Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#blackplague
blurb
Ruthiella
Doomsday Book | Connie Willis
post image

Happy Holidays to all who celebrate!

A couple of questions for any who have finished this month‘s #ClassicLSFBC pick. If anyone would like to be added or removed from the tag list, let me know.

1. In writing about the Black Death, Willis had the advantage of hindsight, but much of the 2056 attitudes towards the present day epidemic was recognizable. Did present day Oxford in the novel seem realistic to you?

#ClassicLSFBC

KathyWheeler It did seem realistic. If I‘d read this book before 2020 though, I would have it wasn‘t because people would not act like that if faced with an epidemic or pandemic. (edited) 2mo
Ruthiella @KathyWheeler While she obviously didn‘t predict cell phones or the internet, I agree that the behavior of people facing a quarantine and a pandemic was all too familiar. 2mo
rwmg And this was the present day's 2nd epidemic/pandemic, which does not bode well for our future. 2mo
See All 11 Comments
The_Literary_Jedi I was annoyed with the general incompetence of the people involved with the project itself once Badri got sick; not one knew how to operate the machine? I first read this back in the 90‘s in HS & I remember thinking there was no way authorities would be so stupid or people be so panicky…lol. 2mo
Ruthiella @rwmg I suspect our experience with the next pandemic (not a question of if but when) will be equally divisive and difficult, unfortunately. 2mo
Ruthiella @The_Literary_Jedi While overall I enjoyed it because I was particularly invested in the Middle Ages story line, the ridiculousness of the missed calls, etc. drove me crazy. It was just to extend the plot tension, but it only annoyed me. (edited) 2mo
Larkken The picketing for useless reasons, general confusion/breakdown of services, and blaming of minorities was painfully familiar. @Ruthiella I did a lot of skimming during the missed connections parts, for sure not my favorite parts either. (edited) 2mo
Ruthiella @Larkken I remember similar issues in “Blackout”, with break downs in the technology and endless (ENDLESS) dialogue about how to get back. 2mo
Larkken @Ruthiella ew... Even though I really liked it, I have to admit that my tear-to-page quota was exceeded in this book so I already wasn't rushing to read the sequel, and that info pushes it still further down the list! 2mo
swynn In terms of the resistance to public health measures and conspiracy-suspicious responses to quarantine, she was spot-on in ways I probably would not have appreciated before 2020. I do think, though, that she also used some comic exaggeration, that for me didn't fit well with the desperate and tragic scenes in the past, and also the future's final act 2mo
Ruthiella @swynn I‘m glad you brought that up. I also found it a bit disconcerting the switch from the light comedy in the present day compared to the drama and trauma of the past. Agnes, in particular, gutted me. 2mo
35 likes11 comments
review
swynn
Doomsday Book | Connie Willis
post image
Pickpick

(1992) Oxford historians send a time traveler to the 14th century, just as a viral pandemic breaks out in their own time, complicating every aspect of the project. Much to admire here: author Willis's style, her 14th-C. worldbuilding, her narrative structure that parallels medieval and modern pandemics. For me there are tonal inconsistencies that complicate my response, but I found the story engaging and, in the final act, gripping.

blurb
Larkken
Doomsday Book | Connie Willis
This post contains spoilers
show me
post image

Omg I‘m so annoyed. Is this the origin of this trope?!? #classiclsfbc

PuddleJumper 🤣🤣 2mo
9 likes1 comment
review
KathyWheeler
The Doomsday Book | Connie Willis
post image
Pickpick

Well, that was one depressing and thought-provoking Christmas-adjacent book! I did like it though. It got a little repetitive and long-winded in some places; at a couple of places, I actually said out loud, “Will you just get to the point?!” Willis‘ take on pandemic behavior is absolutely right. #ClassicLSFBC #audiowalk

kspenmoll Lovely walk! 2mo
KathyWheeler @kspenmoll It‘s one of my favorite places. Five rivers converge here, so it‘s called Five Rivers Delta Center. 2mo
23 likes2 comments
review
rwmg
Doomsday Book | Connie Willis
post image
Pickpick

In a time travel accident Kivrin Engle ends up just before Christmas 1348, when the Black Death arrived in Oxford and the surrounding countryside. Can she survive until rescue comes from 2055 Oxford? ⬇

#ClassicLSFBC @RamsFan1963

rwmg Very readable with well developed main characters, though some of the side characters, especially in 2055, were stock figures of fun. Written in 1992 and very presciently putting a pandemic in the 2020s, though in that world it was a lot worse than in ours. I'm not sure the author did all her homework, however, and there were some definite anachronisms in her picture of the 14th century. 2mo
31 likes1 comment
blurb
KathyWheeler
The Doomsday Book | Connie Willis
post image

William Gadsden‘s mother would drive me up a wall! I wonder if she‘s more than just comic relief. I have a feeling she is, but we‘ll see. #audiowalk

blurb
KathyWheeler
The Doomsday Book | Connie Willis
post image

The Doomsday Book was published in 1992, and, boy, did Willis get the American reaction to a pandemic spot on! I thought she had one scene that dragged on far too long, but now I know why that scene was so detailed. I had a couple of nice and cool walks today. #audiowalk

DogMomIrene I‘ve eyed this book for a while. Sounds right up my alley. Stacking! 3mo
KathyWheeler @DogMomIrene Now that I‘ve gotten past chapter 1, I‘m enjoying it. There‘s nothing wrong with the first chapter, either; I just couldn‘t get past it for years. 3mo
DogMomIrene @KathyWheeler 👏🏼 Will be watching for more updates to see your final thoughts. 2mo
27 likes1 stack add3 comments
blurb
KathyWheeler
The Doomsday Book | Connie Willis
post image

I‘ve tried to read this book multiple times and never got past the first chapter. I don‘t know why — it‘s totally in my wheelhouse. So I‘m listening to it for #ClassicLSFBC and as my new #audiowalk book. I‘ve already gotten past the first chapter. Yay!

BarbaraJean Ooooh, I loved this book! I hope it works for you this time! 3mo
KathyWheeler @BarbaraJean I believe I will like it. Sometimes that just happens to me, and I never really know why. 3mo
18 likes2 comments
review
readingjedi
Turn of Midnight (Original) | Minette Walters
post image
Mehso-so

This narrowly avoids an outright Pan. First part was disappointing, but I ploughed on, hopeless optimist that I am, thinking the excitement might just ramp up in the next chapter ... it didn't. Infuriatingly, it had the same tedious middle section as the last one! The characters got increasingly one dimensional & nowt much happens. The ending has a few moments of satisfying resolution, but overall, I wish I'd not bothered! Disappointing ☹️

review
averil
Company of Liars | Karen Maitland
post image
Mehso-so

Company of Liars is a cozy, entertaining, and immersive novel set during the English run of the Black Death. It has a great many twists that keep you hungering for more—

Unfortunately, I thought it was a straight historical fiction novel. It instead gets pretty fantastical and borderline paranormal towards the end in a way that totally took me out of the world I was coming to inhabit.

#historicalfiction #medieval #historicalfantasy #blackdeath