Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Janesville
Janesville: An American Story | Amy Goldstein
A Washington Post reporters intimate account of the fallout from the closing of a General Motors assembly plant in Janesville, WisconsinPaul Ryans hometownand a larger story of the hollowing of the American middle class. This is the story of what happens to an industrial town in the American heartland when its factory stillsbut its not the familiar tale. Most observers record the immediate shock of vanished jobs, but few stay around long enough to notice what happens next, when a community with a can-do spirit tries to pick itself up. Pulitzer Prize winner Amy Goldstein has spent years immersed in Janesville, Wisconsin where the nations oldest operating General Motors plant shut down in the midst of the Great Recession, two days before Christmas of 2008. Now, with intelligence, sympathy, and insight into what connects and divides people in an era of economic upheaval, she makes one of Americas biggest political issues human. Her reporting takes the reader deep into the lives of autoworkers, educators, bankers, politicians, and job re-trainers to show why its so hard in the twenty-first century to recreate a healthy, prosperous working class. For this is not just a Janesville story or a Midwestern story. Its an American story.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Hooked_on_books
post image
Pickpick

The story of GM‘s recovery after the Great Recession is mostly depicted in media I have seen as a triumphant recovery. This book looks at the reality of what happened to average Americans when the GM plant in their town closed and stayed that way. It‘s clear from their experience that government and private programs, including retraining, are inadequate, allowing many to fall through the cracks. Excellent, balanced reporting.

squirrelbrain I found this fascinating when I read it a few years ago - it‘s a good one! 3y
peaKnit I thought this was a good book too. Janesville does seem to be thriving more these days for sure 🤞🏻 3y
55 likes2 comments
review
Singout
Pickpick

Really interesting: the story of a Wisconsin city where the main industry is a GM plant (like the closest city to my high school village) that completely shuts down. Goldstein looks at how people pull together, create new resources to support each other, and introduce new employers, but also have to go long distances to keep earning an income, suffer family strain, and get mixed political support.
#Nonfiction2021 #Hope #WorkingClass

quote
Singout
post image

#FirstlineFridays @ShyBookOwl
At 7:07 a.m. the last Tahoe reaches the end of the assembly line.

blurb
squirrelbrain
post image

Would Janesville become a #ghosttown when the GM plant closed down, or would it rise from the ashes of globalisation?

I found this book fascinating, depressing and, yes, inspiring in places. The author spent 5 years with everyday families in the aftermath of the closure so there‘s real insight into how people, and big business, react after such an event.

Hooked_on_books I have this one on deck for Wisconsin. Glad to see you liked it! 5y
Cinfhen I‘m slowly becoming fascinated by this genre of NF #stacked 5y
Sace That does sound interesting. 5y
JenReadsAlot I live right outside of Janesville- the book was really well written. 5y
61 likes1 stack add4 comments
review
balletbookworm
post image
Mehso-so

3.5 stars. A solid book recounting if the lives of the people of Janesville in the wake of the GM plant closing at the start of the recession, throwing thousands out of work. The tone of the book felt too chatty for me, and some the chapters absurdly short, but the author did a good job bringing across the frustration of people doing everything they can to stay afloat when barriers keep being thrown in their way.

balletbookworm it also highlights, though not explicitly, the problem with the conservative idea that generosity and charity will see people through when, clearly, that isn‘t enough 6y
balletbookworm ETA: I do need to add a CW though. Late in the book one of the people Goldstein followed died by suicide. The chapter is not long, nor very graphic, but it does recount how she was found and the efforts to revive her. 6y
22 likes2 comments
review
squirrelbrain
post image
Pickpick

So apologies for filling up your Litsy feed but I‘m catching up with reviews from this week...! This is the (true) story of a town in Wisconsin and what happened to its inhabitants when the GM plant shut down. In the first few chapters I thought it maybe a bit dry but it quickly became a thoroughly engrossing read. I was really rooting for all of the characters, although of course there are no glib happy endings to this American tale.

GondorGirl I'm going to have to read this one. I grew up near Flint/Detroit, Michigan and watched my town fall apart after the GM plants shut down. 6y
squirrelbrain Oh yes, you‘ll have to do @GondorGirl - I‘m sure it would mean a lot to you. (edited) 6y
JenReadsAlot I live outside janesville and know a few people that had to make career changes from this happening. 6y
squirrelbrain @JenReadsAlot - it seems as though there really weren‘t many / any options that paid as much as GM, so people really were struggling 🙁 6y
Librarybelle This does sound interesting...stacking 6y
87 likes3 stack adds5 comments
review
Decalino
post image
Pickpick

This book follows residents of Janesville, Wisconsin as they experience the 2008 recession and resulting shutdown of the GM plant at the heart of the local economy. The lives of the auto workers really resonated with me; their choices mirrored those faced by steelworkers, including my dad, when the mill closed in my hometown. Despite occasionally stilted writing, this was an absorbing look at a town faced with a changing world.

