Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Forever War
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
69 posts | 113 read | 43 to read
The monumental Hugo and Nebula award winning SF classic-- Featuring a new introduction by John ScalziThe Earth's leaders have drawn a line in the interstellar sand--despite the fact that the fierce alien enemy they would oppose is inscrutable, unconquerable, and very far away. A reluctant conscript drafted into an elite Military unit, Private William Mandella has been propelled through space and time to fight in the distant thousand-year conflict; to perform his duties and do whatever it takes to survive the ordeal and return home. But "home" may be even more terrifying than battle, because, thanks to the time dilation caused by space travel, Mandella is aging months while the Earth he left behind is aging centuries...
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
KathyWheeler
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Pickpick

I thought I was going to hate this because of the extremely outdated and unrealistic views on gender and sexuality, but I ended up not disliking it. The antiwar stance is an interesting take in a military sci-fi novel, and watching Earth‘s society change drastically over the centuries because of the time dilation experienced by Mandella was fun. I haven‘t decided if the ending is a hopeful one or not — it could be either.

Ruthiella I liked the open ending. I like to ponder the possibilities. (edited) 6mo
KathyWheeler @Ruthiella I liked it too. 6mo
24 likes2 comments
blurb
KathyWheeler
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

Well, the depiction of gay people in this book is certainly interesting, to say the least. Here‘s a picture of George trying to become a bed cat. She wants to sleep with us, but our Maine Coon already does that. He‘s so big that there‘s no more room. #audiowalk

Ruthiella Oh, poor George! 😻 6mo
Sace I love your audio walk posts. I wish I had such interesting routes. Poor George! 6mo
KathyWheeler @Sace Thank you! I‘ll be glad when it cools down a bit though so I can go back to walking outside. That said, this is a nice track; there‘s bikes, rowing machines, and ellipticals in nooks, so you can change up your workout if you want. 6mo
KathyWheeler @Ruthiella she‘s so pitiful. 😄😊 6mo
20 likes4 comments
blurb
KathyWheeler
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

More indoor walking because it was rainy all day. I‘m not really all that interested in battle descriptions, but now that they‘ve been through some and are headed back to Earth, the story could get more interesting. There are already some thought provoking elements; I hope there‘s more focus on those. #audiowalk

blurb
KathyWheeler
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

Although I got this to read for #ClassicLSFBC, I‘m just now starting it as my new #audiowalk book. I think I might like it, but so far I‘m a little appalled by the sexism. Women are “compliant and promiscuous“ by law? Talk about taking away our bodily autonomy! Join the army — get raped. Yay.

Ruthiella Yeah. There‘s a few things that haven‘t aged well in this one. 6mo
KathyWheeler @Ruthiella I see! 😳 6mo
Bookwomble That was a real "WTF!" moment, for sure! 5mo
KathyWheeler @Bookwomble Yes, it was! 5mo
19 likes4 comments
blurb
Ruthiella
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

🚀 I thought I‘d post a couple questions on this month‘s book. Anyone who wants to be removed from the tag list (or added) please let me know.

🚀 Is the ending a happy one for human kind? Or is losing our individuality the price of peace?

