d
dabbe This one's a hard one for me re: the stories of what happened. Holmes does not believe the original story, but who's to say the final stories are true either? At one point he tells Watson that “we must construct our case for ourselves without any help from [Lady Blackenstall and Theresa]“--yet he totally believes Crocker's and their second stories verbatim without checking anything out because their stories fit his reasoning of what happened. (edited) 6d
CrystalE02 I found it odd that he asked Watson for his opinion on the matter. 6d
kelli7990 I enjoyed this story. 6d
CogsOfEncouragement A fun one that I did not figure out.

I much enjoyed:

“Your fatal habit of looking at everything from the point of view of a story instead of a scientific exercise...“

“Be frank with me and we may do some good. Play tricks with me, and I'll crush you.“

“Then it was my turn, and I went through him as if he had been a rotten pumpkin.“

6d
CatLass007 It seemed out of character for Holmes to play matchmaker. 6d
AnneCecilie I never figure out the solution and I‘m easy to fool, but I have also learned that Coyle is using some formulas in his stories. So when it said that the wife was a foreigner, I knew that the solution with have something to do with her. The “jury” at the end was a new one even if Holmes has let people off before 5d
25 likes10 comments
blurb
Cuilin
Shakespeare: The Man Who Pays the Rent | Judi Dench, Brendan O'Hea
post image

I‘m just getting around to some thank you notes and wanted to say thank you @dabbe for this lovely holiday gift. I‘ve had it on my TBR and I‘m really looking forward to reading it. I have a whole Shakespeare shelf and this will be a wonderful addition. Thank you so much not just for this perfect gift but also for your friendship. 🤗 PS the candle smells divine.

Andrea313 What a beautiful gift! Popping in to say I hope you love the book- it was my favorite of my last year's reading. You have such a treat in front of you! 1w
dabbe Yay! I adore my bookmarks and LADY MAC book, too! (I hope I already posted about that! My memory ain't what is used to be! 😂) And what a perfect thought for today's #25Alive ... #friendship 🤗 🩶🖤🩶 1w
Cuilin @Andrea313 thank you 🙏 😊 1w
See All 7 Comments
Cuilin @dabbe yes you posted, I‘m the slow poke here. Absolutely #25Alive #friendship @Eggs @Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks 1w
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks ❤️🤍❤️ 1w
dabbe @Cuilin No, you're not. No worries, m'dear. 🩶🖤🩶 7d
Eggs How lovely 🥰 6d
63 likes7 comments
blurb
Cuilin
The Return of Sherlock Holmes | Arthur Conan Doyle
post image

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes

Fellow Sherlockians, we continue the cannon with a fun game to kick off our reading in 2025. Look out for a link to a quiz this weekend after our discussion for tAo the Abbey Grange. Prize will be sent to the person with the first highest score. 🎉 🏆 🥇 🏅

43 likes6 comments
blurb
Cuilin
The Tree A Day | Amy-Jane Beer
post image

#NaturalLitsy #ATreeADay @AllDebooks

For those reading tagged book and got excited about the tree and location, (Sherwood Forest!!) I went down a rabbit hole and sending a link if you care to join me. There‘s drone footage! 🌳 💚

https://visitsherwood.co.uk/explore-the-forest/the-major-oak/

TheBookHippie Ooooooo thank you!!!! 2w
AllDebooks This is on my turf, I've visiited it so many times since childhood. This book feels like home 🏡 2w
Cuilin @AllDebooks @TheBookHippie I‘m adding it to my bucket list!!! I fell in love with a tree this morning. I love this book. 2w
See All 7 Comments
TheBookHippie @Cuilin I love this book. Love. 2w
dabbe 💚🎄💚 2w
dabbe Just sent you an email re: Sherlock. 🩶🖤🩶 2w
52 likes7 comments
blurb
Cuilin
Hard Times | Charles Dickens
post image

#WhatTheDickens Hard Times Buddy Read

Hard Times is the 10th novel by Dickens published in 1854. With themes, including the consequences of unchecked capitalism and the importance of empathy it‘s still relevant today. All are welcome! We will check in mid month and post a discussion question at the end of January.

Lcsmcat I‘ve got a hard copy and a Kindle edition, so I‘m all set! Looking forward to it! 2w
Cuilin @Lcsmcat 👍 I‘m planning a mix of a hard copy and audio. 2w
See All 11 Comments
Lcsmcat @Cuilin Who‘s reading the audio? Anyone we‘d recognize? 2w
Cuilin @Lcsmcat Bertie Carvel and Jeremy Paxman 2w
Lcsmcat @Cuilin That should be good! 2w
Texreader Yay!!! Here we go!! 2w
BarbaraJean I have such FOMO about this, but January is packed and since Hard Times is a re-read for me I‘m going to opt out this month and jump back in for Nicholas Nickleby. I‘ll no doubt lurk on the discussion, though 😁 2w
Cuilin @BarbaraJean I get such FOMO with Litsy buddy reads. I‘m glad I‘m not alone in that. Yes jump in for the discussion at the end of the month. 👍 2w
43 likes11 comments
blurb
Cuilin
post image

#BookedInTime #BookedInTimeJanuary25 #BookedInTimeTudors

In the wake of the War of the Roses, the House of Tudor succeeded the Plantagenets. They ruled 118 years from Henry VII to Elizabeth I, succeeded by the Stuarts. The most well known Tudor being Henry VIII, with his six wives, and his daughter Elizabeth I, who reigned for 45 years. I‘m reading book 1 of Shardlake series. You? Comment, post or review at the end of the month!

