Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Golden Enclaves
The Golden Enclaves: A Novel | Naomi Novik
55 posts | 65 read | 10 to read
Saving the world is a test no school of magic can prepare you for in the triumphant conclusion to the New York Times bestselling trilogy that began with A Deadly Education and The Last Graduate. Almost singlehandedly--although backed by an increasingly large cadre of genuine friends--El has changed the nature of the Scholomance forever. But now that she is back in the real world, how will the lessons she learned inside the school apply? Will her grandmother's prophecy come true? Will she really spell the doom of all the enclaves forever? As the quest to save her one true love ramps up, however, El is about to learn the most significant lesson of all--the dire truth on which the enclaves and the whole stability of the magical world are founded. And being El, she is not likely to let it lie....
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Anoukeboek
post image
Pickpick

This one was a little disapointing compared to the other two. It all just happened so quickly and yet not a lot of new things were going on. The ending felt way too abrupt. It was still really nice, but it had more potential.

(audiobook)

review
BooksNBowls
post image
Pickpick

I was pretty satisfied with the ending to this trilogy. I wasn‘t sure I was going to get into this one as much since it happens outside the school, but it felt like everything came together from the first two books, the world is continuing to be revealed to us as a reader and Naomi Novik really thought out every single detail into this magic system. The pacing continues to be a little slower in the beginning but I think it pays off in the end.

BooksNBowls If you enjoy unique magic systems and complex characters that come together in a dysfunctional found family type of way (eventually) then I think you‘ll like this. On top of this we have the narrator who is constantly fighting these inner struggles of good and evil. Super interesting read, won‘t forget it 4/5 3mo
42 likes1 stack add1 comment
blurb
jackilynn
post image

Since all of my is out of town/state for the 4th and the people I usually spend the day with made different plans this year guess now is as good of time as any pick up the last book in this trilogy. Let's see how far I can get.

review
Daily
Pickpick

One of the highlights was the phenomenal world-building. The way that Novik described the magical enclaves, and how she laid out the magic system with so much detail, truly brought the world to life. I could picture the world and feel like I was there.....
Full Review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/6615678401

review
iread2much
post image
Pickpick

This book packed a whole lot into a single book and the ending was not very satisfying, but overall a good read.
El learns the very dark secret of how the enclaves that protect wizards from monsters are made and meets the woman who is the dark sorceress she‘s tried her whole life to NOT become leading to unexpected and painful revelations.
4/5 a good finish except for the kind of lame ending.

AnnCrystal 💕🐶🐾🐕💝. 5mo
dabbe #akitasrock 🖤🐾🐾🖤 5mo
Hooked_on_books Puppies!!!! 🐶🐶❤️❤️ 5mo
See All 8 Comments
iread2much @AnnCrystal 😊💜🐕 5mo
iread2much @dabbe 💜🐕💜 5mo
iread2much @Hooked_on_books happy, if someone what confused, puppies 5mo
MemoirsForMe Awww! Love this photo! 😍🐾 4mo
iread2much @UwannaPublishme thank you 😊 4mo
26 likes8 comments
review
alecia3dixie
post image
Pickpick

The first half of this book I had to slog through. So much more world building, which, since we got so much of that in the first two, I just wanted to get more story in this one. About the halfway mark, it did pick up pace but still just slightly above a slog. I was still enjoying it because I love this world so much. Then the ending happened, and I was ugly crying. I loved the ending so much. Then, the last chapter happened and ruined it. 3.5/5

review
TheAromaofBooks
post image
Pickpick

On the whole, I was way into the conclusion to this trilogy. There were some great twists that still made sense within the world and I genuinely like El. That said, there were also some writing choices I didn't like and that I felt didn't fit with character development from the last two books. I also need more books set in this world!!