RamsFan1963 I think it was a happy ending for Mandella, Marygay and the other inhabitants of Middle Finger. As for humanity as a whole, I think the future is as bleak and pointless as possible. I see it leading to stagnation and an eventual collapse of society into a collective or hive mind without any culture, art or music because there would be no individuality to inspire creation 6mo
Ruthiella @RamsFan1963 Yeah. I found “Man” as the answer rather bleak. 6mo
MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm I agree with @RamsFan1963 It was a happy ending for some. Although I do feel that since there are two types of “human” in the end, that if the clones do end up a failure, the more traditional humans will flourish all over again. The aliens were clones and seemed to at least be surviving successfully. Though their quality of life seemed rather dull. 6mo
See All 16 Comments
Ruthiella @MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm That‘s true that there‘s a possibility that the colony at Middle Finger (there‘s a joke in that name somewhere!😅) will flourish. 6mo
julesG @Ruthiella an apt name for a 'thriving' colony 😂 6mo
TheSpineView I agree with @RamsFan1963 for the most part it is not a happy ending or at least one I would want to live. This question did get me to thinking. If this new reality is the only one you know, would it change your thoughts? What if society has a major cultural shift, then what? Would we adapt to just survive or would humans be happy? 6mo
Ruthiella @TheSpineView Haldemam definitely questions this in the book. As many reviews have noted, his concept of homosexuality and female sexuality in the book is awkward and actually offensive by today‘s standards, but with it he does try to address how a society can change drastically over a couple of generations in its attitudes and acceptance of what might have been previously unaccepted. 6mo
Ruthiella @julesG Maybe MF is what the colony is showing the powers that be tried to kill them or in a best case scenario, didn‘t care if they lived or died. (edited) 6mo
RamsFan1963 @TheSpineView That's the thing about history, we can look back on things that aren't acceptable now, and condemn the leaders and citizens, but if you had been living in that time, and that was the system you grew up in, then it would be whats normal. It's easy to be in 2024 and say I would have fought against this injustice, like slavery, but if you'd been raised to believe that was the natural order of things, then you would have gone 6mo
RamsFan1963 @TheSpineView along with it. 20-30 years from now people will look back on 2024 and wonder why we allowed stuff that's happening now, like Ukraine or Gaza, wonder what's wrong with us. 6mo
Bookwomble @RamsFan1963 @Ruthiella @MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm @TheSpineView Haldeman's portrayal of society at the novel's end isn't that appealing, but it's based on his premise that non-heteronormativity is bad, or at least 2nd best. His view of gender & sexual diversity leading to a bland homogeneity lacking individuality & creativity is, I think, an unlikely development. Also, his idea that no LGBTQIA+ people want children was wrong when he wrote it. 6mo
MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm @Bookwomble This was definitely something that bugged me about the book. His views on sexuality grated on my nerves the whole way through. Especially the implication that you can just switch from one to the other at society‘s convenience. The fact that Mandela couldn‘t be bothered to try a same sex relationship but being certain that the other male character would like being heterosexual just fine had me doing some HARD eye rolls. 6mo
Bookwomble @MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm I had the same experience, but bearing in mind we've had about 50 years of feminist and queer experience, theory and philosophy to critique him with 😊 I don't think he was intentionally malicious with his views, but heteronormative for sure. 6mo
MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm @Bookwomble Agreed. I try not to judge older books too harshly due to old beliefs/ignorance. I still enjoyed the book and liked Mandela‘s character overall. 6mo
Bookwomble @MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm Same 😊 A book has to be truly odious for me to be completely unforgiving. Despite the issues we've discussed, there's still much to enjoy about TFW and empathy to be had for it's MC. 6mo
41 likes16 comments
blurb
Ruthiella
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

🚀 I thought I‘d post a couple questions on this month‘s book. Anyone who wants to be removed from the tag list (or added) please let me know.

🚀 Mandella only sees action twice in his long career as a soldier. How is this an anti-war novel?

RamsFan1963 I think the novel is a big reflection of the author's Vietnam experience. Its anti-war because it doesn't glamorize war, like say Starship Troopers, but shows it's a lot of boredom and waiting, intersped with moments of horror and conflict. Also, the soldiers arent5 presented as on a glorious mission, they're not even sure what they're fighting for or really who they're fighting against. 6mo
Ruthiella @RamsFan1963 Great points. The long stretches of waiting and the anxiety of wondering if/when they would be deployed really struck me too. 6mo
CSeydel Just wanted to say thanks for leading the discussion. I‘m behind on this - juggling too many book groups - but I still plan to read it. 6mo
See All 16 Comments
RamsFan1963 @Ruthiella I think the saddest part is the isolation and alienation felt by the soldiers. Everyone and everything you knew was gone every time you came back, becoming stranger and more alien each time. I'm pretty sure I would not like to live in the clone future. I would have joined Mandella and Marygay on Middle Finger. 6mo
Ruthiella @CSeydel You are welcome! I hear you on juggling group reads. It can be difficult. 6mo
Ruthiella @RamsFan1963 Yes, for sure. After that first very disorienting visit, I can see why Mandela and Marygay would never want to return. 6mo
MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm It definitely benefits from being written by a veteran, especially a Vietnam vet. The sense of alienation they felt returning to Earth was reminiscent of what soldiers experienced coming home from Vietnam. So much had changed and overall, the civilians either didn‘t really know about the war or why it mattered. Real veterans struggle with many of the topics Joe touched on in the novel. The most anti-war people I‘ve met in life have been veterans. 6mo
Ruthiella @MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm I‘ve met Vietnam vets on both sides of the war question. But we do know historically that they were not treated well generally by the American public upon returning which was unfair. 6mo
MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm @Ruthiella Oh absolutely. I didn‘t mean to imply that ALL vets are anti-war. Just that the people in my life that have been the most against it have happened to be vets. My BIL served in Afghanistan and after speaking with him, I don‘t know how anyone could ever make an argument in favor of war. How we treat our veterans in this country is shameful, for sure. 6mo
TheSpineView I think it is anti-war because the book does not glamorize war. 6mo
Ruthiella @TheSpineView I thought it was interesting to try to pick out what he might have extrapolated from his experience and what was purely imagined for the sake of the novel. 6mo
Bookwomble @ramsfans @Ruthiella @TheSpineView @MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm I read that he struggled to get a publisher as it was seen as such a clear Vietnam War critique & it was felt the reading public had had enough of that. It must have been gratifying for Haldeman to receive the Hugo! I've just read some Asimov stories written in the shadows of Hiroshima and the Korean War, and they're anti-war in a very "What the fuck is wrong with us" way! 6mo
Bookwomble (Though he'd have said "gosh darned"!) 6mo
Ruthiella @Bookwomble The edition I read had an introduction from Haldeman about his difficulties in finding a publisher. That‘s just yet another example of how culture gatekeepers have often no idea what the public might really want. 6mo
Bookwomble @Ruthiella Yep! "I think this is a good book, but the general public won't understand it so, no." ? 6mo
39 likes16 comments
review
Bookwomble
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Pickpick