9 likes1 stack add
review
JenHiga
post image
Pickpick

Finished this a week ago and I‘ve already recommended it to 3 people. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A close look at families affected by the 2008 closing of the GM factory that employed many in town. Listened to the audio book, which is how I like to consume non-fiction, and I heartily recommend the audio. It‘s an easy story to follow, compelling and straightforward. Sometimes heartbreaking but always respectful of the individuals and their choices. A great read!

review
Lauren_reading
post image
Pickpick

I can‘t even describe how good this book is. It covered so much about Janesville after the GM factory closed down. I loved and cried at the personal stories and still can‘t stand Paul Ryan. #nonfiction #audiobook

Reviewsbylola I already have this on my TBR. Sounds so good! 6y
JenReadsAlot It was so good - I live outside of Janesville.... 6y
69 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
JenReadsAlot
post image
Pickpick

Well written book. I have met a few former GM'ers that switched careers after the closing of this plant. I live right outside of Janesville.

Reviewsbylola This sounds so good. 7y
JenReadsAlot @Reviewsbylola It really was good - I hope you like it. 7y
peaKnit I‘m so glad to hear that the plant has been sold, somehow I think the reminder of it has to have been awful for former employees that haven‘t rebounded. (edited) 6y
24 likes2 stack adds4 comments
blurb
JenReadsAlot
post image

Ugh.. this is tough to relive... I was hit hard by Walker since I'm a county employee....

MayginReads Yeah, it really is. I lost my job because of Walkers attacks on public sector unions. That was the most divided I was over politics until Trump. I lost a decent number of Facebook friends with how things blew up with Walker, but most were people I went to school with and wasn't close to. The divisions after Trump have been more complicated. I give you props for reading this book. 7y
JenReadsAlot @MayginReads I lost one of my closest friends when that all went down with Walker as well. 7y
14 likes2 comments
review
WanderingBookaneer
post image
Pickpick

This Ode to a resilient town follows some of the middle class residents of the WI in the aftermath of the closing of the G.M. assembly plant that employed many residents. The book begins just before its closing in 2008 and follows the political and social drama that ensued as not just the people who worked in the plant, but the people who manufactured their car seats, as well as those who transported and cars to and from the train station. ⬇️

WanderingBookaneer We read about the people who did their best to help out the down and out residents like the teacher who provided basic necessities such as shampoo, deodorant, clothing and shoes; the people who worked to educate the unemployed to find them better opportunities; and the small town politicians who tried to save the jobs first by offering incentives to G.M. so that they produced a different car in Janesville's plant and then by offering ⬇️ 7y
WanderingBookaneer permits to refurbish the building and turn in into a different manufacturer.

Paul Ryan weaves in and out of the narrative as Janesville is his hometown. Personally, I was in shock at the abysmal treatment his constituents received and appalled that the state voted Republican in the 2016 elections. It is beyond me how the Republicans take so many social programs away from these communities and don't lose more of their base.
7y
DivaDiane I grew up in nearby Madison, Wisconsin and was shocked when I heard about the plant closing. 7y
See All 8 Comments
JenReadsAlot I live right outside of Janesville. 😔 need to read this.... 7y
MayginReads As a political scientist/ psychologist, I could rant a lot about this, but this isn't the place to do that. What I will say is that there was analysis done to show that the new voters ID laws in WI accounted for the entire amount Hilary lost by in WI. There were stories of people being turned away from the polls because they didn't have the proper ID and this happened primarily in Milwaukee, which is more Dem than the rest of the state. 7y
Leftcoastzen @MayginReads You nailed it.So sick of certain media going on and on about voter fraud when it‘s clear we have a voter suppression problem. 7y
WanderingBookaneer @MayginReads : 🤦🏻‍♀️ I can‘t believe I didn‘t think of voter suppression. 7y
MayginReads @WanderingBookaneer It's not a story that was well covered, which is unfortunate. WI went from having some of the most open voter laws to some of the most restrictive and then did a poor job of explaining to people what they needed. I myself wasn't sure what the laws were and I've been in politics my whole career. It's frustrating that this wasn't covered because this is something that we can change and is inherently racist and classist. 7y
89 likes8 comments
blurb
Zelma
post image

