Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Cloisters
Cloisters | Katy Hays
The Secret History meets Ninth House in this sinister, atmospheric novel following a circle of researchers as they uncover a mysterious deck of tarot cards and shocking secrets in New York's famed Met Cloisters. When Ann Stilwell arrives in New York City, she expects to spend her summer working as a curatorial associate at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Instead, she finds herself assigned to The Cloisters, a gothic museum and garden renowned for its medieval art collection and its group of enigmatic researchers studying the history of divination. Desperate to escape her painful past, Ann is happy to indulge the researchers' more outlandish theories about the history of fortune telling. But what begins as academic curiosity quickly turns into obsession when Ann discovers a hidden 15th-century deck of tarot cards that might hold the key to predicting the future. When the dangerous game of power, seduction, and ambition at The Cloisters turns deadly, Ann becomes locked in a race for answers as the line between the arcane and the modern blurs. A haunting and magical blend of genres, The Cloisters is a gripping debut that will keep you on the edge of your seat.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
blurb
MaleficentBookDragon
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

I have a bit of a book hangover after So Thirsty and Clown in a Cornfield 3 before that.
I want to stay in the spooky season but I don‘t want slasher or black comedy right now.
Which of these two would you suggest?
Or go completely rogue and suggest a good spooky read.
#hauntedshelf
#blackcatcrew

Ruthiella The Silent Companions was pretty spooky. 4w
Karisa I just recommended The Silent Companions to someone else too. Creepy and so good! 4w
BookwormAHN I haven't read The Silent Companions yet but The Cloisters was really creepy and good 🐈‍⬛ 4w
46 likes3 comments
review
Meshell1313
Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Mehso-so

My first #readyourkindle pick this month was not what I expected- I thought it was going to be more of a fantasy but it seemed more of a mystery. No real supernatural elements. The best part was the setting of the Cloisters. I did not like our FMCs either. This one definitely fell a little short. ⭐️⭐️⭐️

CBee Sorry it wasn‘t a better read! On to the next 🤷‍♀️😂 1mo
54 likes1 comment
blurb
BookwormAHN
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

Thanks for the tag @MaleficentBookDragon 😺
1- New Orleans Museum of Art
2- The Cloisters
I tag @CaliforniaCay @Blerdgal_Fenix @dabbe
#Two4Tuesday @TheSpineView

dabbe I already did it; thanks for the tag! 😘 2mo
TheSpineView Love art museums. Thanks for playing 2mo
Blerdgal_Fenix I love a good museum visit 2mo
36 likes1 stack add3 comments
blurb
DebinHawaii
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

Thank you the #Two4Tuesday tag @TheSpineView & @MaleficentBookDragon 🤗

1️⃣ I have lots of favorite museums but The Cloisters in New York City holds a special place in my heart even though I have only visited it once. The setting, structure, gardens, galleries & even the restaurant, just draw me in.

2️⃣ This book was a light pick for me based on the atmospheric Cloisters setting.

TheSpineView You're welcome and thanks for playing! 2mo
39 likes1 comment
review
Laughterhp
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

I‘m not sure I knew what this book was actually supposed to be about… but I thought it was going to be a different story. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Low pick.

blurb
DebinHawaii
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

Playing catch-up with #StorySettings prompts

I had the opportunity to visit the art galleries in The Cloisters years ago, so I thought of this book for the #ArtGallery prompt. 🖼️

StaceGhost I really loved the Cloisters! I just got another which reminds me of it a bit— The Fortune Sellers 6mo
DebinHawaii @StaceGhost I will have to check that one out! 🤗 6mo
Eggs How magically beautiful and unique✨ Excellent choice👏🏻 6mo
See All 6 Comments
RobES Love this 💙 6mo
lynneamch It does feel like a magical place. . . And unicorns 🦄 6mo
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks Beautiful 💙💛 6mo
57 likes1 stack add6 comments
review
VanessaCW
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Mehso-so

I found this book disappointing. I think it‘s trying to be something it‘s not. I quite enjoy a slow burner but this one dragged a bit for me. It didn‘t flow. The tarot card elements were interesting although I don‘t believe in all that stuff. The characters weren‘t particularly likeable. It just goes to show you shouldn‘t judge a book by its cover and this book‘s cover is certainly eye catching. It lured me in!