I first read this in 2000, and while I think it strikes me very differently now in respect of social attitudes, it holds up as hard sci-fi, and Haldeman's meditation on how his characters are affected by relativistic time dilation is still interesting. As a veteran of the Vietnam War, his attitudes to militarism, combat & death feel personal and true.
Pic. is an artist's impression of a Tauran 👽
#ClassicLSFBC @RamsFan1963
⬇️

Bookwomble I think he's trying to do something liberal with his take on sexuality, which is still binary in the novel, but it reads now as a homophobic and heteronormative dialogue between author and original reader, while having the insight to acknowledge that this reflects his MC's outdated perspective and possibly, therefore, the author/reader's own. 6mo
Ruthiella Interesting depiction of the Taurans. In their first description, I was reminded of Ulysses in Way Station, who is supposedly hideous to human standards but is The Station Master‘s best friend really. How in humans aesthetics can determine our feelings . 6mo
Bookwomble @Ruthiella Yes ? And in Forever War, there's a part where Mandella worries whether he'll still be attracted to Marygay due to her injuries, but "it's all ok" because advanced medical science makes her "look normal". I guess we're all emotionally affected by our placement of things on a spectrum from familiar to alien, something the better SF writers invite us to reflect upon. 6mo
36 likes3 comments
quote
Bookwomble
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

"Tonight we're going to show you eight silent ways to kill a man."

#FirstLineFridays @ShyBookOwl
#ClassicLSFBC

review
MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Pickpick

4 ⭐️s
I really enjoyed this one. The descriptions of the tech and time dilation were fun. I honestly liked Will for the most part despite his personal hang ups on a few things. I appreciate the fact that the violence/war wasn‘t glorified. The changes Earth went through over the course of the story were fascinating. There were a few things I rolled my eyes at, but they‘re mostly products of the time the book and author come from.
#ClassicLSFBC

MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm I saw the ending coming about halfway through. The Taurans seemed too inept to be an actual threat. But the clones were a surprise. I was extremely pleased with the happy ending for Will but the implication that people could just switch between hetero and homosexual when it suited society‘s needs definitely got on my nerves. 6mo
RamsFan1963 @MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm Yeah I found the idea that an entire culture would turn from hetero a little too far fetched to be realistic 6mo
MegaWhoppingCosmicBookwyrm @RamsFan1963 I can imagine an entire race changing how they view sexuality. For me it was more the fact that the conditioning to turn it on or off was viewed so casually. As if it‘s just a switch you can toggle and not suffer major mental ramifications for. It reminded me of one of my favorite Star Trek TNG episodes, The Outcast. The crew encounter an androgynous alien race that think gender expression is a mental defect. It‘s such a sad episode. 6mo
27 likes3 comments
review
CatLass007
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
Bailedbailed

