Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Certain Dark Things
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
Certain Dark Things combines elements of Latin American mythology with a literary voice that leads readers on an exhilarating and fast-paced journey. Welcome to Mexico City, an oasis in a sea of vampires. Here in the city, heavily policed to keep the creatures of the night at bay, Domingo is another trash-picking street kid, just hoping to make enough to survive. Then he meets Atl, the descendant of Aztec blood drinkers. Domingo is smitten. He clings to her like a barnacle until Atl relents and decides to let him stick around. But Atl's problems, Nick and Rodrigo, have come to find her. When they start to raise the body count in the city, it attracts the attention of police officers, local crime bosses, and the vampire community. Atl has to get out before Mexico City is upended, and her with it. In 2015, Silvia's debut, Signal to Noise, was named on seven year's best lists: B&N's Sci-Fi & Fantasy Blog, RT, BookRiot, Buzzfeed, i09, Vice, and Tor.com. Certain Dark Things was also listed on B&N's Sci-Fi & Fantasy Blog as one of 42 books they can't wait to read in 2016 and on io9 as one of 40 Science Fiction and Fantasy Books That Will Rock Your World In 2016!
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
blurb
Jadams89
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

Thank you so much @Nazgul93 !!! I‘m so excited to cozy up with this bag of Reese‘s and start one of these books — but I can‘t decide which one! And I love the Beetlejuice bookmark! Thanks again!! #AHRS #AllHallowsReadSwap

LibrarianRyan Certain Dark things. I liked that one! 3w
Nazgul93 I'm glad you liked everything! Certain dark things is one of my favorite vampire books! I meant to write a note but totally forgot, sorry! And my mom said that Butcher & blackbird is really good! 3w
33 likes2 comments
review
MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Mehso-so

3 ⭐️s
This was going to be 5 ⭐️s with the unique lore and world building; the characters were so relatable and I was SO invested in them and their struggles. Then that ending comes and punches you right in the chest. I felt like the ending took away the whole point of the story. If there‘s ever a sequel, I will absolutely rush to snatch it up because I need closure. 😅🤣

review
Decalino
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

In this fascinating noirish novel, Domingo, a young man who scavenges trash in the vampire-free zone of Mexico City, gets caught up in a deadly war between rival vampire families when he meets Atl, a young vampire on the run. Atl is the descendent of high priestesses who defended Aztec temples, her enemies a gang of vicious newcomers. Unique and intriguing world-building, vivid characters and a distinctive setting made this an exceptional read.

booklover3258 I want to read all of her books! This will be my next one after Untamed Shore. 1mo
19 likes1 comment
blurb
Decalino
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

1. Not yet! I finally started putting decorations up yesterday.
2. Mexican vampire noir

#Two4Tuesday
@TheSpineView

TheSpineView Thanks for playing! Love vampire stories! 1mo
17 likes1 comment
blurb
jen_the_scribe
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

1. My name is Jenny and I‘m a writer lol.

2. Usually I‘m walking or running on the treadmill, cooking, folding laundry, or driving.

3. Last audiobook I finished is tagged!

#WondrousWednesday @Eggs

Eggs Thanks for playing 💜🩵💙 4mo
22 likes1 comment
review
jen_the_scribe
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

I really enjoyed this one. It took a while for there to be any real action, and while that usually causes me to disengage with the story, I didn‘t have that happen with this one. The characters sucked me in, and I found them extremely likable even when they were being stupid. The dynamics between them were intense and the overall plot was exciting. The narrator did a fantastic job too. Another enjoyable read/listen from Silvia Moreno-Garcia!

17 likes2 stack adds
blurb
jen_the_scribe
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

I‘m taking a 4 hour road trip to my hometown tomorrow to help my sister with some personal matters… this listen is 8 hours long so it‘s just enough to keep me company during the whole commute. I‘ve read a couple of other books by Silvia Moreno-Garcia, and I loved them, so expectations are high 🤗

23 likes1 stack add
blurb
Marmie7
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

My tbr for March. 19-20, I'm leaving open for mood reads. I had 4 mood reads this month💗 I read a total of 9 books this month.
#Bookspin #bookspinbingo
@TheAromaofBooks

TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!! 9mo
24 likes1 comment
blurb
diovival
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

Tonight I opened my library book bundle bag and am thrilled to see Silvia Moreno-Garcia was included in the stack! I am so hyped for #deweysreadathon tomorrow y'all 😆

review
DimeryRene
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

Finished this yesterday. I think I said this as soon as I started it, but this is my fave SMG. 🫦

SamAnne My favorite too. 14mo
18 likes1 stack add1 comment
blurb
DimeryRene
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

Love SMG. This is my 5th read of hers. Very cool, gritty vampires in this one.