ChaoticMissAdventures An incredible time. I am going to finally read 2w
See All 47 Comments
Cuilin @ChaoticMissAdventures I can‘t tell you how much I loved that whole trilogy. I‘m looking forward to hearing your thoughts on it. Enjoy. 2w
Daisey This is a great series! 2w
Bookwormjillk I have a hard time getting through books set in this period but I‘m going to try 2w
Amiable I think I might give this one a go, too—thanks to @dabbe ! 2w
Itchyfeetreader I am going with this one. I have read widely from this period and wanted a new vs re read🤞🤞 2w
Jess861 I've decided on reading a Philippa Gregory book set in this time period. Really not sure if I'll like this author but going to give it a go. 2w
Cuilin @Amiable yes!!! 2w
Cuilin @Bookwormjillk good luck, just remember we‘re fans of #hailthebail if it isn‘t for you. 🤞you‘ll enjoy it. 2w
Cuilin @Itchyfeetreader sounds fabulous!! 2w
Cuilin @Jess861 I‘ve never read Gregory. She is popular. Good luck. 2w
dabbe @Amiable #woohoo! I think you're going to love it! ❣️🥂❣️ 2w
dabbe I'm in the middle of REVELATION, book 4 in the Shardlake series. Reading it with the #ShardlakeSeriesBR and for #BookedInTime. All are welcome to join us! ❣️🥂❣️ 2w
dabbe DISSOLUTION is also on the spreadsheet! 🤩 2w
dabbe @ChaoticMissAdventures On the spreadsheet! 🤩 2w
dabbe @Bookwormjillk On the spreadsheet! 🤩 2w
dabbe @Itchyfeetreader On the spreadsheet! 🤩 2w
dabbe @Jess861 On the spreadsheet! 🤩 2w
dabbe @Cuilin YES!!! 🤩🙌🏻🤩 2w
julieclair @Jess861 I‘m giving Philippa Gregory a try, too. 2w
Cuilin @julieclair i‘d love to know what you think of her writing I have never read her so I‘m really interested. 2w
julieclair @Cuilin Will do! 2w
Cuilin @AllDebooks oh very intriguing 🤔 2w
rwmg My most likely contender is the next in a series I'm reading intermittently: 2w
Cuilin @rubyslippersreads I don‘t think any wife of Henry VIII had a good time, but I particularly felt bad for the teenage Catherine Howard. Enjoy. 2w
Cuilin @rwmg Fabulous, looking forward to your thoughts. 2w
Mollyanna I‘m in the middle of Revelation with @dabbe and also in the middle of Wolf Hall. Hopefully I can finish Wolf Hall in January. I‘ve read several of Gregory‘s books. They‘re pretty good. 2w
Cuilin @Mollyanna Love Wolf Hall. 2w
dabbe @julieclair On the spreadsheet! 🤩 2w
dabbe @rubyslippersreads On the spreadsheet! 🤩 2w
dabbe @AllDebooks On the spreadsheet! 🤩 2w
dabbe @AllDebooks On the spreadsheet! 🤩 2w
dabbe @rwmg On the spreadsheet! 🤩 2w
julieclair @Mollyanna Glad to hear you enjoyed reading Gregory! 2w
sblbooks 1. I'm planning on reading this one 2w
Cuilin @sblbooks that one really looks good!! 2w
Bluebird I love Shardlake! I hope you enjoy the first one! This month I‘m reading 2w
Amiable I just started “Dissolution” today! Is there a Storygraph challenge set up for this already? I can usually be more organized when I can follow along on there. 😄 Shall I set one up? 2w
Cuilin @Amiable there‘s a StoryGraph challenge for #bookedInTime organized by @julieclair I started today too. (edited) 2w
Cuilin @Bluebird I started dissolution today. So far so good. 😊 2w
Amiable @Cuilin Excellent! 👍🏼 2w
47 likes1 stack add47 comments
blurb
Cuilin
A Christmas Carol | Charles Dickens
post image
TheBookHippie The Mickey Mouse/Donald Duck one 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 don‘t judge me it‘s Christmas 🤣🤣🤣🤣 3w
TheBookHippie This was so lovely to read again. Thank you. 3w
AnishaInkspill Call Me Claus, Starring Whoopi Goldberg, it's a nice retell, entertaining and warm though a touch cheesy. 3w
See All 12 Comments
Cuilin @TheBookHippie Judgment free zone here. Have a lovely holiday Christine. 3w
Cuilin @AnishaInkspill I don‘t think I‘ve seen this one yet. Thank you. 3w
TheBookHippie @Cuilin You as well! 3w
BookwormAHN The Muppet's Christmas Carol, love it so much. And thanks for hosting 💚 3w
Cuilin @BookwormAHN Love The Muppets!! You‘re welcome. 3w
dabbe 1951 version with Alistair Sim and the 1980 version with George C. Scott. Thanks for hosting us, @Cuilin! 🎄❣️🎄 3w
dabbe And a major honorable mention to AN AMERICAN CHRISTMAS CAROL, starring Henry Winkler. 🤩 3w
CSeydel My very favorite is the Alistair Sim version - he‘s simply perfect as Scrooge. But I also quite like 1988‘s “Scrooged” with Bill Murray. 3w
AllDebooks Loved reading this again. Thank you for hosting @Cuilin I'm all for Alistair Sim, I watched this every year with my gran. 3w
34 likes12 comments
blurb
Cuilin
A Christmas Carol | Charles Dickens
post image
TheBookHippie Not much changes with the ultra rich and massive population of poor. You‘d want to believe it -but I don‘t think anyone would care or believe it. It‘s akin to romance novels HEA -pure fantasy. I have seen this story mentioned a lot recently in the political world as memes, so still relevant. Maybe if not familiar people will pick it up and read it. 3w
AnishaInkspill if Dickens wrote this today then as books were important to him then maybe big corp not swallowing up a humble book store 3w
Cuilin @AnishaInkspill I‘d read that!! 3w
See All 12 Comments
BookwormAHN I think Dickens would be disgusted with the wealthy today as he was in his time and he would find a modern way to let us know. 3w
Cuilin @BookwormAHN Agreed. 3w
Vansa This is very much as relevant today as it was in the Victorian era, and many parts of the world still exist with inequities of income far worse than in the Victorian times! 3w
Cuilin @Vansa completely agree. The disparity is absolutely, staggeringly worse. 3w
Vansa Great, thought provoking prompts, btw! Have enjoyed reading the discussions 3w
dabbe The top 1% still exists, right? And it's completely global now--or at least, we're more aware of it globally. We humans still want to be on top and keep others down, don't we? The I-pulled-myself-up-from-the-bootstraps-without-any-help ... why can't you others? Oh, yes, the story is still so relevant and much needed. 3w
Cuilin @dabbe I just chatted with my dad about that this morning. There are some current CEOs today who have never read a Christmas Carol. And it shows. 3w
dabbe @Cuilin Oh, lordy, ain't that the truth! 3w
AllDebooks This story will always be relevant. It's theme is timeless. 3w
24 likes12 comments
blurb
Cuilin
A Christmas Carol | Charles Dickens
post image
TheBookHippie Purgatory -each sin is seven years. So his sin of greed? I think that‘s what we were taught I do know the 7 year each sin thing was taught 😵‍💫😝 this is probably why between my mothers faith and fathers I did not choose my mothers 😵‍💫😝🫠🤷🏻‍♀️ 3w
Cuilin @TheBookHippie Purgatory, yep. If he saves Scrooge, is that his chance of getting to heaven perhaps? 3w
TheBookHippie @Cuilin that‘s what I assume … 3w
See All 9 Comments
BookwormAHN I also wondered if maybe he didn't feel guilty for encouraging Scrooge's behavior. 3w
Cuilin @BookwormAHN good point!! He was certainly an influence. 3w
dabbe I always think of “The Rime of the Ancient Mariner“ when I think of Marley, He, too, must go around and recount his tale to save others from his fate. I love the possible idea of salvation for him, too, @Cuilin after 7 years of purgatory, @TheBookHippie. Dickens' hope, perhaps, is that Scrooge will be spared those 7 years and get his act together while still alive--a message to all of us who are still living. (edited) 3w
Lin3han @TheBookHippie this was amazing! I have never thought about that 3w
Lin3han Along the lines of @TheBookHippie, maybe Marley had to watch Scrooge to commit those 7 sins for every year? Check for redemption before damnation? 3w
TheBookHippie @Lin3han oh maybe! Parochial school comes in handy 😵‍💫🫠😅😝 … 3w
22 likes9 comments
blurb
Cuilin
A Christmas Carol | Charles Dickens
post image

#WhatTheDickens

This was the first Dickens I had ever read, and I was surprised at how humorous he was. I remember being completely moved at Scrooge‘s transformation. It still gets me. 😢