June #ClassicLSFBC This was first published in 1974 and I don‘t think it has aged well. I believe I read books by Haldeman in the 1980s and I think I enjoyed them. I guess my tastes have changed in the last 40 years. I prefer to read stories that are more character driven. It is told in the first person but Mandella is really just a cardboard cutout. The science was interesting. The prediction that future humans will use they/them/their (cont)⬇️

CatLass007 pronouns is also interesting. I just didn‘t think the characters were all that interesting. 6mo
Lesliereadsalot I almost bailed too but the story actually went to some interesting places. Took me forever to read and it‘s not that long of a book! 6mo
42 likes2 comments
review
Lesliereadsalot
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Pickpick

William Mandella narrates the story of his life over a space war that lasts 1150 years. Imagine the changes earth goes through, many of which you couldn‘t guess. This book was way ahead of its time, winning all sorts of sci-fi awards. And when he got to the origins of this war, all you can do is shake your head. Loved the ending!
#classicLSFBC

Ruthiella Great review! Just started reading it today. 6mo
Ladygodiva7 This is on the NPR‘s 100 SF Books so I‘ve been wanting to read it for a long time. 6mo
Lesliereadsalot @Ladygodiva7 Hope you like it! 6mo
18 likes3 comments
blurb
Ruthiella
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

#weekendreads

Starting all three of these today. The Halderman is for #ClassicLSFBC , the Didion is for #Roll100 , and the Davis is for #CampLitsy24. Looking forward to diving in. I think they will all be winners in their own way.

TheBookHippie That‘s my favorite Didion. 6mo
Ruthiella @TheBookHippie It‘s only the third book from her that I‘ve read but I‘m sure I‘m going to love it. 6mo
vivastory I 💙 that Didion 6mo
Ruthiella @vivastory I‘ve already read the first two essays and am enthralled. 6mo
vivastory She is def one of my fave essayists of all-time
6mo
60 likes5 comments
review
RamsFan1963
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Pickpick

60/150 As military sci-fi goes, this is as anti-war as you can get. War isn't glorified, its usually stupid and death comes swiftly, without warning or reason. William Mandella rises from private to major, never really understanding the reasons for the war with the Taurens. I'm going to put the rest of this review under a block so not to ruin it for those still reading the book. 4⭐⭐⭐⭐
#ClassicLSFBC

RamsFan1963 I wonder if anyone will find this book homophobic? Once Mandella returns to Earth and discovers the majority of the population is homosexual, a measure to reduce the population growth, he's the odd man out. Then later, in a clever twist of America's history of treating homosexuals, heterosexuality is seen first as a crime, then just as a mental disorder. I don't think there was any negative or offensive 7mo
RamsFan1963 characterizations of any of the gay characters, soldiers and civilians. I'll be interested to see what other people thought of the idea of planetside homosexuality. 7mo
See All 6 Comments
Ruthiella Wow! That was fast. 😅 7mo
RamsFan1963 @Ruthiella I was listening to it every day to and from work so that was about 2 hours each day, so it went by fast. 7mo
DieAReader 🥳Great!! 7mo
54 likes6 comments
blurb
RamsFan1963
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

Starting this today on audio. It will definitely be a different kind of military sci-fi from the last two Phule's Company books 🤣🤣
#ClassicLSFBC

blurb
LitsyEvents
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

repost for @RamsFan1963:

Originally, I planned to let voting go until the end of the month, but since this is the overwhelming favorite, three times the votes for Deus Irae, I will go ahead and announce that June's selection for #ClassicLSFBC is The Forever War by Joe Haldeman. A copy should be available at most libraries or used book stores. If you have premium subscriptions to Audible or Spotify, it's available on both formats for free.

34 likes1 comment
blurb
RamsFan1963
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

Originally, I planned to let voting go until the end of the month, but since this is the overwhelming favorite, three times the votes for Deus Irae, I will go ahead and announce that June's selection for #ClassicLSFBC is The Forever War by Joe Haldeman. A copy should be available at most libraries or used book stores. If you have premium subscriptions to Audible or Spotify, it's available on both formats for free.