SamAnne This might be my favorite of hers. 1y
DimeryRene @SamAnne I am glad to hear it. I loved Mexican Gothic and liked four others. Hoping this one is another love! 1y
24 likes2 comments
blurb
Readergrrl
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

I meant to post last week but wanted to let my #LMPBC groups that I received my books! #Round16 #GroupJ and #Round17 #GroupV Thanks!!! I‘ll be getting my books out very soon for Round 17.

Meshell1313 Yay! Can‘t wait for your reviews! 2y
40 likes2 comments
review
EclecticBookLover
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Mehso-so

I finished this, but I haven't had a chance to get to the post office. I will this weekend! I think some of the author's ideas were really good, but they never became as fleshed out as I had hoped. I did enjoy reading it, and the cover is spot-on for the neon noir concept, which I enjoyed. Thanks for sharing, Kristin!

I really enjoyed this round and everyone's picks! Thanks @Johanna414 @kellyann28 @Readergrrl

review
S3V3N
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Mehso-so

Different. It was an ok read.

blurb
EclecticBookLover
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

Starting this one today! I still have to mail mine out, hopefully I'll get it in the mail on Friday. Dies the bookmark belong to anyone or does it stay with the book? @Johanna414 @Readergrrl @kellyann28 #lmpbc

Johanna414 It was with the book when I got it from @Readergrrl so I passed it along 2y
EclecticBookLover Thanks, @Johanna414. That's what I thought, but I just wanted to be sure 😊 2y
Readergrrl Oh dear, that bookmark was part of gift sent to me. I was using it when I was reading. I‘m so sorry that I forgot it. Do you mind sending it along? 🤦🏼‍♀️ (edited) 2y
EclecticBookLover @Readergrrl Of course! I can send when I mail the next book tomorrow. 😊 2y
Readergrrl @EclecticBookLover Thank you so much! I‘ll be sending my book off shortly!! 2y
26 likes5 comments
review
kellyann28
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Mehso-so

This was a "middle of the road" read for me. Didn't hate it but didn't love it! I did like exploring the different vampire clans. I thought they were fun and interesting. I will get this mailed off next week! #LMPBC @Johanna414 @EclecticBookLover @Readergrrl

blurb
kellyann28
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
review
Johanna414
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

This wasn't my favorite of Silvia Moreno-Garcia's books, but I did really like it. The whole neon-noir atmosphere was really cool! @kellyann28 I will try to get it in the mail tomorrow! #lmpbc @Readergrrl @EclecticBookLover

kellyann28 Awesome, thanks! 2y
41 likes1 comment
review
Readergrrl
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

This cover had me from the beginning! 🔥🔥🔥 The story was like a 1940s Noir/BladeRunner/Sin City mashup that I‘ve come to love from Moreno-Garcia. I liked the spin on vampire/human drug lords and gang wars set in Mexico City combined with with star-crossed teen lovers. Entertaining!! I highly recommend listening on Audible. The narrator (Aida Reluzco) was splendid, capturing the nuances of Atl and Domingo‘s characters. Worth it!! 4/5⭐️

SamAnne This is my favorite of her books! 2y
Readergrrl @SamAnne I agree, though I‘ve only read Mexican Gothic. I enjoyed that book too, but CDT really is my type of universe. Very exciting!! 🧛🏼‍♀️ 2y
58 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
bookishbitch
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

I really loved this new take on vampires. There are different types and they each have a different effect on humans, as well as each on other. Humans with bad blood can also infect some of them too. I did like the ending. I will definitely read more by this author. I will put a spoiler about the dog in a comment below to let you know if they live or not. (For those who need to know before reading.)

bookishbitch The dog, a doberman named Cualli, does survive although it first appears they did not. 2y
SamAnne This is my favorite book of hers! 2y
21 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
BookBr
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Mehso-so

This one has a very interesting world concept — vampires of many species all inhabiting our world and relegated to certain areas. Fighting amongst themselves seems almost inevitable… the story was solid and engaging overall, but the pacing felt uneven and that made it hard for me to keep a sustained interest. Still a good read if you like the darker side of vampire fiction.