Suzze Seems like you‘re in the majority. I liked it! It was very different from my normal read (mystery/thriller). 7mo
27 likes1 comment
blurb
VanessaCW
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

I‘m reading this with my online book group, thereadingloft.groups.io.

17 likes1 stack add
quote
Sharpeipup
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

“I don‘t know what will become of my life,” I said. “And I‘m the one living it.”

📸 The Met
Selection of tarot cards within their collection

https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/475513

29 likes1 stack add
review
DebinHawaii
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

#ReadAway2024 #FabulousFebruary #20in4

I finished my 3rd book for the #Roll100 challenge (#44) On my #BOTM stack, I‘m glad I finally got to it. It‘s a lighter pick for me. I loved the setting of The Cloisters. I was in NYC in 2008 & we spent the day there (my first & only time seeing it) & I loved how atmospheric it was & thought the author captured that well. The arts, antiquities & academic aspects were interesting as was the tarot card ⬇️

DebinHawaii …details. It did drag a bit in the set up & I wished I liked the MC or any of the characters more. Still overall, it held my interest & had me Googling more information on multiple subjects, so while not a favorite of the month, still a pick . 9mo
DieAReader 🥳Great 9mo
48 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
Itchyfeetreader
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

One to sit with for a while. The museum setting was fabulous and the tension and angst running through the hot summer added to the gothic feel. The storyline, tarot cards, divination and more could have been great but for the characters. Ann, the main protagonist is beyond bland and all the relationships and interactions felt forced and 2 dimensional. I ended up not caring as much as I could for either the mystery or the people

Caroline2 Yeah, this one just missed the mark for me too. 9mo
Itchyfeetreader @caroline2 I wanted to love it but I just didn‘t in the end ! 9mo
57 likes2 comments
review
Soubhiville
Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

A mystery set in a lesser known art museum in NYC featuring antiquities and tarot? Yes please!

There were some reveals I was pretty surprised by, quite a few characters I really didn‘t trust, and it made me want to check out this museum, The Cloisters, with it‘s gardens full of toxic plants that have in the past been used medicinally. I enjoyed this one. 🙂

BennettBookworm This museum is a true gem! And the gardens are the best part 11mo
78 likes7 stack adds1 comment
review
TracyReadsBooks
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

A solid debut about friendship, rivalry, ego, obsession, set at a small museum/garden in NYC where there is always more going on than anyone really knows. Rejected from every graduate program she applied to, Ann Stilwell is relieved to get a job working at The Cloisters for the summer. When she makes an important discovery, opportunity beckons & she has to decide just how far she‘ll go to get to the top. An entertaining read.

blurb
TracyReadsBooks
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

Started this one a couple of days ago…so far it‘s entertaining.

GondorGirl I really enjoyed this one! 12mo
31 likes1 comment
blurb
Charityann
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

Reading this one today!📖 #scarathlon #teamBOOklovers @Bookwormjillk

Bookwormjillk Like the cover 13mo
Ruthiella Cute pup! ❤️🐶 13mo
GondorGirl I really enjoyed this book... and love your dog! 13mo
Gissy 🐶🐾🐾🖤🖤🖤 13mo
38 likes4 comments
review
CampbellTaraL
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Bailedbailed

Got about 16% in and just couldn't continue. Partly the skeezy dude path, partly the podunk awkward girl idolizing the rich pretty girl cliche, this wasn't for me.

review
kimmypete1
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

I really enjoyed this! A little twist at the end that I didn‘t see coming at all.

review
BirdLaVie
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

Enchanting with its atmosphere and energy, I was drawn deeply into the magic and dark academia of The Cloisters! The entire novel hummed with a sort of spellbinding trance that matched its themes of oracle, desire, allure, power, and seduction. The steady plot, layers of environment and undertones, and quality environment makes this a perfect read for Fall 🍁🍂

review
kspenmoll
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Mehso-so

The Cloisters, its artifacts, & all the sensory elements of this space feels like a character in & of itself. No actual character grabbed me- the end I did not foresee, but even that did not evoke any emotion in me.
Any emotion I felt was for the museum itself The novel did asks questions about the role fate, fortune, choice,luck plays in our lives. #TBR #14books14weeks

TheAromaofBooks Great review!! 1y
61 likes1 comment
quote
kspenmoll
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

“ The Cloisters—it wasn‘t like the Metropolitan, where your eyes could rest. The entire space was the work.” —Ann
I visited the Cloisters once when I was in HS. Just reading a few pages of this novel makes me want to return & feast upon it‘s space & treasures.

