Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Maud: A Novel Inspired by the Life of L.M. Montgomery
Maud: A Novel Inspired by the Life of L.M. Montgomery | Melanie J. Fishbane
38 posts | 14 read | 56 to read
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
review
BarbaraJean
post image
Mehso-so

Catching up on a belated review of this #KindredSpiritsBuddyRead! This YA historical fiction based on L.M. Montgomery‘s teen years felt a bit lacking for me. Of course the author had to work within the events of Maud‘s life, but I thought the narrative needed a bit more shaping or different framing, to make it more of a cohesive whole—as well as more depth of characterization all around. Similarly, the ending felt abrupt and a bit unfinished.⤵️

BarbaraJean (Continued) Also, as I read, I kept trying to match up the narrative with what I knew of LMM‘s life, and I was distracted by wondering what was elaboration or invention. That‘s more my own issue rather than the writing, but it was one reason this didn‘t quite work for me, at least not as well as other historical fiction I‘ve read. It was interesting overall, but not as satisfying as I‘d hoped! 1y
41 likes1 stack add1 comment
blurb
BarbaraJean
post image

#KindredSpiritsBuddyRead - Maud discussion part 5

Do you think the story works on its own, without previous knowledge of LMM‘s books and/or her life? Would you have enjoyed the book without the reader having any context on LMM and her writing? (Or is the connection to LMM kind of the point?!)

BarbaraJean I don‘t think this really worked for me as a standalone. No doubt the author is a bit constrained by the events of Maud‘s life, but I thought the narrative needed a bit more shaping or different framing, to make it more of a cohesive whole, and for it to work as its own story. Similarly with the ending—it felt abrupt and a bit unfinished. But then I have difficulty faulting the book for that, because of course it‘s not the end of Maud‘s life! 1y
lauraisntwilder I think I would've enjoyed it less if I hadn't read House of Dreams. 1y
16 likes2 comments
blurb
BarbaraJean
post image

#KindredSpiritsBuddyRead - Maud discussion part 4

You could argue that Maud has three main loves in this book: Nate Lockhart, Will Pritchard, and her dreams of education and a writing career.
What are some of the similarities and differences in Maud‘s relationships with Nate and Will?
What did you think of how the book depicts Maud‘s ambitions and the role writing plays in her life?

blurb
BarbaraJean
post image

#KindredSpiritsBuddyRead - Maud discussion part 3

What did you think of the way Maud‘s family relationships were portrayed: Maud‘s grandparents, Father and Mrs. Montgomery, her aunts and cousins? What other relationships stuck out to you as particularly formative for Maud (besides Nate and Will… they get their own question!)

BarbaraJean When reading House of Dreams, I was struck by the support LMM received from her grandmother, even though her grandmother didn't seem sympathetic. I liked seeing that represented here & really liked the way Fishbane showed moments of connection between the two, like with the Commonplace Book. The conversations with Aunt Annie and Aunt Emily also stood out to me, especially the parallels with Aunt Emily taking care of Maud after her mother died.

1y
13 likes1 comment
blurb
BarbaraJean
post image

#KindredSpiritsBuddyRead - Maud discussion part 2

I wasn‘t aware that LMM was influenced by Alcott and Little Women, but I enjoyed the references within the novel, and the connections that Fishbane draws out. What connections do you see between Little Women and LMM‘s life and/or her books?

BarbaraJean I came across this post about the connections between the two authors and their work—I found the comparison between the two proposals particularly interesting!
https://www.anneofgreengables.com/blog-posts/lucy-maud-montgomery-and-louisa-may...
1y
lauraisntwilder I've always thought Anne and Jo had a lot in common, regardless of their family backgrounds--the desire to write, unwanted proposals, needing to be told to write what they knew, etc. I've actually never read Little Women (to my shame), so I'm basing this off adaptations. 1y
BarbaraJean @lauraisntwilder I've only read Little Women once, and it was over 15 years ago, so my memory of the book is a little tenuous! But the commonalities you mentioned all ring true, and a lot of them are parallels to Maud herself, I think. I see those same threads in the Emily books, too. Fishbane brings out the “write what you know“ theme with Maud, and both Maud and Jo prioritize writing over marriage as well. 1y
11 likes3 comments
blurb
BarbaraJean
post image

#KindredSpiritsBuddyRead - Maud discussion part 1

Maud is a work of fiction, and the author is quick to point out that it‘s not a biography. Did the book work for you as historical fiction? Or was it distracting to wonder what was biographical and what was fictional?