TheBookHippie I think the ghost story at Christmas time has always been popular, so has the rich/poor equation.. we all want to believe someone like that can change and actually be altruistic … HOPE. I think hope burns brighter in the holidays. This story helps that. (edited) 3w
CogsOfEncouragement Yes, the humor throughout surprised me. Reading this as an adult after seeing countless adaptations, that was a surprise for some reason. I think we all enjoy the reminder that we can change bad/selfish habits we might have fallen into. 3w
See All 9 Comments
BookwormAHN I do love Dickens sense of humor. Bleak House is especially entertaining. I agree I think hope does burn brighter in the holidays @TheBookHippie 3w
dabbe My favorite part is best expressed in the George C. Scott portrayal from 1980. When he's jumping on the bed, saying “I am as light as a feather, I am as happy as an angel, I am as merry as a schoolboy. I am as giddy as a drunken man. A merry Christmas to everybody!“ ... my heart just soars. And who can't help but love a story of complete redemption. Wouldn't we all want that? And yes, @TheBookHippie, hope abounds--especially at this time of year. 3w
Cuilin @dabbe surprisingly the Disney version does this scene really well. The animation is incredible. 3w
dabbe @Cuilin I haven't seen that one in years ... time to revisit! 3w
AllDebooks It's the eternal pull of hope and redemption. We all can change by making different choices. 3w
Lin3han It‘s both a story of hope and horrible reality. The rich needed to be threatened to care about the poor whereas Tiny Tim was giving to all. I think it‘s a big reflection of society at large. I particularly LOVE Sir Patrick Stewart‘s rendition of Scrooge. His subtle body language and expressions convey both the every day horror seeing poor conditions and the development of empathy. 3w
22 likes9 comments
blurb
Cuilin
A Christmas Carol | Charles Dickens
post image
TheBookHippie I think the future ghost has always been my favorite -Christmas yet to come… most affective probably Marley. 3w
Cuilin @TheBookHippie oh interesting! The non speaking ghost of Christmas future always seems the most frightening to me. But yeah, I think probably the most effective. 3w
CogsOfEncouragement After an intro by a trusted partner, the three build the case to change so perfectly. He is reminded of his own villain origin story. How it definitely didn‘t need to be this way. He sees the love he is currently missing out on, hurting himself the most. Seeing a grim future that can be changed is the final push to alter his ways. 3w
See All 14 Comments
Cuilin @CogsOfEncouragement beautifully put. 3w
BookwormAHN I think the ghost of Christmas present seems like the most fun but the future ghost is the most persuasive. 3w
dabbe For me, I love the jocularity of Christmas Present and giving further insight into the present day and what Scrooge is neglecting. Then, the ominous switch to the children under his robe--Ignorance and Want--seem to me to be Dickens giving us full-on his views of the social issues of his time, emphasizing the dire consequences of neglecting the poor and uneducated in society. This is the main lesson Dickens wants to tell. 3w
Cuilin @dabbe I agree this is absolutely the lesson as he tells Scrooge when asked they are “man‘s”. We may not all be as miserly as Scrooge, but who and what are we neglecting? 3w
AllDebooks @TheBookHippie I agree, Markey is definitely the most affective ghost. He jolts Scrooge into a staye of fright ready for the 3 ghosts to visit 3w
AllDebooks *Marley 3w
Lin3han I think Christmas Past is both my favorite and the most persuasive. Scrooge watched the light and passion he used to have for life, how others treated him, and a lost love because of greed. Just like we all do, we tend to look to our past for new decisions in the present. He needed to be reminded of his prior light in order to spread it to others 3w
Cuilin @AllDebooks @TheBookHippie Would Scrooge have accepted the other ghosts if Marley hadn‘t come first? I think not! 3w
AllDebooks @Cuilin exactly. The familiarity of Marley and all their misdeeds cracks his conscience, leaving him more vulnerable to the other ghosts' appearances and their guidance 3w
TheBookHippie @Cuilin no I can‘t think he would have. 3w
23 likes14 comments
blurb
Cuilin
A Christmas Carol | Charles Dickens
post image

#WhatTheDickens
I was so tempted to look this up, but I wanted to hear everybody‘s thoughts first.

Lcsmcat Definitely not my first read! I don‘t remember how old I was the first time I- elementary school for sure. For years my husband and I had a tradition of reading it aloud each year. (I drive him crazy when we watch movie adaptations because I can‘t stop pointing out everything they do wrong.) Yet I find something new every time I read it. 3w
Lcsmcat Like @Cuilin I love the opening imagery. (The house getting lost while playing hide and seek with other houses is a favorite.) But a new funny quote jumped out at me this time. It‘s long but I‘ll try to post it. 3w
See All 18 Comments
Lcsmcat All he could make out was, that it was still very foggy and extremely cold, and that there was no noise of people running to and fro, and making a great stir, as there unquestionably would have been if night had beaten off bright day, and taken possession of the world. 3w
Lcsmcat This was a great relief, because “three days after sight of this First of Exchange pay to Mr. Ebenezer Scrooge or his order,” and so forth, would have become a mere United States‘ security if there were no days to count by. 3w
Lcsmcat And I just realized I posted these in the wrong question. 🤦🏻‍♀️ 3w
TheBookHippie @Lcsmcat I point out the wrong too!! 3w
TheBookHippie I always thought of this as a play or opera. So carol seemed fitting… no clue though 🤣. 3w
Cuilin @Lcsmcat @thebookhippie I did this recently with the David Copperfield movie. I don‘t think my husband enjoyed my exclamations of “That‘s Wrong!” as he ended up falling asleep on the couch!! 3w
Cuilin @Lcsmcat Every year I always find something new too. 3w
Cuilin @TheBookHippie Your hypothesis checks out, apparently there is an Opera!! 3w
TheBookHippie @Cuilin @Lcsmcat I do it with Les Mis 🤣😅😵‍💫 3w
BookwormAHN I believe Dickens used to read this to an audience and had it memorized. 3w
dabbe Poetically, the Cs create a lovely alliteration that sounds melodic like a carol would. Plus, the entire title of the novella is “A Christmas Carol. In Prose. Being a Ghost Story of Christmas.“ The word “story“ twice would be too repetitive.

A stave is usually used as a musical term, so that again solidifies the harmonious musicality and ultimate joy of the season that this story signifies.
3w
Cuilin @dabbe I love your explanation, I also think to call it a Christmas story would confuse it with the Nativity as “The” Christmas Story. 3w
dabbe @Cuilin Excellent point! 3w
Lin3han I think it‘s because of how it was published. He would‘ve had to publish it in bits for print just as he did with A Tale Of Two Cities. A story implies a beginning, middle, and end whereas a carol is always in continuation. Another thought is the symmetry of carolers in the beginning and end. Scrooge was angered at the beginning but ended up using them in the end as a show of his character development. 3w
22 likes18 comments
blurb
Cuilin
A Christmas Carol | Charles Dickens
post image

#WhatTheDickens
My first encounter with a Christmas Carol was reading an excerpt at age 10, the exchange between Scrooge and his nephew. And for weeks afterwards, my friends and I went around saying Bah, Humbug. A few years later, during a storm, I sat by the fireside and read the whole book. I remember thinking how humorous that opening paragraph actually is. Was this your first read?

Cuilin Join in anytime!!! 3w
TheBookHippie They read this to us in grammar school starting in kindergarten. I read it myself fifth grade so 9. I much preferred reading it myself as opposed to the religiosity of parochial school. I always thought of it as a play or opera, both of which I loved. 3w
See All 12 Comments
Cuilin @TheBookHippie the excerpt we did in school was more of an English comprehension assignment, thankfully though surprisingly, as I went to Catholic school, there was no religiosity involved! 3w
CogsOfEncouragement I read it the first time seven years ago and for some reason I was surprised by how funny it is. This was just my second read. 3w
Cuilin @CogsOfEncouragement I love the balance of dark and light. Did you notice anything new your second time reading it? 3w
BookwormAHN The first time I read it was 6th grade and I loved it. 3w
dabbe I regret that I have no recollection of my first “reading“ as a child, but I vividly remember the first time this story came into my life: Saturday night movie on channel 5 when I was 7 years old. The 1951 version entitled SCROOGE with Alistair Sims playing the pivotal roll. I was completely mesmerized and have been ever since. This is still my favorite movie rendition. 3w
AllDebooks My belived gran reading it to me at 7yrs old is my first memory. She then bought a collection of CD's Christmas books when I was in my teens 3w
Lin3han I remember my grandma reading it to me once! I truly remember my “first” time was in 6th grade where we read it in preparation to perform it as a play! 3w
Cuilin @AllDebooks @Lin3han I love that you both read it with your grandmothers. 3w
25 likes12 comments
blurb
Cuilin
post image

#WeirdWordWednesday @CBee

Gift searching has me ramfeezled!!! My new favorite word.