Lesliereadsalot I‘m in on this one! 7mo
See All 12 Comments
TheSpineView I have a physical copy but good to know it is free with Audible plus. I might just read and listen together. 7mo
Roary47 Yay!! Thanks for the tip on audible. I‘m ready to go. 😍 7mo
RaeLovesToRead UK LITTENS: This is currently 99p on Kindle!!!!!!!! 7mo
RamsFan1963 @Lesliereadsalot Do you wish to be added to the #ClassicLSFBC list? 7mo
CatLass007 Yay! I was kinda hoping this would be the June choice just because it is free on Audible. 7mo
KathyWheeler I just downloaded this from Audible and I‘m looking forward to it. Would you mind adding me to the list? Thanks. 7mo
RamsFan1963 @KathyWheeler Okie Dokie! You're added to the list 7mo
Lesliereadsalot Yes! Add me to the list. 7mo
The_Literary_Jedi Also available on Kindle Unlimited if you have a subscription 😀 7mo
53 likes12 comments
blurb
TheSpineView
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

#Movie2BookRecs @Klou
Movie: Universal Solider

There are lots of good military science fiction books put there. This series is one of my favorites in the genre.

Klou Perfect 1y
47 likes2 comments
review
Clare-Dragonfly
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
Bailedbailed

I tried, I really did. I can even see how this is considered a science fiction classic. But it seems to me you could do “the Vietnam war in space” without all the rape and homophobia.

AbigailJaneBlog Sounds like a book I'll be avoiding! 2y
TieDyeDude I remember listening to the audio on a road trip. If I remember, those less savory aspects are addressed later on, but it's understandable if it is hard to get through. 2y
Clare-Dragonfly @TieDyeDude I made it to 75%! Mandella showed his willingness to take advantage of a drunk woman and I couldn‘t power through anymore. 2y
TieDyeDude @Clare-Dragonfly Ah, yeah, that'd make sense. I don't remember that part 2y
20 likes4 comments
blurb
Lauredhel
Forever War | Joe Haldemann
post image

This graphic novel was originally done in 2002 and re-produced and colorised in 2017, but it looks like they changed nothing from the 1974 original.

blurb
SpaceCowboyBooks
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

Today's reading

28 likes1 stack add
review
Paul.VandenElzen1
Forever War | Joe Haldemann
post image
Pickpick

Since my last post, lots has happened in this book. It went from a war experience based book to a story about a man who is re-discovering earth after being gone over 100 years, and then going through another experience of having to go back to war. He gets hurt in battle and we see how he deals with losing limbs and how his relationships are affected by war. If you like books that focus on one persons experiences through different situations,

Paul.VandenElzen1 …you‘ll love this book. The theme I have identified so far is how a persons relationships are affected by traumatic experiences, and whether they are pushed apart or drawn closer than ever. This book is in first person point of view from the POV of a man named mandella. 3y
MissYaremcio Thank you for the review Paul! I was just missing how the pOV was established. 5/6 3y
1 like2 comments
review
Paul.VandenElzen1
Forever War | Joe Haldemann
post image
Pickpick

The ‘Forever War‘ is about a inter-galactic war between the humans and another race called the Taurans. The Taurans attacked earth and killed lots of humans and were barely fought off, so the humans gathered the people with the highest Iq‘s and most athletic to join a small army to go to one of the Tauran‘s home planets to attack and scout them out. If you like books that are science fiction about space and aliens you would love this book.

Paul.VandenElzen1 The theme of this book would be about how war affects people and society in various negative ways. It could also be about how individual people have to deal with committing acts they may not see morally acceptable for their own race. 3y
MissYaremcio Nicely done Paul! What a cool sci-fi book! 6/6 3y
1 like2 comments
blurb
adrien.fox
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

This book is military style fiction. About a special group inside the military that train to fight against an alien force in the “forever war”. They fight in a interstellar war against aliens known as Taurans. If you like books that tell a story with good detail and try to connect our views on life with the fiction then you‘ll love this. The theme is dealing with people who are different from us. In this case the aliens are different from us.

MissYaremcio Thank you for the review Adrien! 6/6 3y
2 likes1 comment
blurb
Leniverse
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks 👏🏻📚👍🏻 3y
TheSpineView I choose the same book! Great minds! 3y
Leniverse @TheSpineView I didn't have a lot to choose from with this prompt. 😅 I try to stick to books I own (and very often haven't read yet 😬) 3y
TheSpineView @Leniverse Yeah... I get that!📚📚📚 3y
Eggs 📚👍🏼👏🏻 3y
30 likes5 comments
blurb
TheSpineView
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

#BeginsWith @Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @Eggs
#Forever

I read this several years ago. A traditional military Sci-Fi story. Not as fluffy feeling as the newer space operas.