BarbaraJean I couldn‘t help but compare this book to House of Dreams and The Alpine Path, trying to match up the narrative with what I knew of LMM‘s life. I was distracted by trying to figure out what was elaboration or invention. Because of that (and maybe other reasons), it didn‘t quite work for me, at least not as well as other historical fiction I‘ve read. 1y
BarbaraJean The author noted that LMM‘s own autobiographical work (Alpine Path and her journals) was clearly curated and selectively presented (even her journals seem to have an audience in mind). I find it interesting when it‘s the author who‘s editing the presentation of their own life—but with this book, I found it difficult to enjoy the story on its own terms. Is it just me, or did other people have the same issue? 1y
lauraisntwilder I was okay with as fiction, but I did think the author leaned too much into telling us how everyone felt, rather than showing. There were long sections of exposition without dialogue. It felt like she had a lot of material to cover and didn't always do it well. 1y
12 likes3 comments
review
lauraisntwilder
post image
Pickpick

I finished this one today for the #kindredspiritsbuddyread. I won't say too much ahead of our discussion, but I enjoyed this. Two thoughts -- 1, I wish there was a sequel covering Montgomery's adult life, and 2, the flowers on the cover should be lupines (this cover is pretty though).

BarbaraJean Yes to a sequel! Her years of college and teaching, and her early career, would be so interesting to read in a novelized form. 1y
23 likes1 comment
blurb
BarbaraJean
post image

Saturday reading for #KindredSpiritsBuddyRead! I‘m enjoying this but also finding it a bit stressful, knowing the difficulties that Maud‘s life contained. I just started the Prince Albert section and am worried about what‘s in store for Maud! How is everyone‘s reading going? I‘m looking forward to discussing this next week!

43 likes2 stack adds
blurb
LitsyEvents
post image

repost for @BarbaraJean:

#KindredSpiritsBuddyRead: Summer Edition! In June, we‘ll be reading Maud, YA historical fiction based on LMM‘s teenage years. Then we‘ll tackle Mary Henley Rubio‘s biography of LMM over July & August, with discussions at the midpoint and at the end of the book.

All are welcome—let me know if you‘d like to join in for either or both books!

#BuddyRead
original post:
https://www.litsy.com/web/post/2592644

blurb
BarbaraJean
post image

#KindredSpiritsBuddyRead: Summer Edition! In June, we‘ll be reading Maud, YA historical fiction based on LMM‘s teenage years. Then we‘ll tackle Mary Henley Rubio‘s biography of LMM over July & August, with discussions at the midpoint and at the end of the book.

I currently have @megnews @Bkwrm7 @lauraisntwilder and @Prairiegirl_reading on the tag list for Maud in June. All are welcome—let me know if you‘d like to join in for either or both books!

julieclair Please add me to the tag list for June! Thanks! 2y
BarbaraJean @julieclair I‘ve added you—great to have you on board for June! 2y
TheAromaofBooks I think I will be skipping in June, but will be back for the July/August read!! 2y
BarbaraJean @TheAromaofBooks 👍 I've got you down for Gift of Wings in July/August! 2y
36 likes4 comments
review
Ehbooklover
post image
Pickpick

I loved this well-researched fictional account about the teenage years of one of my favourite childhood authors. Reading it really opened my eyes as to how much of Montgomery's real life experiences became part of her fictional stories. Recommended for anyone who is a fan of the Anne of Green Gables series.

review
Kenyonbird
post image
Pickpick

I took this book with me on holiday to Prince Edward Island • I adore green gables and have always been fascinated by the story• I felt like I was getting to Know Lucy in this book .... Like it was a door to Anne. L.M Is a magical writer full of so much passion and such a natural with words. It was a fantastic book. I enjoyed every second . The author: Melanie Fishbane wrote it with love & care. What a beautiful story about a beautiful woman. ✌🏼️