In the midst of reshuffling and organizing all of my bookshelves this weekend, I finally made a library-only shelf. It sits right next to one of my reading chairs and will keep things a bit less cluttered. #shelfie

blurb
WanderingBookaneer
post image

#MiaCat is not going to allow me to add this book to my #BuJo #LitsyAtoZ #CatsOfLitsy

TongueTiedSLP11 Hahahhaha. That‘s hysterical. Your cat looks like one of my cats! 7y
117 likes1 comment
blurb
WanderingBookaneer
post image

My view from the stationary bike as I listen to this book. #BonBonCat #CatsOfLitsy #PayItForward

julesG 😹😹😹 7y
Bookishgal71 She clearly has no intention of getting on your bike 7y
Tanzy13 🐱 7y
See All 10 Comments
LeahBergen 😂😂 7y
rubyslippersreads "Draw me like one of your French girls, Jack." ? 7y
Bookladylinda 😂😂 7y
CoffeeCatsBooks Lol! 😹😹 7y
Bookzombie 😂😂 7y
ladym30 Lovely! 7y
Sungirl79 😂😂😂😂 7y
151 likes10 comments
blurb
peaKnit
post image

Reading a book about the closure of the GM plant near my home town and just getting to the part where the new governor attacks the State workers (me) when this came up on my FB feed. 8 years ago. It was Bitter. It‘s been hard but good to read about more of the story. My dad lost his long held UNION dairy job in 1990, he was only 43, but he only knew dairy for 24 years. He took less pay, 3rd shift, an hour away...so overall this is a tough one. 💔

JenReadsAlot Look at you guys! 7y
LauraBrook Go you!!! My neighbors were there too, and I wish I knew they were going - I wanted to come along! Props for reading this book, I don‘t know if I could handle it emotionally. 7y
peaKnit @LauraBrook thanks! This is a tougher read...closer to home, than I expected. Janesville took such a hit, it is good to see more of the big picture. At the time I was more focused on my own frustrations 🤨 7y
26 likes1 stack add3 comments
blurb
Zelma
post image

A very cozy morning here with rain and gloom outside. We have jorums of coffee ( @KVanRead 😆) and books and a very snuggly Doggie in his dapper sweater. Then dinner and Settlers on Catan with friends tonight. Yay!

BookMaven407 Nice sweater! 👍 7y
Bette Seriously GREAT mug. ☕️ 7y
SandyW Thanks for the new vocabulary word... now, what does the mug mean? 7y
See All 8 Comments
Zelma @SandyW you are very welcome. I love this word! And the mug is the Dewey Decimel classification number for coffee. 😉 (edited) 7y
SandyW That is excellent! ☕ Although, I personally prefer tea. 7y
Zelma @SandyW there has to be a tea version out there. I can‘t imagine it doesn‘t exist. (I wish I liked tea, but alas, no matter how many types I‘ve tried, it‘s only coffee for me.) 7y
SandyW I googled the # for tea. It's 641.3372 - seems fitting that it comes before coffee as it existed long before coffee. Love this but of trivia. Tx 7y
Zelma @SandyW that makes total sense! 👍 7y
72 likes2 stack adds8 comments
blurb
Hoopiefoot
post image

Saturday morning vibes. That mug is ridiculous but it‘s also the biggest one we‘ve got so it‘s my weekend go-to.

britt_brooke Love your mug! 7y
MaureenMc Miss Piggy is the best! 7y
Morr_Books Never heard of this book. Lived in Janesville for a little while when I was a kid. Definitely feel like I need to read this. 7y
86 likes3 stack adds3 comments
blurb
Zelma
post image

Drinking coffee out of my new mug from @LeshaMac , reading, and watching Groundhog Day this morning.

SilversReviews Nice mug 7y
Zelma @SilversReviews I barely had to refill it today. It‘s huge! 😍 7y
SilversReviews @Zelma 😍😍😍😍😍😍 7y
See All 8 Comments
LeshaMac 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜❣ 7y
Mitch Just ordered this book. I‘ve committed to one non fiction book a month - think this one is for March! 7y
Zelma @Mitch I like it but I am finding it only want to read small snippets at a time. It has really short chapters that make that easier though. 7y
Mitch I had a feeling it might tug emotionally on me - so I‘ll take your advice and read slowly! 7y
Zelma @Mitch the organization works really well for that. It‘s also the book I was hoping Detroit by Charlie Laduff would have been. 7y
54 likes8 comments
review
DocBrown
post image
Pickpick

Basically a long news feature. No analysis, just description of one WI town that could be the subject of a Springsteen song. Events depicted are recent and familiar to anyone following the news. More interesting are the stories of individual residents whose lives are upended by the closing of several large plants in town, including GM‘s truck assembly. What do you do when all the jobs disappear and you can‘t sell your house, or don‘t want to move?