TheAromaofBooks #SeriesLove2024 @TheSpineView @Andrew65
#100YearsofBooks
#BacklistReadathon @Clwojick
#52BookClub24 - Sticker on Cover
#FourFoursin24 - Mortal Portal @lauredhel
#GottaCatchEmAll - Toxic Relationship (Koffing), Possessive/Possessed (Polteageist), Includes a Journey (Lapras) @PuddleJumper
#BookSpinBingo
10mo
Librarybelle Gorgeous sprayed edges again! 10mo
See All 9 Comments
TheSpineView Great job!🤩 10mo
Bluebird Nice! You zipped through the trilogy quickly! Love when a series hooks you like that! 10mo
TheAromaofBooks @Librarybelle - I'm forming an unfortunate addiction to special editions 😂 10mo
TheAromaofBooks @Bluebird - I read the third book slower than the other two because I didn't want it to end!! 10mo
Bluebird @TheAromaofBooks Lol, I get like that too. I read my first Naomi Novik book a few months ago and loved it-the first in her Temeraire series. Will need to add this trilogy to my TBR list 10mo
TheAromaofBooks @Bluebird - This is VERY different from the Temeraire books, but not in a bad way. I'm still working my way through that series (I've read the first four). 10mo
81 likes9 comments
review
sarahgreatlove
post image
Pickpick

Sort of similar to Nona the Ninth in the sense that I‘m not sure I always know what‘s going on with these books, but I do enjoy them. I may be hazy on some details as I was listening in a rush before libby returned it and I had to go back on the holds list. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

review
BookBr
post image
Pickpick

Okay so, this series was just about perfection? Literally stunning; the writing is excellent, the characters are utterly compelling, the world building is solid. El is the consummate anti-hero, and her struggle is so well drawn. I cried more than once over three books, but also laughed and sighed, and thought about the world and humanity. Highly recommend.

review
katiekat311
post image
Pickpick

Happy first day of fall, ya‘ll! 🎃🍂 a quiet, cool morning allowed me to FINALLY finish the last few pages of this one. What a ride it has been with El, Orion and the Scholomance crew. This one had some unexpected twists and turns and overall, I think it was a satisfying conclusion to the trilogy.

blurb
Twainy
post image

I pre-ordered this book a year ago. My account said was paid for and preparing for dispatch last September. I contacted the bookseller in February with no response. I reached out again in April. Waterstone‘s found a copy at Blackwell‘s and had it mailed to me. My collection is complete. Thank you Blackwell‘s! 🎉

Bookwormjillk Weird! I‘m glad you eventually got it! 1y
SpeculativeFemale Beautiful edition! And IMO you can never go wrong with Naomi Novik. 😁 1y
28 likes2 comments
review
Sempernox
post image
Pickpick

Galadriel manages to escape her magical school, the deadly Scholomance, but her friend Orion remains trapped. Also, someone is attacking all the wizarding enclaves around the world. Are these two events linked? Can she save her friend? A fantastic conclusion!

review
Clare-Dragonfly
post image
Pickpick

This final installment started a little slow, but that made sense and anyway the trilogy definitely avoided the second-book slump, so I can forgive it 😆 I really enjoyed the massive expansion of the magical world, with El jetting all over the world and meeting lots of new wizards… and terrifying them. I had a suspicion pretty early on of the big reveal, and was partially correct, which is always satisfying.

#doublespin for May @TheAromaofBooks

TheAromaofBooks I own all of these. I read the first one before the other two came out and LOVED It and decided to wait and read them all together... but still haven't done it!!! 2y
Clare-Dragonfly @TheAromaofBooks Put them on your #bookspin list!!! 😁 2y
18 likes2 comments
review
WriterAtHeart
post image
Mehso-so

The idea behind the storyline was good, but I didn't feel like the final installment was as good as the other two.

review
451Degrees
post image
Mehso-so

I definitely preferred the two before this one… as awesome as it was getting into the world outside the schoolmance, El‘s character development really crashed in the first quarter of the book (rightfully so) and turned me off of the story. However this novel does make a come back in the last half of the book and ties up loose ends that were left from before. Ultimately a decent end to the trilogy but didn‘t knock my socks off.

review
tphil10283
post image
Pickpick

It‘s an excellent book with a style that‘s basically the opposite of the Locked Tomb series in that it‘s not unnecessarily vague and unexplained as to the working of the world it built. It‘s basically a story about the negative consequences of greed and selfishness on innocent people.

review
Johanna414
post image
Pickpick

While I did miss the Scholomance in this book, I still loved the characters and enjoyed the twists that came along with the story. A solid conclusion to the trilogy!

dabbe 💜 your bunny! 🤗 2y
50 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
Tea_and_Starstuff
post image
Pickpick

And finishing off the re-read, the finale of the trilogy throws the doors of the world open. New people, new places, and still building on the groundwork (for both world and character) in the first two books. Things get bigger, the stakes get higher, and everything still found its way to a satisfying conclusion.