7 likes1 stack add
review
Gissy
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

This one was a different vampire story. A mix of paranormal characters with humans and drug gangs. I liked the world because it was different with different vampire species It is dark and gory. The conclusion, I think was expected. Sometimes it was difficult to remember some names or words but there is a glossary at the end of the book. 3/3.5⭐️I like that cover😍

Gissy November 2022 #BookSpinBingo @TheAromaOfBooks

3rd and last book read during #NovelNovember @Andrew65 I didn‘t read much this month

#AuthorAMonth @Soubhiville I only have to read now one book I own by this author. But I will like other 3 books written by her.
2y
Andrew65 Brilliant 👏👏👏 2y
40 likes3 comments
review
MeganAnn
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

I‘m a sucker for urban fantasy & really enjoyed this different take on vampires. I loved how Moreno-Garcia plays with the common myths assigning different parts to different types of vampires in her world. I thought the idea that they evolved into different subspecies with various characteristics from various parts of the world was well thought out & executed. Aztecs + vampires 😍

I also enjoyed the noir feel and the various viewpoints …⬇️

MeganAnn Seeing viewpoints from a variety of characters really added to this story and to the noir feel, as well as highlighting the gaps between their roles and lives throughout. I‘m not ready to count this as a favorite quite yet, but I feel that has more to do with my timing in reading it now than it does the book itself. I‘m definitely looking forward to exploring more of this author‘s work as she has been on my TBR list for a long while. 4.5⭐️ 2y
MeganAnn Also, finished just in time for #authoramonth @Soubhiville 😅. Using this for #nsr22 #noshamereadathon22 Noir category @Nessavamusic 2y
Nessavamusic Yay! I enjoyed this one as well. 2y
Reggie My other favorites of hers are Untamed Shores and Signal to Noise. All of her books are so different from each other. 2y
37 likes1 stack add4 comments
blurb
bookishbitch
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

I'm really enjoying this book. The writing is excellent. The vampires are plenty but there are different types which is a unique take. They are also born and not made. The Doberman belongs to a character and has a bioluminescent tattoo on its neck and face. Did I buy this because of the dog on the cover? I'll never tell. (Tea is Pukka: rose, chamomile & lavender.)

SamAnne It‘s my favorite novel of hers! 2y
Soubhiville She gets the best cover art! 2y
16 likes2 comments
blurb
Readergrrl
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

Okay, #GroupJ I‘ve finally made my decision. I‘m going with Certain Dark Things by Silvia Moreno-Garcia. I really wanted to read the others too, but this one has some really cool features like an encyclopedia, author interview, and a cocktail recipe in the back that I want to try. Also, that cover!! 🔥🔥🔥 Wake, Siren would have been my pick, but I‘ve read that it is definitely not a romance.
#LMPBC
#Round16

Johanna414 Sounds like a plan!! 2y
SamAnne It‘s my favorite SMG! 2y
32 likes2 comments
blurb
bookishbitch
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

I'm hoping to start this one before October ends. I'm trying to finish my ghost stories one 1st though.

Moony Such a cool cover!!! 2y
bookishbitch @Moony I agree! 2y
SamAnne My favorite SMG book! 2y
See All 6 Comments
iread2much That cover is awesome. If there is a Doberman with cool mystical armor, I want to read this 2y
bookishbitch @iread2much I will let you know. 2y
14 likes1 stack add6 comments
blurb
DebinHawaii
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

#Scarathlon2022 #ScarathlonDailyPrompts

Another book from my October TBR, this one is supposed to be a #dark vampire tale & I‘m hoping to get to it this month.

#TeamMonsterMash 🧛🏻‍♀️🧟‍♀️👻🐺🐈‍⬛🧙‍♀️🧟🧛🏻

39 likes1 stack add
blurb
TLuvs
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

Totally different horror then I expected so far but great story... and it has vampires!

TLuvs Now finishing... wouldn't call this a horror. But, great story, especially if you're a vampire lover. 2y
9 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
Marialou
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
Pickpick

Took me a little while to get into this and I don‘t think it as good as some of the authors other books but this is still a real solid, dark and original thriller.