14 likes1 stack add
review
Lissa00
post image
Pickpick

Janesville, Wisconsin had a proud tradition of GM auto workers, until one day the plant closed leaving thousands out of work. This is a common story but one that I have not seen explored to the depth that Goldstein does with this book, focusing on the daily tribulations of a handful of families and community leaders affected by the closure. This is not about happy endings but about endurance, survival and the resilience of a community.

109 likes3 stack adds
blurb
Eggs
post image

During the 2008 recession, GM shut down a large number of plants in the US, most notably the one in Janesville WI. This is the story of its aftermath, from 2010-2015; written by WaPo reporter Amy Goldstein. It's more like textbook style, but with great data graphics at the end. It's good but it is no American Fire....

67 likes2 stack adds
review
Christine
post image
Pickpick

I flew through this well-written look at economic and social problems (and their political connections and implications) in a small Wisconsin town. Not the most uplifting of books with which to start 2018, but definitely a good read! My mom was a teacher in Janesville in her younger years, so that was another big point of interest for me. Loved how the author grounded her narrative in the experiences of families in the town, with much compassion.

peaKnit I just bought this. I was born in Janesville, but moved 25 miles northish when I was school aged. GM was such an institution, it was devastating when it left. I look forward to reading it after your thoughts. (edited) 7y
Christine @peaknit Oh good! I think you‘ll be moved by it for sure. I was, despite growing up a good ways north in Neenah and not having lived in WI for years. The way she portrayed the culture really resonated with me, though, so I felt a lot of connection to and sympathy for the workers and families. Looking forward to your review! ❤️ 7y
JenReadsAlot I live outside of Janesville so really need to read this soon! 7y
See All 6 Comments
Christine @JenReadsAlot Oh wow, yes you do! Really looking forward to hearing what you think of it, like I just said to @peaknit . It is a heartbreaker, though. 🙁 (edited) 7y
peaKnit My dad lost a union job he had for 24 years when I was a freshman in college, so I can relate to what those folks may have felt at GM anyways, the "what do we do now?" feeling, it was tough to watch, so it could be an emotional read. (edited) 7y
Christine @peaknit Wow yes, you can relate - so sorry he and your family had to go through that! My dad was able to make it through layoffs to retirement from his union factory job only by taking a lower paying job at his company. I‘ll admit my parents shielded me from a lot of the details of that - not so for some of the teens in this book. 7y
61 likes7 stack adds6 comments
review
cathysaid
post image
Pickpick

Good start to 2018 with this book 👍 After reading about the experiences of those in this small WI town that were devastated by a GM plant closing in the late 2000s, I have a deeper understanding of recent election results. And how empathy, rather than political divisiveness, might lead us to some peace. Had I been living in such a town, I would have felt quite conflicted as to my vote. Highly recommended. 4.5/5 ⭐️ #nonfiction

cathysaid If you're interested in this topic of how the shift from manufacturing to other industries impacts our economy and communities, as well as how the negative impacts of this shift have engendered a sense of despair, then I also recommend George Packer's Unwinding. 7y
Christine I just started this one today! My mom used to be a teacher in Janesville, and I have many friends and family in WI who have been directly or indirectly affected by similar economic and cultural issues - I specifically hoped this book would help me empathize more with their political views/actions - sounds like it will fit the bill! 7y
Eggs On my tbr 7y
See All 6 Comments
cathysaid @Christine It's an eye-opening read. Hope you like it! 7y
cathysaid @Eggs Hope you like it! 7y
Christine Wow, what timing - I literally just posted about it! I thought it was very well done. 7y
53 likes2 stack adds6 comments
blurb
MallenNC
post image

I had a ten dollar coupon I had to use by the end of the month, so of course I was very frugal and only bought one book. Ha ha! Like that would ever happen with me. Here's the damage. All nonfiction, so I've got new options for #nonfiction2018 challenge. #bookhaul #tbr

MallenNC @Riveted_Reader_Melissa Thanks for the nonfiction inspiration 7y
Riveted_Reader_Melissa @MallenNC I got a Thanks and not a blame Melissa! 😂 you are so welcome! 7y
MallenNC @Riveted_Reader_Melissa I love an excuse to buy a book or six. 7y
See All 6 Comments
JenReadsAlot I live by Janesville so really need to read this one. 7y
MallenNC @JenReadsAlot I picked it bc @Kelly put it on her best books list for the year, along with Nomadland, which I already read and loved. 7y
cathysaid Reading Janesville right now. Quite interesting. 7y
32 likes6 comments
blurb
mrdavidcharles
post image

Compassionate and sobering. The story of what happens to a middle class US town when the auto industry it's built on disappears. Highly recommended for readers interested in history and business.

blurb
My_novel_obsession
post image

Saw this was only 2.99 in Kindle. It‘s been on my wishlist forever so had to get it. @BookishMarginalia @WanderingBookaneer I think we talked about this one, but I can‘t remember which one you had on the table that was similar to this?