MrBook Nice review! Welcome to @Litsy ! Just warning you now, you won't want to leave. 😆👏🏻 7y
RaimeyGallant Welcome to Litsy! 7y
RaimeyGallant What he said. ;) @MrBook 7y
See All 6 Comments
Kenyonbird Thank you @MrBook for the welcoming & good vibes ✌🏼️ 7y
Kenyonbird @RaimeyGallant thankyou ❤️ 7y
DebinHawaii Welcome to Litsy! 🎉📚👍😀 Hope you are enjoying it here! 7y
5 likes6 comments
review
Katpie1701
Pickpick

To sum it up in a word: charming. It started off a little shaky, with it feeling like the author was basically grafting Anne's personality onto L.M. Montgomery's life, but Maud grew and matured so much throughout the book that that didn't last long. It's a sweet comfort read, especially if you love Anne of Green Gables and want to get some insight into its creator. #bookreview #bibliophile #booknerd #historicalfiction #YA

blurb
Katpie1701
post image

I absolutely love Anne of Green Gables and have never seen any historical fiction focused on L.M Montgomery, so I am thrilled to be diving into this one! I've read mixed reviews so I hope I'm of the more positive persuasion, but I guess we'll wait and see!

quote
mayusteapot
post image

"Perhaps you'll become famous like Louisa May Alcott," he joked [...]
"I'll never be Alcott," she said...

1 stack add
review
ReadingSusan
post image
Panpan

This book enraged me. I hated it so much and I don't understand why it has such good reviews. Maud was so annoying and childish through the first half and the dialogue was just terrible. I hated the writing. If I had not paid full price for this book I would have bailed. This was a huge disappointment.

saresmoore Blurg. 8y
rubyslippersreads I liked it more than you did, but I was disappointed that Maud wasn't more like 8y
minkyb So sorry. 8y
87 likes3 comments
blurb
ReadingSusan
post image

Am I the only one who takes the dust jacket off the book to read it?

BarbaraJean Me too! I never read with the dust jacket on. It's only on when the book is on the shelf. 8y
CoverToCoverGirl Guilty! 😎 8y
Vexingcircumstance I do if I'm reading a book like that that isn't a library book (which is rare). The library here usually tapes them on. 8y
See All 24 Comments
merelybookish Always! Find dust jackets cumbersome when I read. 8y
Chelsey Always! 8y
Redwritinghood Nope. Sometimes they just drive me crazy and I take them off. 8y
drokka 👍👍 8y
Nat_Reads Always. They are so annoying!! Pretty but annoying. 8y
ErikasMindfulShelf I always take them off. 8y
BriKie I take them off but only because I want them to stay beautiful and unblemished. I would rather have them on. 8y
BookishBeth I take them off. A naked book feels better in my hands. 8y
xicanti Always, unless I'm reading a library hardcover where the dust jacket's been reinforced and taped onto the book. They get grotty and awful if I lug them around everywhere. 8y
Chasing_Pages Always off while reading them, then back on while on the shelf. I don't even let my friends borrow my books with the dust jackets on, they just know they're not allowed. Lol 8y
Sarah83 I put it off as well. 😉 8y
elkeOriginal Always! To keep them nice. 8y
pocketmermaid Most of the time I do, unless I want to show off what I'm reading! When I do remove them, I put a stretchable fabric cover over it so I don't get fingerprints on the cover. 8y
minkyb Usually my hardcovers are from the library and they have the plastic covering! 8y
mrp27 I always do, I don't want the cover to get grimy and it feels annoying in my hands. 8y
Cortg I always do...and so do my kids! 8y
ReadingSusan @BarbaraJean yeah it's just annoying to have it on! 8y
ReadingSusan @Vexingcircumstance yeah my library does that too. It's just when they slip around that it annoys me. It's fine if they are taped off. 8y
ReadingSusan @merelybookish me too! They always slip around. 8y
ReadingSusan @Chasing-Pages ha ha! I do the same. 8y
123 likes24 comments
blurb
ReadingSusan
post image

I have been so excited for this book! Love the epigraph!

saresmoore I look forward to your thoughts on this! 8y
Daisey I enjoyed it! 8y
91 likes2 comments
blurb
ReadingSusan
post image

I got this beauty in the mail yesterday from Amazon. I was so excited. Until I looked at it. Giant smudges over the cover and the dust jacket was rumpled and crinkly. So angry. I requested a replacement right away. I don't spend my hard earned money to get a less than perfect copy!