It‘s kind of ‘Narcos‘ plus vampires and I enjoyed it overall. The second half of the book is particularly good.

blurb
BookDame
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

This book is amazing. And this author is becoming one of my favorite authors out there. What are your thoughts? https://linktr.ee/ddphughes #bipoc #vampires #fallreading

ReadingOver50 I thought this was great! 2y
BookDame @ReadingOver50 me too. And now I want an altered Doberman! 2y
4 likes2 comments
blurb
TheSpineView
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

#Movie2BookRecs @klou
Prompt: Narrow Margin

PageShifter What a cover!! 😍😍😍 I didn't know this book exists 2y
Klou Wow, this cover 😍 gonna have a better look at this book on goodreads 2y
54 likes4 comments
review
coffees
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Mehso-so

First off, this cover is really cool! The story is too but I have to confess I fell asleep a couple of times. I think it's an interesting take on #vampires and I always appreciate the #mexico #historicalfiction settings in Silvia's books, but idk, it was just ok. I really liked Domingo, he was so cute, but Atl was hard to love bc she didn't let ppl close to her. In a way she was very complex. And the ending made me a bit sad lol 3.5 ⭐ #fantasy

Clwojick I love this cover! I‘ve almost picked this up a few times for the cover alone! 2y
11 likes2 comments
blurb
coffees
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

I started this one a few days ago but it didn't instantly catch my interest so i started other books. Now it's time to finish it #vampires #mexicocity #mexicanlore #augustARC @Clwojick

9 likes1 stack add
review
Johanna414
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

I love how Silvia Moreno-Garcia hops from genre to genre with every book rather than sticking to something safe or easy to sell. I liked the noir feel to this one and the idea of different species of vampires. Probably not my favorite of her books, but still a great read!

44 likes2 stack adds
blurb
Johanna414
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

Turns out you don't get much reading done when there are kittens in the house... we are fostering these babies for a couple weeks and I can't get enough of them! I did spend some time listening to the tagged audiobook while snuggling them today 😻

squirrelbrain Aw, cuties! 2y
JessClark78 🖤🖤 2y
rubyslippersreads Kittens take precedence over everything else. 😸❤️ 2y
See All 8 Comments
MelanieSolane 😍😍😍 2y
Clwojick So cute!!!! 🖤 2y
HeyT 😻omg those little faces 😻 2y
rabbitprincess 😻😻😻😻😻😻😻 squee!!! So cute!!! 2y
kstadt929 Foster fail??? 😻 2y
47 likes8 comments
blurb
thegirlwiththelibrarybag
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

Ran out of renewals - so a late night library return was in order…

Will have to remember to reserve it again in the future when there is room in my library holds queue…

blurb
TLuvs
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

This sounds so different from other vampire books, I have to give it a try!

blurb
Avanders
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

My 2nd (big 😁) #speculativespringswap #sss pkg— WOW @BookwormAHN !! Thank you so much!!! You picked perfect books, I‘m so excited to try the journal, those peeps are 🔥, the coffee smells delish, the candles are all sooo perfect, that little NB is so cute & I 💖 those pens, the crystal soap is soo cool!, & the coaster is exactly perfect for me🤩🤩. Also you wrapped everything beautifully & I love those keys!! Thank you sooo much!!🔮🧬♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️

BookwormAHN You're very welcome. Thank you for setting up this swap 😺 3y
ReadingOver50 Certain Dark Things was awesome 3y
Avanders @BookwormAHN my pleasure 🥰 @ReadingOver50 I‘m so excited for it!! 🤩 3y
BethM Space unicorn blues sounds absolutely bananas and entertaining. I can‘t wait for the review! 3y
67 likes4 comments
review
amma-keep-reading
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
Pickpick

i really enjoyed this.

blurb
Larkken
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

#bookspin # doublespin and #bookspinbingo list for February!
I'm trying to actually finish some reading challenges this year, and many of the books on the list may apply to #pop22 #readharder22 or #booked22
Book 1 has been on my list since my in-person book club chose it for "up next..."Last October ? no one else managed to read it either, though, so I'm in good company! Lol
Nos. 2 and 3 are #roll100 and I actually remember buying them! Amazing.