Eggs 💙🖤💙 3y
59 likes1 comment
review
ljmcm
Forever War | Joe Haldemann
Pickpick

An easy read that mashes war and time dilation well.

blurb
Twainy
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

I shouldn‘t buy the tagged book BUT it‘s only $5 BUT it‘s free on Hoopla BUT Book Club doesn‘t read this book for months what if it disappears like Netflix switches their line up, why do I have to justify spending $5, well to be fair that‘s per book & there‘s completely new books each day.

I LOVE seeing “Already Purchased”!! Audible, please only sell books I already own or don‘t want!

I listened to the sample. Bought 2 today.

#AudibleSale

review
bookishbitch
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Pickpick

This book is amazing! The world building is just incredible. So many things I have not seen done in other sci-fi books, and I've read quite a few. Written in 1974 by a Vietnam Veteran, it really tackles the insanity and futility of war. But it is also so much more. It had a very satisfying ending as well. I highly recommend this one. (Fair warning: it does have quite a bit of battle tactics described.)

iread2much This book was really awesome, fascinating and also unique. 4y
bookishbitch @iread2much Yes! You've summed it up perfectly. 4y
iread2much @bookishbitch 😄 you‘re too kind. Have you read A canticle for Leibowitz? It‘s long but also really interesting and from the same era. 4y
bookishbitch @iread2much No, but I will check that out. Thanks! 4y
iread2much @bookishbitch you‘re welcome! 4y
16 likes1 stack add5 comments
blurb
Angeles
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

Here is my book loot from the “library of baby brother “ it is great to get free books and know if I don‘t return them he STILL has to talk to me!😄

Scochrane26 My family and I borrow books from each other, too. 4y
8 likes1 comment
blurb
Eggs
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Klou Okay, this sounds really good. 4y
Eggs I haven‘t read it-hope you enjoy! @Klou 4y
Klou @Eggs ❤❤ 4y
57 likes3 comments
review
Danielthewriter
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Bailedbailed

QOTD- What are your feelings on military scifi?

Forever War is easy to read and has some strong world building, but unless you already know you love hard, military scifi, this one isn't worth trying.

5/10

review
TracyReadsBooks
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Pickpick

First published in the early 70s, this book is considered to be one of the exemplars of military science fiction & it‘s easy to see why. Written by a veteran of the Vietnam War, the depiction of war, in this case humans fighting an alien species light years away, is raw, visceral, & unrelenting. It‘s hours of boredom & travel & preparation punctuated by moments of frenetic action. A powerful story about the cost & futility of war.

blurb
TracyReadsBooks
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

With all our extra time at home, we decided to make our patio a little more comfy—a new couch, some pillows, and a couple little tables later and this is my new favorite reading spot. I especially love my new reading buddies! Finishing the tagged book this morning and then it‘s on to Harrow the Ninth.

RebelReader Looks so inviting! 4y
squirrelbrain So pretty! 💕 4y
LiteraryinPA Such a magical place! 4y
23 likes3 comments
blurb
TracyReadsBooks
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

John Scalzi describes this book as one of the two cornerstones of military science fiction (the other being Starship Troopers). I originally picked it up for my son who is a huge Scalzi fan. He read it and really enjoyed it which is recommendation enough for me.

17 likes1 stack add
blurb
TheSpineView
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

#JamminJune @Eggs
#Forever

This is the first book that came to mind. I think because I read not long ago. 📚📚🤩

Eggs Looks powerful 👌🏼 4y
48 likes1 comment
review
TheSpineView
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Mehso-so

I am really on the fence on this book. While I liked the plot and the pacing was good, it lacked the character development I crave. Also there was a lot of fight scenes, which is okay, but there was not much meat elsewhere to counter balance it. I was expecting so much more. Disappointed! 3.7ish stars

blurb
TheSpineView
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

#weekendreads @rachelsbrittain

1️⃣ Tagged
2️⃣ Both, just depends on my mood.
3️⃣ The Heart of the Matter by Evan Currie. It is book.#2 in the Odyssey One series and I read it in April.

blurb
TheSpineView
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

"Tonight we're going to show you eight silent ways to kill a man." And then the dragons arrived.

To play, add to the first line of the book thou are reading the phrase 'and then dragons arrived.'

Mine was not too interesting, but I bet some will be!

