data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d4be0/d4be04e7065b2375ceb3eef5411948f5ff8ef558" alt="post image"
30 Book Recommendations in 30 Days — Day 28 “Beheld,” by TaraShea Nesbit
I‘m just not having the greatest time with @MoonWitch94‘s #AuldLangSpine list! Northanger Abbey is on it so maybe I‘ll reread that next—I certainly know I‘ll enjoy it 😁
Did this feel queer-bait-y to anyone else? With Abigail staring at Eleanor‘s bosom and the constant refrain that Dorothy was her “dearest consort”… but from the reviews I could find it doesn‘t go in a sapphic direction.
I loved that this was told through women of course. It also will make you realize how our formal education romanticizes that whole time period. A wise woman once told me there‘s no such thing as nonfiction. I always think of her when I read a new perspective on an old story.
#WinterReadathon #bookspinbingo
@Megabooks @Andrew65 @TheAromaofBooks @DieAReader @GHABI4ROSES
I read this with the #literarycrew, and it was fascinating. A view of the colonists ten years after they arrived written from mostly the women‘s points of view. I had a hard time putting it down! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
#literaryctew #buddyread
I also bought this from ThriftBooks so I could use sticker for #tbrtarot. (Couldn‘t get into my first choice for #tbrtarot)
I read this in one sitting. Growing up outside of Boston, I was taken on school trips to Plimouth Plantation (where door frames demonstrated just how short everyone was) and much was spoken of the famous men of that time. No women were ever mentioned The author does a fantastic job of saying a lot in few words, of detailing how the puritans dictated their beliefs and moralistic thinking to all, of how women lived during that time. This was great.
Discussion questions are up for this month‘s #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead ! I could list a ton more discussion points - like the friendship between Alice and Dorothy - but I‘d be posting all day!
You can find the questions by either searching my feed, the book‘s feed, or using the above hashtags.
If you have not already done so, comment below if you would like to be included in next month‘s tag list for Kate Quinn‘s The Diamond Eye. ⬇️⬇️⬇️
8. The Author‘s Note in the back tells us about the research...to write this novel, as well as that several aspects...were fabricated. What do you think the relationship should be in a historical novel between what can be verified and what an author imagines, particularly when much of the history...has been suppressed, ignored, or cannot—due to a lack of written records...—be verified? ~from LitLovers discussion questions #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead
7. Prior to reading the book, what did you know about the interactions between the puritans and the indigenous peoples...particularly the members of the Wampanoag Nation? Was there anything that surprised you upon? ~from LitLovers discussion questions #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead
Note: I highly recommend This Land is Their Land by David J Silverman - academic in tone, but a solid look at true relations between puritans and the indigenous peoples.
6. Although the murder in the colony is a first, death is very common...especially the death of infants and children. Religion—Anglican or puritan—is also important to their lives, and there is much discussion of God‘s tests, signs, and punishments. How do grief and faith shape these people? Do you see differences in the characters‘ personal relationships to God and religion? ~from LitLovers discussion questions #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead
5. The conflict that leads to disaster in the novel is over a parcel of land. What is the significance of land for the colonists? What does it represent specifically for John Billington? ~from LitLovers discussion questions #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead
4. Throughout the book, much goes unspoken about Dorothy‘s death. How is our understanding of her death complicated through the course of the novel? How do you make sense of it in the end? ~from LitLovers discussion questions #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead
3. There are a few sections from other perspectives as well—the sections headed “Meanwhile“, “Nature“, “The Diary of John Winthrop“, and “Dorothy“. What purpose do these other sections serve? ~from LitLovers discussion questions #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead
2. The novel is written in sections from the perspectives of different characters...The men‘s sections are narrated in the third person; the women speak themselves. What is the effect of having these different perspectives and different voices? Were there voices you trusted more than others? Do the characters ever differ on the facts, or is it only their interpretations that differ? ~from LitLovers discussion questions #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead
1. In the first pages of the novel, Alice Bradford is anticipating the arrival of a ship. The passage is also full of foreshadowing. “Everything,“ says Alice, “could have been a sign of what was to come“...How does foreshadowing work in the book? What expectations did you have as you read? What aspects of the story were still unexpected? ~from LitLovers discussion questions #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead
My library has had this book since 2020. I was so discombobulated when I opened the book to find it had been bound upside down. Has the library known this since 2020? Is it possible no one ever mentioned it when they returned the book? Inquiring minds want to know.
I devoured this literary historical fiction look at the Plymouth colony ten years after the Mayflower limped onto shore. Told from various viewpoints, this shows the layers of contempt and prejudice among the Plymouth founders. There is lots to explore on this, and I‘m so glad to have read this with #LiteraryCrew this month.
Discussion on the 30th!
This was a surprisingly quick read and appropriate for the season considering it is about one of the first settlers of the new world. Told from multiple points of views with the two prominent perspectives being the governors wife and a woman from the opposite side of the social standings of this society. I really enjoyed these unconventional views on a story that you feel like you thought you knew. Really enjoyed the authors note as well.
#literarycrew
I really loved this historical fiction that takes place with the Puritans. I loved how the story embraced narratives that offered viewpoints that not only differed but could be equally true. I also appreciated a historical version of events that shared the darker side of history that there are people attempting to white wash and deny the dark and ugly side of colonization. So glad I read this.