I really love this trilogy, and tearing through these three books again in a matter of days was a week well-spent.

review
Laughterhp
post image
Pickpick

Thanks so much Chrissy for letting me borrow this book! It always takes me so long to read the final book in the series, because I never want it to end.

This one is a lot different than the other 2 books because they aren‘t in school anymore. It was an interesting premise and I enjoyed seeing El getting in touch with her fellow students.

This was definitely an interesting series and I enjoyed it.

#SeriesLove2023

TheSpineView I enjoyed this also. Well done! 2y
56 likes1 comment
review
AlizaApp
post image
Pickpick

Wow wow wow. What an amazing end to this trilogy. I loved the resolution and also the ending that left space for more stories in this universe. Highly highly recommend!

review
thewallflower0707
post image
Pickpick

I preferred book 1 and 2, but The Golden Enclaves is still a worthy conclusion. I enjoyed meeting all of the characters and discovering more about the enclaves. El really grew to me as a character, although she felt very overpowered. Orion has great golden retriever energy.

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
#NaomiNovik #Schoolomance

review
K.Wielechowski
post image
Pickpick

What a finale to the Scholomance trilogy!
El got everybody out of the Scholomance except Orion and she can‘t forgive herself. The only thing that rousts her is two of her classmates from the London enclave showing up begging her help when a mawmouth attacks.
This sets her on the path to saving enclaves, rescuing Orion, and fulfilling her gr. grandmother‘s prophecy. El tries to rebuild their world with lots of twists along the way
Finished 1/6/2023

review
kellyann28
post image
Pickpick

The Golden Enclaves was such an amazing end to the Scholomance trilogy! There were a lot of twists and surprises as El goes on her journey to "balance" the looming enclave war! I would like to do a reread of this series knowing what I know now to see what I can catch! #booked2023 A Book described with "twist" and "balance" @cinfhen @alisiakae @BarbaraTheBibliophage

38 likes1 stack add
review
ulrichyumiodd
post image
Pickpick

I could tell from the ending of the last book that this one would be different. One character missing, plus a change of setting, meant the story would have to go in a new direction. Due to those changes, I preferred the first two books. The twists are good, but the plot seems to drive the story, with little space for the characters to shine. I couldn‘t quite understand their decisions or their emotions on a deeper level. Not bad, but not great.

quote
SincerelyWinona
post image

“Also I haven't lost an ounce of the passionate desire to beat him over the head with a large stick. And surely that was a sign of true love.”

review
Centique
post image
Pickpick

First book of the year and I seem to be carrying on my Sci Fi and Fantasy fascination - escapism is working for me! This is Book 3 in The Scholomance series and is action packed with a lot of the drama now large scale and world changing. It was a great end to the series, but I do prefer Novik‘s first two books that were smaller scale and more intimate. Still that‘s nit picking - it had to go big!

rockpools Happy New Year, Paula! 2y
Centique @rockpools happy new year to you too Rachel! 😘 2y
vivastory I hope your year is off to a good start, Paula! 2y
60 likes1 stack add3 comments
review
encinarus
Pickpick

How can a third book feel like a bridge book?