MariaW 😂 1mo
peanutnine I love it 1mo
dabbe 🤩😂🤩 1mo
kspenmoll I love this word!!!! Perfect! 1mo
CBee Fantastic word 👏🏻👏🏻 1mo
54 likes5 comments
blurb
Cuilin
post image

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes @dabbe

I think I missed something regarding the poison.

Librarybelle To me, it seemed a little odd that she took the poison. I also wasn‘t 100% sure why they went to the Russian embassy. 1mo
See All 9 Comments
CogsOfEncouragement 1 - not sure

2 - Her life was horrible, and she didn't want to have to do time for killing the secretary?

3 - I thought SH and W wanted to provide the evidence to free Alexis from his sentence in the Siberian salt mine as the Mrs. requested.
1mo
Daisey I agree with @CogsOfEncouragement that she didn‘t want to be convicted of murder and they went to the embassy to share the proof of evidence. 1mo
Cuilin @CogsOfEncouragement @Librarybelle I think the poison was a bit extra but as @Daisey said she didn‘t want to be convicted of murder and therefore sent to prison. 1mo
dabbe @Cuilin @CogsOfEncouragement @Librarybelle ... what I don't get is why have poison in the first place? It was proven by Holmes that she did not come there to murder anyone. She didn't bring a murder weapon at all--yet she brings poison? Just in case? How would she know she'd be in a place where she could quickly find a weapon if she needed to? 1mo
Librarybelle Good point, @dabbe ! 1mo
Cuilin @dabbe exactly!! 1mo
27 likes9 comments
blurb
Cuilin
post image

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes @dabbe

It‘s Sherlock so possibly but so much information was gleaned from one object. Thoughts?

Librarybelle You‘re right—possibly Sherlock would have figured it out, but, as the title suggests, the pince nez was the pivotal clue. 1mo
See All 6 Comments
CogsOfEncouragement I thought the change in the amount of food being consumed was key. Maybe even someone with 20/20 vision would take the wrong way in trying to leave the house because of the flooring. 1mo
Cuilin @CogsOfEncouragement yes, the food was pivotal. He knew the suspect was still in the building. 1mo
dabbe Holmes (being Holmes) probably could have put it together without the pince-nez. The footprints and lack thereof on the garden path is another clue as well as the same type of carpeting leading to the garden as well as to Coram's room. The glasses are the cherry on top of the banana split, as the cliche goes. 1mo
24 likes6 comments
blurb
Cuilin
post image

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes @dabbe

Interested her hear what other people think of this one. It fell a little flat for me but it may be a me issue. Thoughts?

Librarybelle I thought it was a little flat too. For me, it was not as exciting as some of the other cases. I did like the hidden room. 1mo
See All 7 Comments
CogsOfEncouragement Maybe SH's perfect description of the culprit? Seems like something Watson would particularly want to share with his readers. 1mo
kelli7990 I didn‘t like this story that much. 1mo
Cuilin @Librarybelle @CogsOfEncouragement @kelli7990 I see we‘re all on the same page with this one. 1mo
dabbe A day late! So sorry! Perhaps this one was included for its Russian pre-revolution plot or whatnot. Every time Watson mentions all of the other cases that he never writes about, THOSE are the ones I wish we could read! Somebody needs to write pastiches with exactly those titles! 🤩 1mo
23 likes7 comments
blurb
Cuilin
Joy to the World: A Regency Christmas Collection | Erica Vetsch, Amanda Barratt, Carolyn Miller
post image
AmyG Ha, Spotify is using AI for the wrap-ups. The descriptions have been bananas. 🤣 1mo
dabbe I do and will! Thanks for the tag! 🥰 1mo
julieclair Thanks for the tag! I‘m going to have to check out the Spotify wrap ups! And… congrats on the Pilates roll up! 1mo
kspenmoll Glad your daughter is back in NH! 💛 3w
42 likes4 comments
blurb
Cuilin
A Christmas Carol | Charles Dickens
post image

#WhatTheDickens

For many of us, this is a reread every year. Have you read it this year yet? If you have or if you have not and want to join in a gentle buddy read, with a quick discussion Christmas Eve, December 24th, let me know and I will tag you. This is open to all, but I will tag members.

Lcsmcat I‘d love to join in. Don‘t know if I‘ll have time to discuss on the 24th but I can join in later. 1mo
Cuilin @Lcsmcat Absolutely, I‘ll post on the 24th but everyone please 🙏 feel free to answer whenever you can. 🎄 1mo
See All 31 Comments
CogsOfEncouragement I‘ve started a reread this month, please count me in. 1mo
Born.A.Reader Count me in! 1mo
AllDebooks I read this every Christmas. Count me in. x 1mo
AnneCecilie That‘s sounds perfect. I was already planning on reading this so I finished on the 23rd. Christmas Eve is the big day for me, so I‘ll probably join the discussion a little later. 1mo
TheBookHippie Oh me! 1mo
TheAromaofBooks Yay, do tag me!! 1mo
dabbe Just finished LISTENING to it for the first time ever! My first completed audio book narrated by Tim Curry. And, #allthefeels--always! Yes, please tag me! 💙❄️💙 1mo
BookwormAHN I'm in 🩵 1mo
Cuilin @Born.A.Reader yay 1mo
Cuilin @AllDebooks ✅🩵 1mo
Cuilin @AnneCecilie ✅🩵 1mo
Cuilin @dabbe will do ✅🩵 1mo
Texreader ♥️♥️♥️ 1mo
Daisey Tag me please! 1mo
Bookwormjillk Sure! Good idea! I usually listen to the audio while wrapping presents. 1mo
Cuilin @Bookwormjillk I think I‘m going to do audio this year too. Hugh Grant narration perhaps 🤔 1mo
quietjenn Definitely! 1mo
Lin3han I reread every year! Usually with my students! 1mo
Cuilin @quietjenn ✅🩵 1mo
Cuilin @Lin3han how wonderful? What grade? 1mo
BarbaraJean I‘ve overloaded myself this month, so I‘m not sure if I can manage another read before Christmas! Do tag me, though—I may try to fit the audiobook in somewhere along the way! 1mo
Lin3han @Cuilin I‘m an 8th grade English teacher! 🥰 1mo
Cuilin @Lin3han So glad a teacher is reading Dickens with 8 grade!! Do they like it? 1mo
47 likes31 comments
review
Cuilin
post image
Pickpick

#BookedInTime
I don‘t care about the controversy surrounding this novel. Was a page or two plagiarized? Writers get inspiration from many sources including real people. Putting those pages aside (which the author literally did, and rewrote them) this novel is beautiful and it deserves all the stars. ⭐️

blurb
Cuilin
post image

#BookedInTime

I personally love this time period. So much drama and so much to choose from. Thanks to @rubyslippersreads for suggesting this prompt.

