Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Why Didn't They Ask Evans?
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
The puzzling question of a dying man leads two friends into a complex and dangerous investigation
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Jen2
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

This was really good!

KathyWheeler I liked the show too. 13mo
62 likes1 comment
blurb
Sharpeipup
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image

Walking into a tree would definitely make a trail “more difficult”. 😂

#audiobook #audiohike

Tamra 😂 14mo
30 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
Scochrane26
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

A pretty good stand-alone Christie with some actual danger to the MCs. Bobby is with a dying man after they think he accidentally falls off a cliff. He & his friend Frankie start investigating after some other events.

review
Tineke
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

This was one of my oldest books. It was an enjoyable story. Not quite the same like the Hercule Poirot or Miss Marple series, but there was still a mystery at its center, which I didn't guess ahead of time.
TBR since May 19th. 2010; 191 pages.

review
Linsy
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

I know I asked for more plucky heroines, but I missed my Poirot! This one was cute and fun, but had almost nothing to do with golf. That cover misled me.

And thus ends my Agatha Christie week! The husband is back and I finished 8 Christies and started ABC Murders (once I finish I'll be all caught up with #agathachristieclubr2). The children refused to let me read much, so I mostly listened. Hugh Fraser and Joan Hickson are just perfection!

77 likes1 stack add
review
ImperfectCJ
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Mehso-so

This one reads a bit like a farce, with some fairly ridiculous characters and a pretty unlikely plot. The tone actually reminded me a little of Cold Comfort Farm. Enjoyable, I suppose, but not one I expect to return to.

review
batsy
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Mehso-so

I continue to make my way through the #agathachristieclub reads in chronological order, & this surfaced as one of the Christies I don't think I've read before. It's a standalone mystery--no Marple, Poirot, or Tommy & Tuppence--& it's pretty fun. Irreverent, lively, with a fizz & zest about it as befitting a novel featuring amateur detectives of the "bright young things" era. However, the mystery itself was a bit of a dud & did nothing for me.

shawnmooney This was the last Agatha Christie I read, and the last I will ever read; in fact, let‘s go out on a limb and say it was the last murder mystery I shall ever, ever read! 🤣🤣 3y
batsy @shawnmooney Definitely not your cup of tea 😆 3y
Ruthiella I‘m not a huge fan of this kind of Christie where the crime is less solved than stumbled upon by perky young folk. Still, I enjoy the ride. 😀 3y
See All 6 Comments
Billypar I've never even heard of this one! It's an odd title - I can't tell whether I like it or not. 3y
batsy @Ruthiella "stumbled upon by perky young folk"—that's a perfect description! 3y
batsy @Billypar It is! I think that's why I've avoided it all this while 😂 3y
100 likes2 stack adds6 comments
review
galueth28
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

The mistery definetely isn't one of Dame Agatha's best, but I loved the plucky heroine and the sense of adventure.

review
janeycanuck
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

I really enjoy when Christie writes a young woman detective. And it was nice to get back to a novel after so many short stories. This did have a couple of really ridiculous reaches but generally was a fun romp.

28 likes2 stack adds
blurb
ferskner
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image

4. The 1980 adaptation of this novel was the first authorized adaptation in decades, after a few failed attempts during Christie's life that soured her to the idea. This lead to all the classic BBC adaptations we love today: Poirot, Miss Marple, Tommy and Tuppence. Why do you think this novel was selected? How does it lend itself well to adaptation over other, more famous works?

#agathachristieclubR2

TheAromaofBooks I haven't seen the adaptation of this one, but as a standalone it's a fun place to start because you don't have to worry about “ruining“ any of Christie's more famous characters. There are lots of disguises & shenanigans in this one, plus the dramatic insane asylum, so I can see it being a fun one to choose. 4y
ferskner @TheAromaofBooks yeah I'd agree with everything you said. It kind of feels like a soft launch rather than swinging for the fences. A lot of the early adaptations were Christie's thrillers or more comedic mysteries, and I wonder if that has to do with what was popular in the culture at the time. I don't know! 4y
janeycanuck Yup, what @TheAromaofBooks said... there‘s lots going on, some good light stuff, some@good dark stuff... and the humour would be really appealing for a lot of people, too. Plus, you don‘t have to feel like you‘re missing something if you haven‘t seen the other movies with that character. 4y
41 likes1 stack add3 comments
blurb
ferskner
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image