Oryx Same happened to me recently from amazon. Big greasy smudges. Got a replacement. 8y
ReadingSusan @Oryx so maddening. At least they are good about returns. 8y
Mccall0113 Yikes 8y
See All 12 Comments
Teafiend Disappointed with amazon lately! 8y
Lmstraubie That is very frustrating 😣 8y
janeycanuck Ugh... I had that with a book recently. Three copies sent, each more damaged than the last. After three, I just got a refund. 8y
ReadingSusan @janeycanuck that is terrible! 8y
ReadingSusan @Amyg3 it was packed in too big of a box with no wrapping. So ridiculous. 8y
ReadingSusan @Lmstraubie so frustrating. Luckily the new copy will get here tomorrow. 8y
LeahBergen 😠😠 8y
minkyb Very frustrating. Glad they made it right. 8y
kspenmoll Glad they did- i would do the same! 8y
83 likes3 stack adds12 comments
blurb
TirzahPrice
post image

I'm oh so thrilled for my friend Mel and the release of her YA novel MAUD, about the teenage years of LM Montgomery. This is a painstakingly researched labor of love that has the official approval of the Montgomery heirs. I've heard excerpts over the years and I'm just so happy that it exists in book form for everyone to read!

ReadingSusan Omg I am DYING to read this. 8y
moranadatter It's good to see you back! 8y
Bklover Hope things are going well for you. 8y
45 likes6 stack adds4 comments
blurb
Laura317
post image

"Next to marrying a cousin, marrying a Baptist is like going to the devil." Well, I never!! ?? guess I've gone to the devil. I married one of them Baptists! ???

rubyslippersreads LMM didn't think much of Methodists either. 😄 8y
Reecaspieces That's a hoot! 8y
Laura317 Good grief! Double whammy. A Methodist turned Baptist. I'm doomed. Doomed I tell ya! 8y
55 likes1 stack add3 comments
quote
BranCrisp
post image

2 likes1 stack add
review
Sarahthelibrarygirl
post image
Pickpick

Love love love love love. There were squeaks of delight, heart palpitations, and stomach butterflies involved in the reading of this book. I felt like I was in middle school again, which Is awesome, because my middle school self was pure of heart and soul. I got a distinctly Little House on the Prairie vibe from the second half that I wasn't expecting, but then again, I didn't know about Montgomery' time out west. 10/10 would recommend.

5 likes2 stack adds
blurb
Sarahthelibrarygirl
post image

You would never know that behind that orange blocked cover lies my kindle, now would you? I'm in love with this case made with traditional bookbinding techniques in England @klevercase endeavors to keep the magic and tradition of books alive in the digital age, and I LOVE it! #klevercase #infinitelibrary #bibliophile #bookstagram

blurb
Sarahthelibrarygirl
post image

In love with this book already! If you can please a hardcore Anne-fan, you're doing something right. #netgalley #arc

4 likes1 stack add
review
Daisey
post image
Pickpick

I truly enjoyed this historical fiction about a teenaged Lucy Maud Montgomery! It covers time spent living with her grandparents, going to live with her father, and coming back to her grandparents' home while dreaming of becoming a writer and continuously working towards more education along with some romance.

If you enjoy L.M. Montgomery's Anne of Grren Gables and her other books, I highly recommend this.
Available May 2017

#NetGalley #YA

43 likes1 stack add1 comment
blurb
JenlovesJT47
post image

Sooooo excited to read this!!!! I love Lucy Maud Montgomery, currently listening to Anne of Green Gables on audiobook. Yay! 📚🤓📚#NetGalley #ARC

blurb
Daisey
post image

Like many other posts I've seen today, I like tea (tonight it's acai green tea) and chocolate with my books!

#ReadJanuary

tpixie Yummy on all accounts! 8y
54 likes1 comment
blurb
Daisey
post image

I made it to 24 hours for the #24in48 readathon with 3 completed books, 1 completed audiobook, and an hour and a half to spare before midnight! The last hour or so was spent finishing my #CovertoCover book and a few more chapters of Maud.