45 likes2 stack adds1 comment
blurb
booklover76

Why does the author keep referring to the jobs center as the former Kmart building? The first time was ok. I am half way through the book and she is still doing it

review
Jana
Pickpick

This book is sad, eye opening, frustrating, maddening, inspirational, and every emotion you can think of. Amy Goldstein immersed herself in this town and legit cares for it and the people and it shows in her writing and careful portrayal. It's a very political story but she does a phenomenal job of removing her biases. This a fascinating look at what happened during the Recession and afterwards and for me, is on par with Matthew Desmond's Evicted.

Erynecki Just finished it and agree with you 100%, particularly the comment about the connections to Evicted. 7y
5 likes1 stack add1 comment
blurb
Erynecki
post image

Spent part of my day reading the first bit of Janesville.

Update - This reminds me a lot of Evicted - the whole idea that stability and community depend upon outside factors beyond individual family choices. It's a long form journalism look at how the closing of the GM plant had a wide ranging impact on the Janesville community. Definitely an important and interesting read.

blurb
Kelly
post image

Janesville is the city nearest me so of course, I need to read this.

rubyslippersreads 😻😻😻 7y
JenReadsAlot Where do you live? I'm outside of Janesville as well and have not seen this... 7y
See All 7 Comments
Kelly @JenReadsAlot im near lake geneva, you? 7y
JenReadsAlot Near Milton. Is this any good? 7y
Kelly @JenReadsAlot yes!! I'd recommend it. I'm half way through and the writing is excellent. It's not perfect -- a lot of glossing over issues of race -- but a good picture of what happened to Janesville after GM. 7y
JenReadsAlot I'll check it out. Thanks! 7y
23 likes2 stack adds7 comments
review
Floresj
post image
Pickpick

This book bridged the WI I left 20 years ago to the WI that exists today. Empathetic writing of all sectors of Janesville that showed the impact of GM closing in a community that was based on the auto industry. The education sections were surprising and me reconsider some of my beliefs. Unions, Paul Ryan, Walker, education, business recruiting, and nonprofits were written about objectively and proved just how complex society is. Superb.

review
lauralovesbooks1
post image
Pickpick

Interesting look at what happened in Janesville after GM decided to close their factory. I learned a lot about how the effects of the closing rippled through the community in both predictable and surprising ways. I was hoping for insight into factors that impacted the election, but I didn't find that here.

15 likes2 stack adds
review
Sunflowery
Pickpick

4 stars - With our family's personal connection to Janesville, I found this book moving in so many ways. All the feels! The writing was very well-done.

quote
SconsinBookyBadger
post image

Television crews from as far away as the Netherlands and Japan have come to film this moment, when the oldest plant of the nation's largest automaker turns out its last.

So the closing of the assembly plant, two days before Christmas, is well recorded.

This is the story of what happens next.

#lifeaftergm

2 likes1 stack add
blurb
Hooked_on_books
post image

Well, I was planning on not buying any books (other than #BOTM) because of #summersantagoespostal, but how could I not celebrate World Book Day? The only bookstore near me here on vacation is Barnes and Noble, so here's my #bookhaul today! Definitely some Litsy influence here!

Cinfhen What better way to celebrate 🎉 buying books!!! Seems appropriate 😃 8y
Reviewsbylola I loved If I Stay and Thirteen Reasons Why. They are both very heavy! 8y
Zelma California is really interesting. 👍 8y
83 likes3 comments
review
RivendellMom
post image
Pickpick

Just finished this and I still have tears in my eyes. What a mostly heartbreaking uniquely American story. It takes so much courage to reinvent yourself again and again while supporting a family. Full review on my blog next week.

9 likes2 stack adds
blurb
Rhondareads

An intimate look at what happens to a small town when the factory that was the towns main employer shuts down.Told from the point of view of the people of the town by Amy Goldstein a Pulitzer Prize winning author.Sounds fascinating &very timely.

10 likes1 stack add