PuddleJumper I'm so glad other people forget buying books too 🤣 3y
TheAromaofBooks Woohoo!!! 3y
TheAromaofBooks @PuddleJumper - I literally started a spreadsheet with “New Arrivals“ to note down incoming books and where I got them, because otherwise they just seem to disappear into my shelves, never to be heard from again 😂 3y
Larkken @PuddleJumper @TheAromaofBooks I just started a list for kindle books, and it‘s shocking how much I must buy daily deals and never look at them again after! Def need to up my spreadsheet game. I could do roll100 many times over 😳 3y
TheAromaofBooks I made my #Roll100 AND a #TBRDeckofCards all of physical unread books! And still had some left! 😂 That doesn't even touch my Kindle - those free and 99c books are sooo hard to resist!!! 3y
27 likes5 comments
review
wisherwishinguponastar
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

If you enjoy vampires, noir, alternative realities, or just smart writing… this is for you. Silvia Moreno-Garcia‘s work is more well known now due to “Mexican Gothic” and I am really glad this was reprinted and I got my hands on it! #vampires #colonialism #folklore #noir #bookjournal

hannah-leeloo I love hummingbirds this is beautiful 3y
wisherwishinguponastar @hannah-leeloo thank you! Let‘s just say that the vampires can be very different in this book and hummingbirds are important, so I jumped at the opportunity to feature one! 3y
8 likes2 comments
review
sprainedbrain
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

Ok seriously… every time I read a Silvia Moreno-Garcia novel for the first time it becomes my new favorite Silvia Moreno-Garcia novel. And that‘s ok!

Love this fresh take on vampire lore. Very gritty and gory, but lots of fun.

Full review on my blog: https://sprainedbrain.blog/2021/12/01/review-certain-dark-things-by-silvia-moren...

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

LeeRHarry This might make me want to pick one of her books up 😊 3y
75 likes4 stack adds1 comment
blurb
Chittavrtti
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

1 like1 stack add
blurb
TheDaysGoBy
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image

@ImperfectCJ Thank you, thank you! You absolutely spoiled me with this box! The window clings and socks are adorable as well as the koosh light up pumpkin. The candy is fab and I‘m excited to try the cocoa mix - I‘ve always thought about making my own. And the books are perfect! I appreciate you throwing in a surprise one - love getting recs!

Thank you again so much! ❤️

#HHS21 @wanderinglynn

TheDaysGoBy Also forgot to mention the absolutely adorable bookmarks you included in each book. So sweet! 3y
wanderinglynn Great box! 🎃🧡 3y
40 likes2 comments
review
underground_bks
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

Dark, bloody, and lit up like neon glinting off fangs, Certain Dark Things is a vampire novel unlike any I‘ve read before. I really enjoyed the world-building, the action-packed plot, and the main characters—garbage collecting street kid Domingo and beautiful and menacing vampire brat Atl, but I don‘t think noir—or even neo-noir or neon-noir as SMG calls it—is my genre! I appreciated but didn‘t love this, same way I felt about SMG‘s recent noir.

27 likes1 stack add
review
SassenachTheBookWizard
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Mehso-so

Could totally be my reading mood right now since I have really enjoyed the other 2 novels by Silvia but this was just meh to me

review
ReadingOver50
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

A fresh take on the vampire mythos. I really liked how the world knows about vampires, and in some ways coexists with them. This book focuses on Atl, who comes from an ancient line of Aztec vampires, and Nick, one of the Necros form of vampires. Nick wants to kill Atl. Add in a young human assistant, and a police detective determined to stop the vampires, and you get a great story. I loved the world building here, and the writing was intriguing.

Enchanted_Bibliophile Dig the cover! 3y
ReadingOver50 @Enchanted_Bibliophile the cover is amazing! There‘s another edition out there that is not as cool. 3y
72 likes2 comments
review
Asthecroweflies
Certain Dark Things: A Novel | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

I loved this book and I loved Domingo‘s character, but Silvia! What is with your endings, woman?!? So disappointed with the ending but the book is worth it. It has a very different spin on vampires.

26 likes1 stack add
review
BookwormAHN
Certain Dark Things | Silvia Moreno-Garcia
post image
Pickpick

I loved this book. It has really unique vampire families & its set in an alternative realitity of Mexico. Domingo is a garbage collector & Atl is a vampire on the run from another vampire gang, the one that killed her family 🖤
#Scarathlon2021 #TeamHendrix
#Wickedathon @StayCurious
#Screamathom #DiversifyYourHorrorShelf @4thhouseontheleft
#LittensDressedInBlood #Bloodbath @MidnightBookGirl
#Spookoween @TheSpineView
#LittenListen @aperfectmjk

65 likes1 stack add4 comments