TieDyeDude I hope you're enjoying the book. I was impressed by it. The audio version was great. 5y
TheSpineView @TieDyeDude Not very far in, but so far I like it. 5y
56 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
InLibrisVeritas
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Pickpick

This was my first book finished in about 2 months, and while I definitely enjoyed reading again the book was only so-so. I loved the sci-fi elements, the time dialation and combat deployment being used to show how jarring it can be for soldiers to return home was intriguing. The war itself, while barely explained was also interesting. But the look on society was something that veered into cringe territory.

review
HighLordGugu
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
Mehso-so

It's ok. Weak ending.

blurb
writeropolis
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
review
Squidapus
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Pickpick

Squidapus often feels many "classics" people hail as cornerstones of literature are often products of their time and do not hold up over time. The Forever War is not one of those fallen classics. A very obvious parallel to the Vietnam War, it's story can still resonate to this day. Even without the greater themes it tackles it's just an entertaining read about a war over thousands of years that the people who started it never saw the end of.

review
2BR02B
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image
Pickpick

I can understand why this won the Hugo, Nebula, and Locus Awards, as it's quite wonderfully written- Haldeman's prose is efficient and utilitarian, managing to weave sophisticated concepts into the story while neither over-explaining to the reader or leaving them at sea. It would undoubtedly be a five star read if the dated attitudes towards sexuality weren't so uncomfortable to read, and profuse.

REPollock Ugh yes. It‘s jarring when you come across that kind of stuff in an otherwise great book. 7y
TieDyeDude Yes, excellent book. I don't remember the issues of sexuality being too jarring. Considering when it was written, I thought it was fairly progressive, unless I'm misremembering... 7y
2BR02B @GoodForCirculation I'm sure it was progressive at the time, but definitely not by today's standards. The protagonist describes himself as "tolerant," yet reiterates his disgust for "homolife" several times over the course of the book. 7y
See All 6 Comments
TieDyeDude @2BR02B Okay, that's what I remember. My read of it was that Mandella, and his view on homosexuality, were a product of the past, the time he came from, and the author was advocating sexual fluidity, almost challenging those who consider themselves tolerant to consider possible sexual norms in the eras he sends Mandella. 7y
2BR02B @GoodForCirculation I could almost buy that, except that the "happy ending" involved the MC and his lady love retiring to a hetero colony, and two of the gay characters being "straightened" and marrying one another. A bit too pat, in my opinion. 7y
TieDyeDude Well, who wants a bunch of old homophobes running around ruining everyone's good time? 😝 I don't remember the straightenings, though. That's unfortunate... 7y
53 likes6 comments
quote
2BR02B
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

Here's where the book really starts to date itself (it was published in 1974.)

A general is trying to convince soldiers to re-enlist instead of returning home to Earth, because homosexuality has become widespread and the men are all sissies now. 🙄

DGRachel Ugh 7y
42 likes1 stack add1 comment
blurb
2BR02B
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

1. Fran lookin' all nonchalant while hugging her tail.
2. About to start the tagged book for my IRL book club.
3. A soy latte and a chocolate-almond croissant.
4. A handful of pecans. I has tummyache.
5. I don't know. The cake is a lie.

#HumpDayPost @MinDea

rubyslippersreads 😻😻😻 7y
TricksyTails Fran‘s so beautiful! 😻 7y
AmyG Gorgeous cat. 7y
See All 6 Comments
CouronneDhiver Cake is a lie. Lol 7y
MinDea 😻😻😻 so cute. I love when they hold their tail. 7y
SassyBookworm She is beautiful!!! Love her eyes!!😻 7y
78 likes6 comments
review
tobypfrench
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
Pickpick

Those aliensm. Sheesh!

blurb
eshchory
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
post image

Some of the attitudes make me cringe they are so dated and it is worse when he is trying to be open-minded but the story-telling is thrilling and I care enough about the characters to keep turning the pages.

review
LSDuigi
The Forever War | Joe Haldeman
Pickpick

When I finally made the effort to get into the Vietnam-era war mentality, and set aside all of my "well, that's clearly dated" snap-judgments, Forever War turned in to one of my all-time favorite books (genre nonspecific), and ended up being 1/3 of one of the best SciFi trilogies that I've ever read... Sure, you can clearly tell that the author was drawing upon that Vietnam, GI Joe, must-kill-Charlie headspace from the time, but it was so great