52 likes1 stack add
blurb
kspenmoll
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

#Augustreads #2023
I am leaving for Acadia National Park tomorrow & going back to work 8/28 so this is ambitious for me!

wanderinglynn Enjoy! Acadia is in my travel wish list. 1y
47 likes1 comment
blurb
TheEllieMo
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

I am posting one book per day from my extensive to-be-read collection. No description and providing no reason for wanting to read it, I just do. Some will be old, some will be new. Don‘t judge me - I have a lot of books. Join in if you want!

#ABookADay2023

review
Caroline2
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

Disappointing. When I hear the words Dark Academia, it sets my expectations sky high. Which doesn‘t help. I liked the location but there wasn‘t enough atmosphere or interesting plot for me here. I found the tarot cards stuff frankly boring. At one point, she says that the history of tarot cards is often left out by historians… I think there‘s a reason for that!!! I liked the ending tho, good twist. 👍

marleed I read this a few months back and can‘t recall the story. What stays with me though is the actual physical place and gardens maintained with historic seeds. I want to visit those gardens! 1y
95 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
Ericalambbrown
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Mehso-so

This one wasn‘t as good as I‘d hoped it would be. The premise sounded fascinating but it just bumbled along for me. I wound up checking out the audiobook on Libby to get through the last half while harvesting and cleaning onions and garlic so I could get on to something else in a hurry.

54 likes1 stack add
blurb
Augustdana
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

Accidental book club strikes again. My friend and I may make it a witchy themed club.

19 likes1 stack add
blurb
perfectsinner
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

Checked this out yesterday from Libby.

review
AnnieMcC
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
Pickpick

Between so-so and pick. . . . . Wonderful descriptions and setting but I never fully felt the suspense and mystery. I think the characters, especially the narrator, were not developed enough so I didn't end up caring too much about any of them.

review
JaneyWaneyB
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Mehso-so

Set in The Cloisters of New York this is an atmospheric story of murder, mystery, the occult and academia. There was something missing...not sure whether it was pace, need for more incidents or intrigue but I felt a little deflated with each turning point in the book. There is a lack of drama & the story is delivered at one tone that doesn‘t change as the story progresses. Sadly, it offers a level of dullness like the main character Ann.

JaneyWaneyB The premise of the story is good, Hays has done her homework on the occult, especially tarot, which gives the story some weight. Sadly not a beautiful story as the cover. 2y
38 likes1 comment
review
Cazxxx
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

Libraries, tarot, botany and mystery. I was always going to love this one!
4 ⭐️

blurb
JaneyWaneyB
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
30 likes1 stack add
review
Cathyloves2read
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Mehso-so

In all honesty, I found parts of this book dull, and other parts fascinating. I loved reading about tarot cards and other forms of fortune telling. I also loved leading about The Cloisters in NYC. Its gardens sound beautiful. I‘m beginning to realize that thrillers aren‘t my go to genre. What thrills some seems to bore me. I do plan on visiting The Cloisters someday.

review
RachReads
Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

✨️I loved this book! The fate of a summer spent working at a gothic medieval museum. Renaissance art history, Greek/Roman mythology, poisonous plants, & tarot cards. The New York setting of parks, punk bars, the Adirondacks, and mentions of Tarrytown. This hit a lot of interests for me and gave an ending I wasn't expecting at all! I love a good shock & awe for a conclusion.🌿

7 likes2 stack adds
review
StaceGhost
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

The Cloisters was my favorite read this month! Lots of Terry Pratchett too though which was very cozy ✨

dabbe 💜 your sketches! 🤗 2y
35 likes1 comment
review
Melismatic
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Mehso-so

I‘ve never been to the Cloisters so I can‘t accurately speak of the atmospheric authenticity here - but this novel made me want to go. ⛪️

That being said though, this plot was snails pace, had little to offer, and wasn‘t even a real spooky mystery despite the ambiance. Even the POV character was a snore.