3. How do Frankie and Bobby stack up against Tommy and Tuppence? #agathachristieclubR2

Laughterhp I liked them better than Tommy and Tuppence 😬😬😬 though I might be biased because I didn‘t like the first Tommy and tuppence novel but I liked the second one I read. 4y
TheAromaofBooks Sadly I can't like anyone better than Tommy & Tuppence but I did love Frankie & Bobby's lighthearted banter. I'd love to get the four of them together 😂 @Laughterhp 4y
Laughterhp I might have to give Tommy and Tuppence another chance. I‘ve only read one book with them! @TheAromaofBooks 4y
ferskner @Laughterhp @TheAromaofBooks I like Tommy and Tuppence more but to be honest I confuse them in my head very often! Probably because the same actors play both couples. This feels like it could have easily been a T and T novel. 4y
janeycanuck @TheAromaofBooks @Laughterhp @ferskner hmmm, yes, I agree this could have been a T&T novel. I don‘t think I can decide which I like more... 4y
31 likes5 comments
blurb
ferskner
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image

2. Christie uses the light tone from her international intrigue novels and applies it to a more straightforward mystery. Did you this this hybrid was successful? What other similarities did you find to her light thrillers? #agathachristieclubR2

TheAromaofBooks When Christie is being funny & snarky, that's when I like her best. I really enjoyed the somewhat absurd ideas of disguise & intrigue that our two “detectives“ pulled off. 4y
ferskner @TheAromaofBooks I do like her portrayal of the Bright Young Things so I liked that she used them for a regular mystery. I don't really like the plots of her thrillers, so I felt like I was getting the best of both worlds. 4y
janeycanuck @TheAromaofBooks @ferskner Yes, I like when the snark comes out, too. I enjoyed the lighter feel of this mystery. 4y
29 likes3 comments
blurb
ferskner
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image

It's time for our March #agathachristieclubR2 book discussion! Only one week late with the questions, haha!

As always, please look at all the following posts for the rest of the questions, and please tag anyone who has already commented to keep the discussion going.

1. Did you enjoy this book? Why or why not?

Laughterhp Yes! I really liked this one. I accidentally read it in January because my list was off, but I thought this was a really good mystery and it kept me guessing the whole time. 4y
MaleficentBookDragon How can I get in on this? I‘m a huge Christie fan. 4y
See All 9 Comments
rubyslippersreads I didn‘t get to this one but will try to join in this month. 😊 4y
janeycanuck I‘ve been reading the short stories released in the UK so haven‘t picked this up yet. Maybe this weekend! 4y
TheAromaofBooks I quite enjoyed this one - the fun banter reminded me of Tommy & Tuppence! @Laughterhp 4y
TheAromaofBooks @MaleficentBookDragon - We are reading through Christie's books in published order, one a month, & then have some discussion questions (some months later than others haha). April's book is Parker Pyne Investigates & May's book is Murder in Three Acts - @ferksner is in charge of the tag list & posting the questions!! 4y
ferskner @Laughterhp @TheAromaofBooks I liked this one, probably better than The Seven Dials Mystery, which I always confuse this one for. I like that it's more of a mystery than a thriller but retains the scrappiness. @MaleficentBookDragon I hope you'll jump in! You just read the book and then look for the #agathachristieclubR2 tag for questions. I'll put up the May questions shortly. 4y
janeycanuck @Laughterhp @TheAromaofBooks @ferskner Oops, I read this ages ago and forgot to come back and answer the questions... I quite liked this one, too. It did have Tommy & Tuppence vibes, didn‘t it? Also, I‘ve been reading the short stories that weren‘t published in the US and man, there‘s some overt racism that I was happy to mostly leave behind in this one. 4y
29 likes9 comments
blurb
TheAromaofBooks
The Boomerang Clue | Agatha Christie
post image

#BookReport - Pretty good progress this week. Strangely, being busy at work has led to more reading - I'm just too tired to want to do anything more difficult than sitting on the couch in the evenings 😂 Quidditch & Prince Caspian are my ongoing chapter-a-day reads & I'm enjoying both. I didn't review Defiant Dreams, which was an absolutely absurd little romance about a southern belle sent north during the ⬇

TheAromaofBooks (cont'd) Civil War where she falls in love with a Union soldier. The scandal! (Except not really, it was honestly a pretty boring book considering the setting.) Heartstone was really intense, so when I finished that yesterday I picked up a P&P variation on Kindle Unlimited & I feel a little binge of those coming on this week. Need to get my April reading sorted out & post my #BookSpin list!!

@Cinfhen
4y
Cinfhen Yay!!! Awesome reading week!! 4y
86 likes2 comments
review
TheAromaofBooks
The Boomerang Clue | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

Another fun read for #AgathaChristieClubR2 - I really enjoyed this little romp although there were a few things that left me scratching my head haha (I'll put my biggest question in a spoiler below). This one is AKA Why Didn't They Ask Evans? and that title probably makes more sense. Not only was this my #DoubleSpin for March, it took me to my first stop in Wales (Denbighshire) for #SeparatedbyaPondTour !! @Andrew65