Bookwormjillk This time period has always been a challenge for me but I did find this chunkster unread on my phone the other day 1mo
See All 25 Comments
dabbe I'll be finishing the #ShardlakeSeriesBR with the tagged in January. I'm thoroughly enjoying rereading these historical mystery reads! 🤩 1mo
dabbe Reminder to everyone: we have a spreadsheet with all of the books we've read! Here's the link:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1sLpOtIgy6SwJkyU0wwno2MN4YUbe0ldjPwSusW3g...
1mo
Cuilin @dabbe Thank you, for reminder about the spreadsheet. I thought Shardlake would work for this prompt. 😉 1mo
rwmg How would you feel about a separate tag for announcements of upcoming periods to be discussed, such as BookedInTimePeriods? I plan each month's reading at the end of the previous month and I can't always find what the period is easily. 1mo
Karisimo @dabbe @cuilin I‘m definitely using shardlake for this one! (edited) 1mo
Cuilin @rwmg yes I can create a separate hashtag like #BookedinTimeJanTudors Would that work? 1mo
Cuilin @Karisimo I‘m looking forward to it but worried about adding another series to my TBR lol 😆 1mo
ChaoticMissAdventures This is perfect I had this one on my TBR all this year and kept putting it off. This gives me more incentive to pick it up in January 1mo
Cuilin @ChaoticMissAdventures loved that trilogy, perfect choice 1mo
dabbe @Karisimo 🤩🤩🤩 1mo
dabbe @ChaoticMissAdventures On the spreadsheet! 🤩 1mo
dabbe @Bookwormjillk On the spreadsheet! 🤩 1mo
rwmg I was thinking of something more general. If I've forgotten the prompt, which I usually have by the beginning of the month, I can't look up eg Tudors. so I need something like BookedInTimeJan2024 1mo
Cuilin @rwmg Got it!! I can absolutely do that. I‘m not adverse to posting a few hashtags. 1mo
rwmg Thank you 😘 1mo
julieclair Love this time period! 1mo
julieclair @rwmg (and everyone) I have set up a challenge on StoryGraph that lists all the prompts, if that would be helpful to you: https://app.thestorygraph.com/reading_challenges/2cdac7b0-0085-4e6b-b601-f63cbd6... 1mo
kspenmoll I have Hamnet in my TBR so that will be my choice! 3w
Cuilin @kspenmoll I loved it. Enjoy. 3w
Jess861 I'm planning to read either The Wise Woman or The Other Boleyn Girl by Philippa Gregory.

@julieclair - thank you for the storygraph add for bookedintime! I find it such a great tool to track prompts for challenges!
(edited) 3w
Cuilin @Jess861 Enjoy!! 3w
julieclair @Jess861 You‘re welcome! I like it for tracking, too. 3w
49 likes25 comments
blurb
Cuilin
Historical Fiction | Alfred Duggan
post image

#BookedInTime

I‘m just putting it out there for all to see. I will still do a monthly post. As a reminder, all are welcome to join this very low-key Buddy-read. All genres are included from graphic novels to spy thrillers, horrors and actual history books.

AllDebooks Looking forward to it 😀 1mo
See All 23 Comments
BarkingMadRead Ohhhhh I‘m going to try and not fail epically at this one, time to plan ahead 1mo
ChaoticMissAdventures Yay! Thank you for putting this together and leading us! I am excited lots of fun times here. 1mo
Mollyanna Looking forward to another year! Thank you for hosting. 1mo
Amiable Great time periods! 1mo
Deblovestoread Fantastic! Looking to a bunch of these. Thank you for putting the whole year together. 💙🩵💙 1mo
Bookwormjillk Piracy and Famine! Count me in! Seriously though thanks for putting this all together. Looking forward to a great reading year. 1mo
dabbe I've already got January covered! Thanks for hosting, m'dear! 💙❄️💙 1mo
Jess861 Great list!! I'm really hoping to participate more next year - this year was so busy and different from normal that reading took a backseat.

I just read a short on the Irish Famine - looking forward to reading a bit more about it.
1mo
Cuilin @AllDebooks 💜🩵 1mo
Cuilin @BarkingMadRead ✅💜🩵 1mo
Cuilin @Amiable thank you 🙏 1mo
Cuilin @dabbe I may have to try Dissolution 🤔 1mo
Cuilin @Jess861 oh life!! It can really mess up my reading too. Join in whenever you can. 🩵 my favorite book of all time is set during the famine 1mo
dabbe @Cuilin Oh, you'd love it! 🤩 1mo
julieclair For those who use StoryGraph, I have set up a challenge: https://app.thestorygraph.com/reading_challenges/2cdac7b0-0085-4e6b-b601-f63cbd6... I find it helpful for keeping track of what books I might want to read for each prompt. 1mo
Cuilin @julieclair thanks, I filled in my last book for this year!!! Challenge completed ✔️🎉 1mo
kspenmoll Thanks. @julieclair for the storygraph set up & thanks @Cuilin for hosting this again! 3w
julieclair @Cuilin Congrats! 👏🏆 I still have a few unread books for 2024. 3w
julieclair @kspenmoll 🩵💙🩵 3w
48 likes23 comments
blurb
Cuilin
Goodnight Mister Tom | Michelle Magorian
post image

#MiddleGradeMonday @Karisimo

Mr. Tom technically is not William‘s grandfather, but he certainly loves and protects him like he is. Beautiful classic novel.

Karisimo Sounds great! Thanks for sharing! 2mo
42 likes1 comment
blurb
Cuilin
post image
Librarybelle I was a little surprised by the Mafia mention, honestly. I‘m sure there are connections in England with the Mafia, but I hadn‘t really thought about it. As for Napoleon and the statues…though this is written decades after, it‘s still a huge piece of British history, a source of pride. It made sense to me for Napoleon to be the statue—destruction of a hated enemy. He‘s still not really well liked in parts of the world. 2mo
Cuilin The mafia mentioned caught me off guard too. Like what? I thought that was Italian American history. 2mo
See All 9 Comments
Read4life I remember thinking early on the first time I read this that there was something in the bust. The mafia connection felt like it came out of nowhere when I read it. 2mo
CogsOfEncouragement I suspected right away, it reminded me of The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle.

I was surprised so many people would want a N bust. I don't have any warm feelings for him.

The mafia mention didn't surprise me, Doyle taking the time to define what it was caught my attention.

So many good feelings from L in these stories yet the tv adaptations tend to lean into a ton of animosity from L to SH which I find interesting.
2mo
eeclayton The friendliness between Lestrade and Holmes was a pleasant surprise for me too, in this one and other stories as well, seeing how their relationship is shown in adaptations. @CogsOfEncouragement 2mo
Cuilin @eeclayton yes!!! The movie adaptations especially have them pit against each other. 2mo
Cuilin @CogsOfEncouragement I just watched the Granada YV adaptation with Jeremy Brett, and they seem friendly in that one. And then the BBC has them be on friendlier terms but the Robert Downey Jr. movie it‘s like they‘re enemies. 2mo
dabbe Part of the fun of reading the canon for me is seeing certain relationships develop, like the one between Lestrade and Holmes. I believe he features in more of the stories than any other police detective. His relationship with Holmes in the BBC series was an affable one and done very well IMHO.