Bookworm83 Great job!! 📚🎉📚🎉 8y
CherylDeFranceschi 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 8y
mhillis Impressive!! 8y
See All 15 Comments
SaturnDoo 🖒🖒🖒❤ 8y
saresmoore Woohoo! 8y
DebinHawaii Awesome!!! Great job! 🎉📚👍 8y
Megabooks 🎊🎊👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻📚👍🏻 8y
Simona Congrats 🎈🎊🍾🎉 8y
Eyelit Fantastic! 👏📚🎉 8y
TrishB Well done 😀🎉 8y
Readerann Way to go!! 8y
Graciouswarriorprincess Congratulations!! 8y
tpixie Wow! Great job! And you even had time for #LitsyBookClub! 8y
moranadatter Congrats!🎉 8y
53 likes15 comments
blurb
Daisey
post image

I went to meet up with friends for a while this evening. Now I'm back home with a book, a beverage, a cat on my lap, and the dog right beside me. It seems like the perfect way to end my day and get some more time in for #24in48.

DebinHawaii Perfect! 🐱❤️🐶👍 8y
Texreader Lovely! 8y
38 likes2 comments
blurb
LauraBeth
post image

Currently reading and loving 💕A novel inspired by the life of L.M Montgomery? Yes, please! Publish date is May 16. Also - this cover ❤#netgalley #24in48

Readbtwnlakes How did I not know this was coming?!?!?! So excited! 8y
GlitteryOtters @rubyslippersreads tagging you to make sure you see this post/know about this book (I feel like it might be easy to miss stuff this weekend with all of the readathon posts flying around!) 8y
Bookish.Heart What is this?? I never knew this even existed!!! 8y
See All 11 Comments
Lidia I want it! ❤️ 8y
Reviewsbylola I'm curious about this one. 8y
Cinfhen Gorgeous cover💞 8y
Eaclarke82 @SaturnDoo Ooh thanks think I'll have to read this one 8y
Daisey I'm almost halfway through and enjoying it! 8y
Laura317 I've got it in my NetGalley stack! 8y
rubyslippersreads @GlitteryOtters Thanks so much for tagging me. I did get a chance to read the book, but it's so easy to miss things, especially when @Litsy is extra-busy. I appreciate your thinking of me and my ❤ for LMM. 😊 8y
146 likes15 stack adds11 comments
blurb
Daisey
post image

#24in48 Intro Survey

blurb
Daisey
post image

Starting my day with a fresh baked apple scone and this novel about L.M. Montgomery!

#NetGalley #YA

Laura317 I've got that book from #NetGalley too. I look forward to reading your review. 8y
42 likes1 comment
quote
TirzahPrice
post image

A great line from the upcoming LMM YA novel!!

33 likes1 stack add
blurb
TirzahPrice
post image

My friend Mel has been working on this YA novel about Lucy Maud Montgomery's teen years for a very long time! I'm so excited that it's finally coming out this year!!!

LauraBeth 💕 the description! 8y
TirzahPrice @LauraBeth rawr autocorrect!!! 8y
ScorpioBookDreams Sounds great. Love Anne of Green Gables so can't wait to read this! 8y
MamaGina Beautiful cover design!🌷 8y
Bookish.Heart I'm so excited! I didn't know about this book until today!! 8y
34 likes1 stack add5 comments
blurb
Daisey
post image

I don't usually keep track of many release dates or even work to get a book when it's first published, so I don't really have an anticipated reads list. However, I'm a long time fan of L.M. Montgomery and just got access to this via Netgalley so I'm excited to start it soon!

#SeasonsReadings2016 #2017MostAnticipatedBooks #NetGalley

Reviewsbylola This looks good! 8y
Betty @Suzze are you aware of this book? 8y
Suzze @Betty No! I'm adding it right now. Thanks! 8y
LauraBeth This looks so awesome! 8y
46 likes8 stack adds4 comments
blurb
RivendellMom
post image

Using all my self control not to put down the Cybils to read this ARC. SQUEE!!!!

RivendellMom I've appeased myself by promising it as a book dessert for later today. 8y
saresmoore !!! I must read this! 8y
RivendellMom @saresmoore I know!! I gasped when I saw it. 8y
TirzahPrice I heard Melanie read an excerpt from this three years ago. I cannot wait for this book to be out! 8y
8 likes2 stack adds4 comments