Golden Enclaves picks up moments after The Last Graduate and brings much of the same interesting world building that the previous two did, some characters you know and love fine back, but the much like the Temeraire series, I felt like El was pulled along with few choices to make it surprise us with. El's growth comes from outside revelations and direction, not internal wrangling. Still loved it!

review
Decalino
post image
Pickpick

I loved this series and the third installment did not disappoint. El has survived graduation day but unfinished business leads her to work with the Enclaves to save them from mysterious attacks. An intricately plotted story with exquisite world building and vivid characters, whose story arcs come to unexpected but deeply satisfying conclusions, The Scholomance series is officially a personal favorite. Loved it!

review
vlwelser
post image
Pickpick

I love this series. A lot. And I highly recommend listening to it on audio.

#BookSpinBingo @TheAromaofBooks

TheAromaofBooks Yay!! I loved the first book and am really looking forward to reading this whole trilogy. 2y
35 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
monalyisha
post image
Mehso-so

This entire series was too intricately plotted for me. The strategy, the battles…all not my jam. I know this is a problem I have with the genre & not something that all Fantasy readers will balk at. Still. When Novik focuses on her characters, relationships, & even her creatures, I‘m all in. I started the book crying (a fun experience! 😅) & mostly maintained that level of emotion. But if I had to do it all over again, I don‘t know if I would.

Clare-Dragonfly Hahaha, I haven‘t read this series yet but now I‘m even more excited to do so! I love intricate plotting! 😁 2y
74 likes1 comment
review
ICantImReading
post image
Pickpick

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Novik stuck the landing and even elevated the trilogy for me as a whole! It‘s so expertly and intricately plotted - I was shocked by a lot of the twists, but also felt like they made sense and were being set up since the first book. The ending had me on the edge of my seat with tears welling in my eyes. With incredible imagination, complex characters, sharp social commentary, and a fierce, golden heart at the core - it‘s pure magic.

review
Nessavamusic
post image
Bailedbailed

I‘m bailing on this, at least for now. Somehow the MC is even more insufferable and it is now keeping my attention. I may come back to the series eventually.
#bookspinbingo

blurb
Laughterhp
post image

Happy Sunday morning! Forgot it was DLS this weekend, so getting extra reading in while the hubby is still in bed.

So excited to finally pick this one up!

#currentlyreading

blurb
monalyisha
post image

At my favorite beach, on this gift of a day, deciding what to read.

I never expected to be back this late in the season (and without a jacket!)…but I‘ll take it.

jlhammar Loved Small Pleasures so much! One of my favorite reads this year. 2y
monalyisha @jlhammar I ended up starting another one, instead (tagged) — but hopefully I‘ll get to Small Pleasures soon! 2y
89 likes2 comments
quote
catness

"To speak the future is to shape the future."

I didn't like the book overall - it's not about the school anymore, and it's much less exciting than the previous Scholomance novels. But it has its moments.

review
TheSpineView
post image
Mehso-so

So many loved this book, but I am not one of them. I thought the first two were imaginative and had great characters. This one dragged for me and I was not a fan of where the author went with the MC. Her actions were so out of character. I did like the ending but it was not strong enough to raise my rating to above 2⭐️.

#Scarathlon2022 @StayCurious #TeamMonsterMash

TracyReadsBooks I love this world, and the premise generally, but I thought the second book was basically a repeat of the first book and that both really dragged. Based on your review, it sounds as if I‘ll like the third even less which is really disappointing. 2y
TheSpineView @TracyReadsBooks It was very disappointing. If this series continues, I have no interest in reading more. 2y
64 likes2 comments
review
Mindelan
post image
Pickpick

Finished this book while I was babysitting Poppy here, and WOW does it have some thoughts about capitalism, class, climate change, etc. Novik‘s plotting is as strong as ever (I feel quite clever for figuring out the main twist) and there are some really wonderful friendship moments. Some if her twists call back to the first book; it makes me want to reread the series already to see how it hangs together. Can‘t wait to see what she does next.

blurb
Mindelan
post image

I am going slow (apparently my migraines hate school this year, which is helpful) but I am engrossed. So much so that even with a mild migraine last night I could not put this book down for two hours! I‘m going to have to be careful about when I pick it up next, because I think I‘m getting to the point where I won‘t be able to stop until the end.