I also think Doyle did write about the time period beyond just England. He's had the Mormons, the KKK, and now the Italian mafia in his stories.
2mo
30 likes9 comments
blurb
Cuilin
post image
Librarybelle I think it is a reflection of attitudes, and really attitudes today of otherness. 2mo
Cuilin @Librarybelle I was thinking the same thing that nothing much has changed, unfortunately. 2mo
See All 9 Comments
Read4life I agree that it really hasn‘t changed much. 2mo
CogsOfEncouragement I was thinking about this as I read, especially his description of being so ugly. Seemed like all Italians basically knew each other, though it would make since they might gravitate to the same neighborhoods where they could speak their heart language, as people still tend to do. I lack knowledge of the history of Italians in England. 2mo
CatLass007 I know that filmmakers and authors today are still accused of perpetuating stereotypes. All Italians are members of the Mafia, everyone in Boston supports the IRA, indigenous people are primitive or drunks or whatever the latest stereotype is. So, no, humans haven‘t changed much at all. 2mo
CatLass007 But there‘s more. Didn‘t the bust-smashing Italian Mafia guy have a nickname? It seems like everyone connected with the Italian Mafia in the movies and on television has a nickname. I enjoy reading a good mystery or thriller, but I don‘t remember reading anything with Italian Mafia guys, much less ones who have nicknames. 2mo
dabbe It seems that anyone who is “foreign“ born without white skin receives some sort of prejudice in these stories. I'm reminded of Tonga, the Indian islander who has the poison darts in THE SIGN OF FOUR. He was also described as small, ugly, dark-skinned, and able to get in tiny places. These bias portrayals even reminded me of the razor-wielding orangatang in EA Poe's “Murders in the Rue Morgue.“ 2mo
27 likes9 comments
blurb
Cuilin
post image
Librarybelle This was another fast read. I‘m not familiar with the perception of Napoleon from Italians, since he is from Corsica, and I vaguely recall animosity between the two countries (I‘m not up on my European feuds unless they involve the Tudors). 2mo
Cuilin @Librarybelle yeah I thought this was a fast and good read also. It‘s interesting regarding Napoleon, as an Irish person it was a case of “an enemy of your enemy is your friend” so I think Napoleon was probably more popular in Ireland than in many parts of the world. lol (edited) 2mo
See All 9 Comments
Read4life I enjoyed this one. I vaguely remembered it from reading it years ago. 2mo
CogsOfEncouragement I enjoyed it. The newspaper man so upset, concerned that he wouldn't get a chance to write about the interesting story because it happened to him, and he feared he was too shaken to write was a fun aspect. Then using the paper to place the culprit at ease to continue his search for the pearl was also entertaining. 2mo
CatLass007 I rarely am able to follow the clues Conan Doyle supplies. This time was different. I suspected that something was hidden in one of the busts and that the nationality of the person smashing them was a red herring. Of course, I didn‘t know what was hidden because the pearl was also a work of fiction by Conan Doyle. It‘s a nice change being able to keep up with Sherlock. 2mo
Cuilin @CatLass007 for some reason I thought there was going to be a map with clues inside the bust. 2mo
CatLass007 @Cuilin Ha! I think there‘s a reason they are called short stories. 2mo
dabbe A little late to the party this time around. After rereading this one, I remembered how I felt cheated a bit since none of us had any clue about a stolen pearl until Holmes was in the process of explaining how he solved it. Therefore, we basically had zero chance to solve the crime as far as knowing what was in the Napoleon busts. 2mo
27 likes9 comments
blurb
Cuilin
Europe Between the Wars | Martin Kitchen
post image

#BookedInTime

Those who do not learn from history, are bound to repeat it!!

Thanks to @PathfinderNicole and @majkia among others for suggestion.

AllDebooks Oooh, this is going to be a good one 😊 2mo
See All 19 Comments
Mollyanna This is a great one! I have Shrines of Gaiety currently checked out from the library, so that will probably be my choice. 2mo
majkia I've got Bright Young Dead by Jessica Fellowes I'll try to get to. 2mo
Amiable And unfortunately too often those of us who do know history still have to repeat it because of the uneducated. 😖 2mo
dabbe Got the column created and the books listed above are on it! 🤩 2mo
Cuilin @AllDebooks agreed 👍 2mo
Cuilin @Mollyanna fabulous 👍 2mo
Cuilin @majkia fabulous 👍 2mo
Cuilin @Amiable yes 😔 2mo
Cuilin @dabbe thanks Denise. 🙏 2mo
sblbooks My current read will work for this time frame. 2mo
julieclair Great theme! So many choices. I have updated the StoryGraph challenge, for those who are using it: https://app.thestorygraph.com/reading_challenges/f6f6ac21-909a-4d7e-9e1c-2084aab... 2mo
rwmg I have been reading Frances Brody's Kate Shackleton series set in 1920s Yorkshire, so I may read the next one: 2mo
Cuilin @julieclair thanks I‘ve updated mine. 2mo
Cuilin @sblbooks sounds like a fabulous cozy read. 2mo
Cuilin @rwmg I love the sound of the series. 2mo
julieclair @rwmg Oh, I love the Kate Shackleton books, but haven‘t read any for awhile. Thanks for reminding me about them! 2mo
60 likes19 comments
blurb
Cuilin
The Adventure of Black Peter | Arthur Conan Doyle, Sir
post image
Librarybelle It was an odd statement about killing versus murdering someone—based on the intent. I‘ve never thought of it that way…another thing to ponder. It seemed odd to me that Holmes let the inspector arrest the wrong man, only later to tell the inspector it was wrong. But, Holmes said a couple of times he did not have all of the facts of the case. Still seems strange that he appeared to be in agreement initially. 2mo
CogsOfEncouragement Hmmm, it was self defense, right? It was definitely more force than necessary, but maybe if one gets so comfortable using a harpoon maybe one loses sight of how dramatic it is to use it on a man with murder in his eyes?

I felt SH knew in that moment he couldn't convince Hopkins that it wasn't Neligan, he needed to gather the convincing evidence for Hopkins to see his mistake. Neligan was not in comfort, but would be okay for another day or so.
2mo
See All 7 Comments
dabbe I also think Holmes was ticked off at Neligan for not telling the entire truth, which could be why he let him go to jail for a bit. I also don't know if I take Hopkins word that it was self-defense; he could just as easily been the first to grab the harpoon and then have Carey pull the knife after. We'll never know totally because Carey is dead. Perhaps kill means just to end a life, while murder implies absolute intent. 2mo
CogsOfEncouragement @dabbe Interesting point that maybe SH was annoyed with Neligan. Let him learn to not provide partial info that doesn‘t add up to the clues left at the scene. 2mo
dabbe @CogsOfEncouragement I think SH in the past has even let the bad guy go (if he wasn't a murderer) as long as he was honest with his story. I swear, if Sherlock asked me to tell the story and leave nothing out, I'd sit up straighter in my chair and say, “Yes, sir!“ 😂 2mo
CogsOfEncouragement @dabbe LOL! Right? 2mo
28 likes7 comments
blurb
Cuilin
post image
Librarybelle Watson brings up examples of this, and yet we‘ve also seen cases that the client is clearly wealthy. We‘ve also seen cases that involve the lower classes of society. It‘s an interesting thought by Watson. I‘m still thinking about it. 2mo
CogsOfEncouragement I feel like SH is there for the puzzle and not the purse. One that stands out to me right now is the governess that he helps, Watson lets us know that she ended up as a head of a good school - telling the reader without telling the reader that SH must have made this happen as she was unable to get a better job than the governess job previously, though she was too bright for it. @Librarybelle 2mo
dabbe Agree 💯 with @Librarybelle and @CogsofEncouragement. The case has to be interesting enough for Holmes to take it--no matter who the client is. We've seen him take on all kinds and types of cases as we are at the 29th short story and the 3rd novel! 27 stories and 1 novel to go! 🤩 2mo
AnishaInkspill I‘m left with the impression Holmes takes on other cases by how he interacts with others, but I‘ve read only 2 so far 2mo
28 likes5 comments
blurb
Cuilin
post image
Librarybelle I agree. Holmes‘ method of deduction is an art. Yes, it‘s observation, but the way he does it is an art form onto itself. In this story, he creates a position to lure the murderer out. 2mo
CogsOfEncouragement Watson greatly admires SH. This friendship is part of what makes these stories so fun for me. I tend to agree with Watson, even though SH has his faults, I admire the artistry. I wasn't at my best with this one and only saw how all the pieces fit together after, but I thought the clues we had for this one were pretty good. 2mo
dabbe This one was quite grotesque for me. The picture in my edition included Holmes trying to stab the pig. 😑 And that seemed to be the big clue that SH deducted--that only an extremely strong man could have killed Peter with a harpoon, not the wimpy Neligan--whose dad HAD to have been involved in the bank crimes--even though the 10-year-old Neligan wanted to believe he was totally innocent. 2mo
AnishaInkspill this is an interesting question, I'm thinking yes and no. Yes, because Holmes has that level of abstract thinking that bypasses others (example here, Hopkins and the footprint, and later the notebook). No, because art is about creating, or for me it‘s about creating, and here Holmes is not creating he is deducing. 2mo
25 likes5 comments
blurb
Cuilin
post image