TheAromaofBooks For me, the real question is - Why didn't they KILL Evans?! They knew where she was & what she knew & were terrified that Bobby was going to talk to her... it just seems like the obvious solution for people who have no issues bumping people off?? 4y
Andrew65 Well done 👏👏👏 Wales can be the hardest to get to. (edited) 4y
TheAromaofBooks @Andrew65 - Thank you!! I was pretty excited when Christie specified where in Wales they were since she doesn't always do so! 😂 4y
Andrew65 @TheAromaofBooks Annoying when a book isn‘t specific. Don‘t they realise we are doing challenges 🤣 4y
72 likes4 comments
blurb
TheAromaofBooks
The Boomerang Clue | Agatha Christie
post image

#WeeklyForecast - another busy week ahead!! I'm starting new books for #PotteraDay & #NarniaReadalong & hoping to read the tagged for #AgathaChristieClubR2 (its aka is Why Didn't They Ask Evans?) I only have one short story left in Don't Look Now, but I am not sure I am going to get to my reread of Rebecca this month after all. Can't believe it's time to start reserving April reads at the library!!!

@Cinfhen

Cinfhen Woohoo!!! April #bookspin is on the horizon 🌈🙌🏻💕🎉 4y
TheAromaofBooks @Cinfhen - I can't believe how fast it is coming!!! I need to post the reminder this week already! 😲 4y
TheAromaofBooks @Cinfhen - I can't believe how fast it is coming!!! I need to post the reminder this week already! 😲 4y
Ruthiella I like that edition of Rebecca! 😀 4y
TheAromaofBooks @Ruthiella - Thank you!! It's actually a first edition from back in the day when “library editions“ were a thing. Printed in 1938 & has been read so many times that the page edges are all soft & worn - I love it!! 4y
79 likes5 comments
review
Laughterhp
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

I‘m still going through Christie‘s work chronologically. I‘m not sure if the #agathachristieclubR2 is still going, but 🤷🏻‍♀️ I‘m still going to read all of Christie.

This one was really good! So clever. I loved Bobby and Frankie. Such a great mystery she unraveled here.

#BookSpinBingo

Reagan I‘ve never read her! I should pick one up, maybe this one! 4y
Laughterhp @Reagan I definitely recommend her! Her really popular and usually favorite is 4y
janeycanuck I‘m a book behind but am still with you on the #agathachristieclubr2 train! 4y
See All 10 Comments
Linsy @janeycanuck Ditto! I‘m still with y‘all! I‘m a bit behind, but I thought this month was Edgware, Evans in March. What list are you following? (edited) 4y
Laughterhp @Linsy Oh, maybe I‘m a month ahead. I accidentally read Edgware early not even realizing it. I‘m just looking online at the Agatha Christie website and I‘m skipping over the short story collaborations with other authors. 4y
janeycanuck @Laughterhp @Laughterhp I‘ve got Lord Edgeware dies for Jan, Hound of Death for Feb and Murder on the Orient Express for March. I don‘t have Evans until May... I‘m using a list from the Agatha Christie website (https://storage.googleapis.com/agatha-christie-assets/archive/pdfs/christie-reading-list.pdf) 4y
Laughterhp @janeycanuck Weird that list is a little different. I‘ve been going off of this. The Hound of Death isn‘t even on my list that I can see. https://www.agathachristie.com/stories 4y
janeycanuck @Laughterhp if you go down to the very bottom of that page, there‘s a PDF - that‘s the list I linked above. I think you aren‘t seeing Hound of Death because it‘s short stories and that‘s only showing novels? 4y
Linsy @janeycanuck i‘ve been reading off of that PDF as well, but skipping the months with short stories. Glad y‘all are still reading along with me!☺️ 4y
janeycanuck @Linsy I‘m on Tuesday Club Murders now and it‘s pretty good - though I‘m not generally a short story person. 4y
66 likes10 comments
review
MommyWantsToReadHerBook
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
Pickpick

Enjoyable as always. Funnier than I remembered! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

31 likes1 stack add
blurb
MommyWantsToReadHerBook
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image

Completely broken emotionally, so another AC reread on my phone it is.

review
DGRachel
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

I didn‘t have high hopes for this one as I usually dislike Emilia Fox‘s narration, but she wasn‘t as obnoxious as with the Marple books, and Bobby and Frankie were absolutely delightful sleuths. They reminded me of Tommy and Tuppence, who I adore. Plenty of red herrings to keep the reader guessing as well.

59 likes1 stack add
blurb
umbrellagirl
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image

If I keep reading the eBooks I‘ve downloaded, I might run out of reading material and have to buy new books, right? #myyearwithagatha

53 likes1 stack add
review
veritysalter
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

An accident, suicide or murder? When Bobby finds the body of a man at the base of a cliff, the strange question posed by the dying man sends him on a quest to discover the truth. A solid Agatha Christie, with twists and turns and clues galore.

Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks I‘ve never read any of her books!! 😳😲 5y
veritysalter @Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks you must, she takes you to another time, her mysteries are always so meticulous, but all the clues are there. Definitely my favourite author. 5y
14 likes2 comments
quote
veritysalter
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image

My boy is playing football (soccer) in this awful weather, I‘m hiding in my car with an Agatha Christie and a coffee. #GloriousBritishWeather #AgathaChristie #BadMum #LoveToRead

review
ferskner
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

I remember watching the adaptation for this and finding the solution so intriguing. It's not great Christie, but, as usual, it satisfies. #agathachristieclub @Bambolina_81 #pop19 #bookwithaquestioninthetitle

64 likes1 stack add
review
VictoriaB
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
Pickpick

No Poirot or Miss Marple in this one! This mystery involves two amateur sleuths investigating the death of a mysterious stranger and his final words. Not one of Christie‘s best, but still a fun read.

blurb
TaciturnWhenReading
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image

So much down time at a swim meet. Guilt free afternoon of reading with periodic breaks for cheering on the girl!

CoverToCoverGirl Perfect! 😊 6y
53 likes1 comment
review
Rachbb3
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

I love the Poirot and Miss Marple books but her stand alone stories are remarkable.

92 likes1 stack add
blurb
Rachbb3
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image

Trying to finish this one up tonight. 🍷😊

blurb
Rachbb3
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image

Up next.....Dame Agatha ❤

mabell Love this one! 6y
jenreads7 Ooh! I‘ve never heard of this one! 6y
Jaimelire Never heard of this one. Stacking! 6y
97 likes1 stack add3 comments
review
rwmg
Pickpick

A stand alone which I thought was going to be a Poirot so I was even more off the track than usual.

blurb
rwmg
post image

😁

blurb
rwmg
post image

Appropriate reading for the Olivier Cafe, scene of a murder that had the whole country agog for months

review
Marybook
post image
Pickpick

It was a good one! I loved Bobby and Frankie and it was well written 🙂 Right now I just enjoy reading every Agatha Christie Book I can get my hands on 😂📚😍

umbrellagirl She is wonderful. 7y
Marybook @umbrellagirl That is true 😊 7y
Sarah83 Never heard of this one... 7y
Marybook @Sarah83 Neither did I but a friend found it in a small Shop in Paris a couple of months ago ! I could not resist 😂 7y
Sarah83 Looks great 😍 7y
13 likes5 comments
blurb
rabbitprincess
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image

I get really annoyed with the more recent ITV adaptations of Marple. They add Marple to stories she's not in, then while they're at it they change the murderer, change the motive, add ridiculous subplots, and in the case of Evans, DELETE characters but then ADD DIFFERENT ONES. WHAT IS THE POINT OF THAT 😡 JUST WRITE YOUR OWN DAMN 1930s MYSTERIES and leave Agatha's name out of it!
#emojinov day 11: 😡

Nebklvr That seems like hiring a pro for a job and then turning it over to an amateur 7y
Rachbb3 Agreed!!! 7y
rabbitprincess @Nebklvr @Rachbb3 I can understand adding Marple, I guess, because she would be considered more easily marketable, but everything else is ridiculous. The source material is fine! They hardly need to do any work. 7y
rwmg 😡😡 7y
33 likes4 comments
review
brennahawleycraig
The Boomerang Clue | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

Freaking finally...finished my first book of October! And it might not look like much, but this is the first night in 19 days this floor isn't covered with our mattress. We get to sleep in our bedroom and construction is done! 🙌

batsy Great cover. I had to look it up and didn't know Why Didn't They Ask Evans? was published with this title! 7y
brennahawleycraig @batsy the title only makes sense at the very end of the book! It was the only version I could find on Abe Books so I went for it. A great book! 7y
30 likes2 comments
blurb
brennahawleycraig
The Boomerang Clue | Agatha Christie
post image

Yesterday's post-client presentation golf course view.

blurb
brennahawleycraig
The Boomerang Clue | Agatha Christie
post image

Finished one book on the plane, brought a trusty Agatha to dive into for fun.

blurb
TitleSpines
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image

Just washed my hair with Curley Whirley A Coconut Shampoo by Lush. Feels and smells beautiful. #lush #organic #vegan #coconut #agathachristie #crime #girlswhoread #booknerd #pretty #books

review
mabell
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
Pickpick

A really terrific and unpredictable Christie mystery! Much as I love Poirot and Miss Marple, it was refreshing to have the investigation taken on by 2 young friends, complete amateurs, in the English countryside.

review
krpotts
Why Didn't They Ask Evans? | Agatha Christie
post image
Pickpick

Wonderfully fun story that I finished on a flight to Dublin. Was so totally absorbed in the mystery and its twists and turns that I was pleased to have all the time to dedicate to it without stopping. If you're looking for a quick, fun read then look no further!

10 likes1 stack add