#fantasy #queerbooks

review
sprainedbrain
post image
Pickpick

A fantastic end to a really great series. This was full of surprises, made me very anxious at times, but ultimately ended in just the most perfect way. Novik amazes me with her ability to write such complex and fascinating worlds and fill them with imperfect characters you can‘t help but love.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️1/2

robinb I‘m way behind on this series. I enjoyed the first but need to get to the second. 😊 2y
sprainedbrain @robinb I‘ve read them all since summer… I like to wait until I know a series is almost done to start it if I can. I have zero chill. 😂 2y
67 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
the.bookish.valkyrie
post image
Pickpick

#NSR22 #NoShameReadathon22
Set in a darkly magical world, full of monsterous terrors. People send their children to the hungry halls of the Scholomance only a fraction of them will return from. But some survivors are better than none. Naomi Novik kept me guessing at where this was all going from book to book and delivered a fantastic conclusion to this #Fantasy trilogy! I loved this engrossing juxtaposition of #Grimdark horror and grudging hope.

review
BarbaraJean
post image
Pickpick

Loved this conclusion to the Scholomance trilogy! Seeing El‘s growth throughout the series has been wonderful, and I loved seeing her friendships deepen and her find her own way in the aftermath of the events of the previous book. There were some jaw-dropping revelations in this book—all so well done. I want to go back and re-read the whole trilogy now.

43 likes1 stack add
blurb
Mindelan
post image

Have the day off today, starting out with a cup of chai and some book time. My spouse read this in the 48 hours after it came out! I‘m taking it slower but really enjoying it. Novik is so good at twists and satisfying endings; I have some guesses but I‘m also sure she is going to surprise me.

review
Linsy
post image
Pickpick

Just finished!! It's a great ending to the series, but I have so many spoilery thoughts! Reply with the spoiler button in the comments if you've read it too and want to chat!

#monster #ominousoctober #teamslaughter #scarathlon #witchathon #spookoween #pointsathon #bookspinbingo #bodycountbingo #autumnbingo2022 #octoberbookbingo

cariashley I loooooved this finale, just finished it yesterday. Such a fantastic series!!! 2y
Linsy @cariashley Agreed!!! i was so stressed out when we found out what Orion really was! And at first I was confused by the solution, but I'm glad she didn't just have to kill him! 2y
cariashley @Linsy same here. Any other author, I would have been skeptical that they could pull off his survival in the end, but Novik really is a master! 2y
65 likes1 stack add3 comments
review
Soubhiville
post image
Pickpick

I liked this just as much as the first two books. It was full of surprises for me, which was fun!

I love El‘s personality, and especially related to her frustration with situations that seem to unnecessarily stack obstacles in her way. I feel that sister! The friendships formed through the trilogy continue to strengthen, even in the face of impending doom.

If snarky dark academia fantasy is a genre, this falls solidly into it. Love!

vlwelser I'm holding out for the audiobook from the library. Good to know it's awesome. 2y
MemoirsForMe 😻😻😻 2y
85 likes2 stack adds2 comments
blurb
CoffeeK8
post image

A little reading in paradise

zezeki 😍😍 2y
5feet.of.fury Great view! 2y
49 likes2 comments
blurb
lesliemarie
post image

Currently reading!

39 likes1 stack add
review
underground_bks
post image
Pickpick

This serious, satisfying, and ambitious finale to the Scholomance trilogy follows the freshly graduated El as she keeps the enclaves she despises from falling apart under force from a mysterious threat. Novik weaves every thread from the first two books into a deft, surprising, and thrilling conclusion, with a valuable consideration of systemic injustice and moral absolutism to boot. Maybe not quite as fun but just as excellent as the first two!

26 likes1 stack add
blurb
Johanna414
post image

I am currently in the middle of two books I'm really enjoying. But this came in the mail yesterday and I kind of want to drop everything and read it right now... lol nevermind the fact that i have to be teaching in 10 minutes!

BarbaraJean Haha… same! I borrowed a copy last night from a friend who already finished it (❗️). I read 50-some pages last night, and now it‘s sitting on my desk, taunting me. Tempted to take an early lunch…😆 2y
45 likes1 comment