#PoetryMatters #villain @TheSpineView

Can‘t tell you how much I love this poem.

TheSpineView 😍😍😍 2mo
lil1inblue 💛 💖 💛 2mo
dabbe It's a whoah one. 🧡 Robert Burns, too. 🧡🍁🤎 2mo
Cuilin @dabbe 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 2mo
32 likes4 comments
blurb
Cuilin
post image

#WhereareyouMonday Ancient Egypt @Cupcake12

I started this on audio this morning the story seems interesting. Not sure about the narrator. We‘ll see if I‘ll continue.

#BookedInTime #TimeofthePharaohs @dabbe

dabbe On the spreadsheet! 🤩 2mo
49 likes1 comment
blurb
Cuilin
Robert Browning | Robert Browning
post image
TheSpineView Good one!🤩🤩🤩 2mo
dabbe 🤎🍁🧡 2mo
lil1inblue 🤎💜🤎 2mo
35 likes3 comments
blurb
Cuilin
Candy Cane Murder | Joanne Fluke, Laura Levine, Leslie Meier
post image

#DaysDedicatedTo #candy

*This looks like a good cozy mystery.
* Anytime anyone from Ireland visits me this is the candy I ask for. When my sister came in May, she brought so much candy and between my daughters and I it is all gone.

Eggs You have great ‘taste‘ in candy 🍫 2mo
45 likes1 comment
blurb
Cuilin
Complete Sonnets | William Shakespeare
post image

#PoetryMatters @TheSpineView #vile

I‘m probably not the only one that will think of this sonnet.

TheSpineView Perfect! 2mo
dabbe 🧡🍁🤎 2mo
39 likes2 comments
blurb
Cuilin
Sandwich Library | Sandwich, KENT, United Kingdom (Library)
post image

#DaysDevotedTo #Sandwich

* Sandwich MA on Cape Cod is beautiful.
* Apparently I am the target audience for this novel about a menopausal woman with grown-up children. I have not read it.
* I had the most delicious mozzarella, tomato, pesto sandwich on a baguette at an Orchard farm café called Pippin‘s in Vermont yesterday.

CBee I absolutely loved this book - I don‘t have grown children as I started a bit later, but I most definitely am menopausal 😵‍💫 2mo
Amiable My library hold for this book just came in today! I‘ll be picking it up tomorrow on my way home from work. 2mo
Luke-XVX Not that far from where I live!!(sandwich the place) 2mo
See All 16 Comments
Cuilin @CBee Menopause is not for the faint of heart. 😮‍💨 2mo
Cuilin @Amiable it‘s got such mixed reviews on Goodreads I‘ll be interested to know your take. 🤞 (edited) 2mo
Cuilin @Luke-XVX Are you on the Cape? I‘m in NH. 2mo
Luke-XVX Oh no the Sandwich in the UK. Cute coastal town 2mo
Cuilin @Luke-XVX beautiful. Wish I was close to there. 2mo
Eggs Love this post😍 I‘m 15 years beyond the “Pause” (it should be called the Full On Curse or something) but post-pause is heavenly 2mo
CBee @Amiable I hope you like! 2mo
CBee @Cuilin I wish I‘d known that there were stages. At this point, just throw the whole pie at me and be done with it - this years long crap is awful 😥🤦‍♀️😵‍💫 2mo
Cuilin @Eggs thanks. 😊 2mo
Cuilin @CBee same. The struggle is real. 2mo
CBee @Cuilin sending you love and solidarity ♥️👊🏻 2mo
Cuilin @CBee right back at you 👊 2mo
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks ❤️❤️❤️ 2mo
66 likes16 comments
blurb
Cuilin
Agatha Christie | Laura Thompson
post image
Eggs Excellent choice of course 😍🧡🥳 3mo
38 likes1 comment
blurb
Cuilin
Oche Shamhna | Marie Whelton
post image

Oíche Shamhna Shona daoibh!!!!

Happy Halloween everyone!!! Anybody else break into the candy already? Just me?

AmyG Hahahaha I have been eating candy all month. 3mo
Cuilin @AmyG oh thank goodness I‘m not the only one. 😆 3mo
MaureenMc Wait, there are some times of the year when you don‘t eat candy?? 😳 3mo
See All 7 Comments
Cuilin @MaureenMc lol I bought candy specifically for trick-or-treaters. I even bought candy that I don‘t particularly care for. Why am I eating it? 3mo
dabbe My #HHS chocolates are almost gone. I just opened them yesterday. 🤩 3mo
kspenmoll Candy! Yes eat along with the trick -or-treaters!!!! 3mo
33 likes7 comments
blurb
Cuilin
Mystery: An Alex Delaware Novel | Jonathan Kellerman
post image

#ThreeListThursday @dabbe

I was surprised I got 9! Love these 4 choices. Recognized some other writers I‘ve read but not the book chosen. I thought Dracula would be on a most influential list but maybe that‘s characterized as a Gothic Horror novel not mystery. Off to add some to my TBR 🤦‍♀️

dabbe 🎯 on all of your choices! My TBR just grew quite a bit, too! 😂 Thanks for playing and sharing! 🖤🎃🖤 3mo
34 likes1 comment
blurb
Cuilin
Untitled | Untitled
post image
Eggs Thanks for playing and sharing 😍🙏🏻🎃 3mo
dabbe Will do; thanks for the tag! 😘 3mo
33 likes2 comments
blurb
Cuilin
post image

#MiddleGradeMondays @Karisimo

Of Course Roald Dahl would have a collection of scary stories. Love this cover!!

Care to join in @TheBookHippie @TheAromaofBooks

Karisimo Perfect!! 3mo
PageShifter I have read some of his spooky stories and loved them! 3mo
Cuilin @PageShifter Good to know. I haven‘t read them yet. 3mo
34 likes3 comments
blurb
Cuilin
David Copperfield | Charles Dickens
post image

I feel like we get two seasons in one. First we get autumn, the leaves changing color with beautiful scenery and then fall, which happened last night. All the leaves on my tree made a pact counted to three and dropped. I‘m playing catch up #WhatTheDickens My #HyggeHour will be spent on my couch reading tagged book drinking cocoa.