Photo above was taken at The Met.

review
BennettBookworm
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Mehso-so

So-so instead of pan because a) I live right next to the Cloisters and I enjoyed reading about a setting I know so intimately, and b) the last two pages were really well done.
Otherwise, I found the characters all deeply unlikeable and the central conflict just didn‘t hold enough weight for me. The plot felt really contrived and I skimmed a lot.
Tarot cards are now so mainstream that I also don‘t see how the story hinged on their “darkness.” 🧐

BennettBookworm I chose to highlight these two passages (they‘re not spoilers at all) because they connect to my love of studying art history and my love of living in NYC - two things that made me initially excited to read this book. Some insights to be had in an overall disappointing read. 2y
51 likes1 comment
review
Megbert
Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

A really fun ride through a young woman‘s journey as she shakes off some dark shadows and finds her feet in the world of art academia. Well researched and beautifully set in the NY Cloisters, it‘s no wonder it‘s been picked up for TV development. At times the story stumbled and fell a bit flat but the overall plot and setting carried it through. Look forward to seeing the adaptation.
(pic from the violet fox)

blurb
Lizpixie
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

The third in todays #BookMail is truly beautiful with raised gilding, gorgeous colours & sprayed edges. Not signed(bummer)but still worth it. Set in New York, it‘s about an art historian who moves there after getting a job at the Met. But she‘s assigned to the Cloisters, the Gothic museum & garden arm of the Met, full of medieval & renaissance art. Drawn into the circle there, she finds a once-lost 15thC Italian tarot deck & things heat up.

5feet.of.fury Beautiful edition! 2y
kspenmoll Stunning! 2y
45 likes2 comments
blurb
RaeLovesToRead
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

Mum let me have my books early 💕 I am so addicted to Waterstones Exclusive Editions!!! Aren't they beautiful? 🥰

#endpapers

Meshell1313 Oh so pretty! 2y
PathfinderNicole That one for The Cloisters is so freaking amazing 2y
Clare-Dragonfly Gorgeous!!! 2y
Branwen OH. MY. GOD! 😱 They're all absolutely gorgeous! 🥰💕😵‍💫 2y
74 likes4 comments
review
Palimpsest
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

I enjoyed this book about a woman named Ann who is hired to work at The Cloisters. I really love medieval history as well as tarot so I was pulled into the detail that the author included about the various items as well as the plants from the gardens.

review
KarenUK
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

I always love me some dark academia, and although this is no ‘Secret History‘ (what is?) I still really enjoyed this NYC story. The Met Cloisters, a museum specializing in Medieval artifacts, is the perfect eerie setting, and the study at the center of this novel is of divination and historical tarot cards. Secrets are in abundance, a fish is most definitely out of water, and motives are endlessly questionable. Twisty, atmospheric and lots of fun.

See All 10 Comments
LeeRHarry Good to know this is good one as I have it on my TBR- love the cover 😊 2y
Cinfhen What an awesome review you wrote!!! You made me want to read a book I wasn‘t at all interested in!!!! #SuperReviewer ❤️🙌🏻 2y
squirrelbrain I‘ve wondered about this one but thought it wasn‘t my ‘thing‘…you‘ve made me change my mind. Stacked. 2y
KarenUK @squirrelbrain @cinfhen It‘s kind of a mash up of gothic dark academia and a mystery/thriller. I thought it was a lot of fun 😊 2y
Cortg Sounds like a great read! 2y
Bluebird Great review! Sounds like something I‘d like. Stacked! 2y
61 likes10 stack adds10 comments
blurb
KarenUK
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

Just starting this one…. Trying to catch up on my endless #ARCs ! 🤦‍♀️
Feeling good about this so far… Dark Academia is usually totally my thing. 💕