We are at the halfway point with this month‘s #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead ! I‘ve seen some great posts so far, and it looks like a few have finished the book!
Any thoughts to share with the group? Full discussion will be on November 30th!
I will post December‘s info, The Diamond Eye, in the next few days - I‘ve had limited downtime as of late due to a high turnover in staffing.
If you have a thought for a good book for next year, comment below!
I really enjoyed this #HF narrative about the early settlers who established Plymouth Rock. Interesting multiple POVs from the governor‘s wife to an indentured slave/ land owner. Audio was excellent. Excited to join the #LiteraryCrew discussion 🤓
Just started #LiteraryCrew
It‘s a great pick @Librarybelle
Are you guys continuing in 2023?!?
I‘d love to be tagged on your upcoming reads!!!
#bookreport #November6to12 #2022
Completed the first 5 books (reading across), the other 4 I am at various stages-3 of these are buddy reads.
#BookReport Favorite was Rememberings. Looking forward to the #LiteraryCrew discussion on Beheld and the other 2 were good not great. I‘m feeling a bit overwhelmed with all the buddy reads and need to do better at just saying no to myself. Enjoying #NonFictionNovember.
I picked this #literarycrew #buddy read up to start it and was pleasantly surprised to see it‘s written by an English professor at my kid‘s university. He‘ll never take a class from her since he‘s not an English loving kid (is he actually mine?) but the knowledge that he could tickles me nonetheless. @Librarybelle
Beautiful writing and character development. Story moved quickly. Looking forward to discussion with #literarycrew
For November‘s #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead hosted by @Librarybelle we read this one. I was going to take my time with this one but I sat down today to read a couple chapters and well…that turned into the whole book. This was so good. I loved reading about the female perspective of settling Plymouth. Historic fiction at its finest #bookspin @TheAromaofBooks
Repost for @Librarybelle
Today starts this month‘s #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead !
Read at your own pace; discussion on November 30th.
Tagging those who have expressed interest. If you would like to be included in periodic posts as well, comment below!
Today starts this month‘s #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead !
Read at your own pace; discussion on November 30th.
Tagging those who have expressed interest. If you would like to be included in periodic posts as well, comment below!
Reposting for @librarybelle next months #literarycrew buddy read. Everyone is welcome- check out her post for more info.
I am terribly behind on posting - so sorry! October has not been kind personally or professionally!
The November title for #LiteraryCrew #BuddyRead is Beheld. Read at your own pace, and discussion questions will be posted on the 30th. Tagging those who previously expressed interest, but all are welcome to join! Just comment below! I‘ll post periodic checkins throughout the month.
I got in a few chapters of my book club pick this morning. I‘m not sure yet what I think of it. #doublespin
Confession: I expected to hate this as it is not a book I picked out for myself and ugh-Puritans. 😂 Instead, I enjoyed this work of historical fiction set during a time I‘ve forgotten about. I‘m sure we studied the Mayflower and pilgrims in school, but I found it boring and blocked it out. This book is anything but boring and I loved the insights into conflicts between the colonists. #book about a cult or religion #booked2022
You‘d never know from reading primary source accounts that women even existed in Plymouth, the first Puritan colony. Nesbit tries to remedy that by giving voice to two women, Governor William Bradford‘s second wife Alice, and an freed indentured servant, Eleanor. These women enlighten the problems and conflicts in this sometimes glorified early American settlement.
#bookspin complete just in time! Library books, #1001books, #nyrb, off the shelf/kindle. @TheAromaofBooks
A Pilgrim murder mystery sounds perfect for Thanksgiving, don‘t ya think?
The NYTimes just released this list. Do you agree?
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/books/notable-books.html?campaign_id=9&...
Set in 1600‘s Plymouth, so many events in this story remind me of present day 🇺🇸 3/5🍁s
This is not a feel good book. Using (mostly) the voices of two pilgrim women of different classes & backgrounds it imagines what lead up to the first murder by & of a European in America. Life is bleak in the colony- even as seen through wealthy Alice's eyes- & the book examines how the oppressed become oppressors, how the Haves ensure the Have Nots continue to have not, and how the same events look very different as seen through different eyes.
An intriguing look at life, & the first murder, in Plymouth colony told primarily through the POVs of the governor‘s wife & the wife of a man who paid their way to the New World by signing them up for 7 years of indentured servitude. While other POVs are employed, it‘s these two—a woman of privilege & power within the community & who has none—that stand out & through which the challenges, prejudices, & privilege of life in the colony are seen.
Plymouth 1630 - the lies, hypocrisies, dangers, dreams & aspirations of a group of settlers as seen through the eyes of the women of the community. Fashioned on real historical events. I loved the settings, thought the different factions were drawn well and the emerging townscape vivid. I'd of liked more agency on the part of the women - they commentate from the sidelines and their own connective power isn't central.
My favourite time of day - it‘s early, the sun is up, the world is quiet and Bunky is craving cuddles. Add to that a new book and the world looks OK today.
Starting off the year with an “eh.” The murder was not really as large a part of the story as the galley copy led me to believe. Beheld is more a fictionalized entry into lesser known colonists in Plymouth - the women and the indentured servants- than mystery or crime novel. I‘d probably have liked it better with different expectations- it‘s a quiet, very interior book.
#AdvancedReaderCopy