TheBookHippie Dickens and fall go together so well. 3mo
Chrissyreadit 🧡💛🍁💛🧡 3mo
Texreader Ahhh, to see the leaves change color. If only that were the case down here in South Texas! It's still HOT here. 3mo
See All 10 Comments
AllDebooks Dickens, dark evenings and candlelight are the perfect combo. 🥰 3mo
Cuilin @Texreader in another few weeks I‘m going to wish it was warmer. (I sent you an email re: #WTD) 🧡 3mo
Texreader @Cuilin I sent you a reply. Yes, I'll post the question. 3mo
kspenmoll Love your whimsical(to me) division of autumn & fall. We are close to fall, but some dark brown, rusty colors cling to branches. I love the crunching sound the leaves make as I walk through them. 🍁🍂 3mo
Cuilin @kspenmoll thank you 🍂I‘m about 2 hours north of you and yesterday I had grass, today a blanket of leaves. So the crunch is coming!! 3mo
52 likes10 comments
blurb
Cuilin
Dracula | Bram Stoker
post image
BarkingMadRead Sooooo cool 3mo
See All 16 Comments
BarkingMadRead That‘s epic, what a great history leading up to Dracula! 🧛🏻‍♀️ 3mo
Librarybelle Wow! Incredible! 3mo
mcctrish That‘s so wonderful! Thank goodness for curiosity and silver linings 3mo
Cuilin @BarkingMadRead @Librarybelle I didn‘t know Dublin had a Halloween Stoker festival. 3mo
Cuilin @mcctrish imagine stumbling across an unknown story. I would just think it was one I hadn‘t heard before, he obviously knew his Stoker canon. 3mo
mcctrish @Cuilin same ( honestly it‘s even creepier than Dracula ) 3mo
TheBookHippie Oh my word how cool and fascinating!!! I love it. 3mo
marleed That is fascinating! 3mo
Ruthiella What a great story! And I love the connection to Stocker‘s mother in the naming of the foundation. 3mo
dabbe #sheerawesomeness 🖤🧡🖤 3mo
Bookwormjillk Thank you! 3mo
Bklover Wow! Thank you for sharing! 3mo
kspenmoll Wow!!! 3mo
56 likes16 comments
blurb
Cuilin
The Adventure of the Solitary Cyclist | Arthur Conan Doyle, Sir
post image

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes

It‘s so interesting to look up a biography of Arthur Conan Doyle. It gives a really good insight into these stories and Sherlock himself.

CatLass007 Having an affair while his wife was dying? That sounds very similar to American politician Newt Gingrich, who did not ask his wife for a divorce on her deathbed, but did visit her in the hospital after surgery to remove a benign tumor and who was still “out of it” following the surgery. His intention was to get her to agree to certain conditions in their divorce proceedings, which had already begun before she was hospitalized. 3mo
See All 10 Comments
CatLass007 Former American Presidential candidate John Edwards began an affair after his wife was in remission from breast cancer. He fathered a child with his mistress and continued the affair when Elizabeth Edwards‘s breast cancer returned and she was in the hospital dying. Times haven‘t changed much. 3mo
Librarybelle I did not know that about Conan Doyle! This story was shorter than others we have read, and it would have been interesting to hear more of the backstory. It‘s like we were told things happened, but we are left to wonder what exactly transpired. 3mo
Aimeesue @CatLass007 Ewww. So slimy. 3mo
CatLass007 @Aimeesue Very slimy. 3mo
dabbe In past stories, Doyle took the time to flesh out some of the characters (sometimes annoyingly so), but here we get no backstory at all. What exactly happened in South Africa that allowed Carruthers and Woodley to hook up? How on earth did they meet Ralph Smith? And what about Carruthers' wife? Did she die in South Africa? When he goes to jail, who takes care of his daughter? So many unanswered questions in this one. 3mo
Cuilin @dabbe I feel like he saw a girl on a bike came up with a stalking story (as you know it‘s hard to chaperone someone on a bike) and published before it was ready. 3mo
dabbe @Cuilin 🎯 3mo
28 likes10 comments
blurb
Cuilin
The Adventure of the Solitary Cyclist | Arthur Conan Doyle, Sir
post image

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes

“it is part of the settled order that such a girl should have followers” Sherlock Holmes. He sends Watson because he‘s too busy with important work. Got it.

CatLass007 Conan Doyle was a man of his time and so is Holmes. There are still many, many people who have the “she was asking for it” attitude. This story doesn‘t go quite that far but it is assumed that a woman would expect to attract certain attentions merely because of her gender. 3mo
Librarybelle I think it‘s sadly typical of any time, historical or contemporary, that a woman, as @CatLass007 says, gets the “she was asking for it” attitude from people. 3mo
See All 6 Comments
Aimeesue @Librarybelle I agree, though I think that one of the positive sides of social media is the spread of ideas that dismantle those gender stereotypes simply by pointing out they exist. All societies construct gender "norms" but it can take a lot to make individuals aware that they‘re swimming in the (baseless) assumptions. It‘s harder for oppressors to keep up oppressions when we‘re aware of them. 3mo
Librarybelle Very true, @Aimeesue ! 3mo
Cuilin @Aimeesue This!!!! I heard someone say that men live in an infinite loop of their own propaganda! 3mo
22 likes6 comments
blurb
Cuilin
The Adventure of the Solitary Cyclist | Arthur Conan Doyle, Sir
post image

#NoPlaceLikeHolmes

This one made me uncomfortable.

CatLass007 It made me uncomfortable also. The assumption made by the defrocked minister and the “groom” that a marriage forced upon the young woman would be upheld by the law is probably not too far from the truth for that time. Only because she had consulted Holmes and he was present when she was kidnapped kept the marriage from becoming reality. Women had very few rights at that time. Had she been drugged and kept isolated there would have been (cont)⬇️ 3mo
CatLass007 little to no chance to save her. I think the most disturbing point is that Conan Doyle could never have known what our current reality would look like. It seems that every time women (or any other oppressed group) make any progress there are those who will do everything in their power to reverse those rights. 3mo
See All 12 Comments
Cuilin @CatLass007 agreed. It is scary to see mostly white, male, Christian nationalists talk about repealing the 19 Amendment. 3mo
CatLass007 Yes. And in Florida the DeSantis Health Department sent cease and desist orders to local television stations running ads to promote an amendment to the state constitution legalizing abortion. In the words of Chief U. S. District Judge Mark E. Walker, “It‘s the First Amendment, stupid.” 3mo
Librarybelle It is an uncomfortable story, but I was also not surprised by the actions of the men in the story. 3mo
Aimeesue @CatLass007 Good grief. Just when you think they‘ve gone as low as they can, they jump in and start digging. 3mo
Aimeesue Definitely showed the precarious position of single women at that time. I was cheered by her determination though, especially when she turned around and chased the stalker. 3mo
Cuilin @Librarybelle sigh 😔 3mo
Cuilin @Aimeesue yes she had pluck!!! 3mo
dabbe I guess stalking is okay if you really love the person you're stalking. Or obsessing over. Watson was write in deeming this love a “selfish“ one because had Carruthers simply told Violet the truth, yes, she would have left, but she would have been saved from her brutal kidnapping. Man up, dude! 3mo
22 likes12 comments