Ruthiella I‘ve heard good things about this. The premise is intriguing! 2y
60 likes2 stack adds1 comment
review
kezzlou85
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
This post contains spoilers
show me
post image
Mehso-so

This was an interesting premise and the location draws you in but the story fell a little flat. It was a very slow build and it was obvious early on who killed Patrick. I did like the twist of Ann's reasons for coming to the cloisters. The ending was well done though I had guessed about what might have happened to Rachel. A gothic read. #Netgaley 3*l

Palimpsest Spoilers! Wish I hadn‘t read review as I‘m 1/3 in and didn‘t know who was going to be murdered. 2y
Palimpsest Just so you know there is a spoiler button you can select so you don‘t ruin a book for someone next time. 😔 2y
kezzlou85 @Palimpsest sorry I didn't think it was a spoiler as I didn't reveal the ending or identity. Will be more careful next time. 2y
Palimpsest @kezzlou85 it was somewhat my own fault as I usually wait to read reviews, but I just came on litsy to add that I was currently reading it and noticed the book only had a 55% like so I scrolled down to see a bit to see why people found it meh. I usually don‘t read murder mysteries, but I love the Middle Ages & Renaissance periods in history as well as tarot and dark academia, so I‘m enjoying those details. Thanks for adding the spoilers tab! 2y
kezzlou85 I'm the same. I try to avoid too many reviews. I do love my murder mysteries and usually who dies is quite obvious but not in this case. I'm usually careful not to give anything away but I slipped up on this one. Thanks for letting me know. 2y
48 likes5 comments
blurb
lynneamch
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image

Lots more than just one #secret here. Not all littens agree, but I'm enthralled so far. It's so fun to read about places you've been. I'm about halfway through, where Ann & Rachel are at the Morgan #Library. Pics are from my visit last March. #JanuaryJazz #NYC @Eggs @Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks

Eggs Awesome 👏🏻 2y
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks Beautiful 😍 2y
42 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
Skeeterisme
Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

😳😳😳

BookwormM Just started this one so far I love the writing 2y
62 likes1 comment
review
bridge12
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Panpan

Ok, I had to put my puppy Jethro to sleep on Sunday and this book was an affront on every aspect of my life.

I was SO excited to read this book, however, the plot was subpar, the characters were obnoxious (not in a good read way), and the dialect felt like if a 3 year old wrote it. Do not recommend 2⭐️ #botm

Cuilin Oh no,I was really hoping this would be good. I visited the Cloisters for the first time in August and was looking forward to this. 😞 2y
14 likes1 comment
review
Kboltz
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

Loved this first novel by Katy Hays. Anne gets an internship at the Met in NYC. She is learning how to live away from home and is immersed in the history of tarot cards. I love that I had to look up items that I didn‘t know and the ending is perfect. Fate and fortune are part of life.

16 likes1 stack add
review
candc320
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Pickpick

This was a quick, interesting - if not overly complicated - audiobook. The characters weren‘t particularly likable and the main character was surprisingly gullible and went along with more than I would think a supposedly super intelligent person would fall for. However it does have a somewhat unique premise and interesting use of tarot cards and kept me listening until the end. 🌟🌟🌟

21 likes1 stack add
review
brittanyreads
The Cloisters | Katy Hays
post image
Panpan

2⭐
Right..so..I thoroughly enjoyed all my art history classes in college, I love museums, and I am enthralled with anything relating to the history of the occult..this book is all those things but somehow I was SO bored.
The characters stink and the thinly veiled mystery was so obvious.
💯 dud 👎
Any recs for atmospheric, dark academia that features intelligent characters and an actual plot?

I do want to visit the actual Met Cloisters, though!

swishandflick Have you read Donna Tartt's The Secret History? 2y
brittanyreads @swishandflick I haven't, but I own a copy!! Maybe I should prioritize it in 2023! 2y
swishandflick @BrittanyReads You def should!! Based on what you felt like you were missing here, I have a feeling you'll enjoy it! It's on my favorites shelf 😄 2y
brittanyreads @swishandflick Ooh! Thanks!! 2y
40 likes5 comments