Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
16 posts | 13 read | 12 to read
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
quote
Singout
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image

What no one will ever understand is that the world belongs to orphans. Everything becomes our mother. We are mothered by everything because we know how to look for the mothering. Because we know a mother might leave us, and we‘ll need another mother to step in and take its place. The tree mothering its shade. The restaurant door, slightly open, mothering its smell of cookies to us. A blinking walk sign, holding on to mother us across the street.

blurb
Singout
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar

#Bookspin
1. Saving Time
2. The covenant of water
3. The covenant of water
4. Thank You Mr Nixon
5. Thank You Mr Nixon
6. In My Own Moccasins
7. An Immense World
8. Fresh water for flowers
9. H is for Hawk
10. Saving Time
11. H is for Hawk
12. Swimming in the Dark
13. Afraid of the Sky
14. Afraid of the Sky
15. The Bandit Queens
16. Big Men Fear Me
17. How Much of These Hills
18. Some People Need Killing
19. Greenwood
20. Swimming in the Dark

review
AbstractMonica
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image
Pickpick

This was a random pick from the library. Three Pakistani sisters living in America, orphaned after both their parents pass away. They live in a dire situation with their uncle who has adopted them. Their pain and need for belonging creates a distance between them as they get older. It was very beautifully written.. full of poetry and prose. Really loved it.

review
Cinfhen
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image
Mehso-so

I wanted to love this book but the interesting format ( a cross between poetry and Mad Libs) left me with a mostly detached feeling. It was also very sad with no moments of happiness which was another reason I never warmed to the story. It‘s a so-so for me but others have really enjoyed so maybe give it a try if you‘re curious. The cover art is STUNNING 🤩 Thank you dear @BarbaraBB for gifting me this one 😘It‘s my #DoubleSpin @TheAromaofBooks

BarbaraBB I always dread books without any lightness or happiness too. Thinking of you, 2y
Cinfhen This wasn‘t as dreadful as Shuggie @BarbaraBB but it was pretty relentless 😥 2y
TheAromaofBooks Did the book have you fill in your own adjectives or something?? I'm intrigued by the Mad Libs aspect 😂 2y
See All 9 Comments
Megabooks Very curious about this one, but I haven‘t been compelled to get it yet. Maybe I‘ll hold off. 2y
Cinfhen I would have sent you my copy but I already donated it to the charity bookshop where I volunteer @Megabooks 2y
Megabooks Thanks for thinking of me friend. I think it‘s okay. Maybe my library has it, but it‘s way down on my priorities. 🤷🏻‍♀️ interesting because it won the shield‘s prize that was just announced at Parnassus. 2y
Cinfhen I know and @Reviewsbylola LOVED it @Megabooks 🤷🏼‍♀️ 2y
Megabooks Yes!! Steph has been reading a lot different books than she used to. I‘m enjoying seeing the classics and poetry she‘s picked up, but I especially like that she‘s into short stories now!! 😁😁 2y
Cinfhen Yeah/ I noticed that too @Megabooks I miss all the Darguach Girls!!!! 2y
69 likes9 comments
blurb
shawnmooney
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image

I‘m currently reading this book, and I have read enough to say this prestigious prize is richly deserved! 👏👏🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍⚧️

review
rmaclean4
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image
Mehso-so

This novel of three orphaned sisters did not work for me. It has been nominated and shortlisted for a couple of awards (Carol Sheilds and Aspen Words.). I wonder if listening to the novel rather than physically reading it hurt my connection with the novel. I had trouble distinguishing the sisters. 2.5 🌟

CollapsingLibrary I find it difficult to do books with multiple POV hard as audio, especially so if the tones/voices aren‘t very distinct. 2y
21 likes1 comment
review
JackieGreco
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
Pickpick

I enjoyed the story and unique perspective of the novel. This book wasn‘t written traditionally, but it helped bring the story of the three sisters to life. 4/5

review
Ellen_C
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image
Pickpick

A novel about orphans that focuses on their grief. Kausar and her sisters have lost their mother to illness, their father to murder. Now Uncle has taken them in but he really leaves them alone most of the time. Kausar‘s sorrow and anger run through the story and her life. https://cannonballread.com/2023/03/when-we-were-sisters-a-novel-elcicco/

quote
eve
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image

Incredible, honest book. Manages to be kind and tender even as it hurts so openly.

Pinta Loved this! Convincing child‘s voice is tough to nail, and Asghar gets it. 2y
4 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
KristiAhlers
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image
Pickpick

Have Kleenex handy. This is part of #TimeMagazinesTop100ReadsOf2022 and I totally understand why this was on that list. This story touches on what it means to be orphaned and left to struggle with identity, religion, sexuality and what it means to be America when you‘re half Pakistani. #bookspin @TheAromaofBooks

TheAromaofBooks Great progress!! 2y
46 likes2 stack adds1 comment
review
RebelReader
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image
Mehso-so

This pretty much sums up my reading for the first week of 2023. I bailed on my first book and I probably only finished the tagged one because it‘s my #doublebookspin and just to vent I‘ve been battling a head cold all week. Things are looking up though with The Violin Conspiracy. I should finish today and I‘m enjoying it. Might be my favorite so far on the #ToBshort list. Im also listening to Dopesick which is interesting too.

squirrelbrain I think The Violin Conspiracy is my favourite on the list so far too. 2y
Chelsea.Poole I‘ve heard very good things about The Violin Conspiracy…waiting for my audio hold to become available! 2y
BarbaraBB I am glad to have a TOB book that I can look forward to 😀 2y
See All 7 Comments
Suet624 For some reason I didn't even realize this was on the short list. Good to know you enjoyed it. 2y
Megabooks I wasn‘t a huge fan of Violin, but most people seemed to connect with it. Good luck! 2y
Hooked_on_books I loved this one. It‘s one of my top books of 2022. I‘m glad you‘re enjoying it, too! 2y
TheAromaofBooks Ugh, I hate it when I have a run of meh books. Hope you feel better soon!!! 2y
55 likes7 comments
blurb
TheBookDream
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image

Thank you @erank58 for my #JolabokaflodSwap gifts! The books looks amazing and I love Hersheys! Thanks so much! @MaleficentBookDragon

erank58 So glad you enjoyed your package! I hope you like the book I picked! 2y
32 likes1 comment
quote
Pinta
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image

^^ p 95 orphans finding maternal care in the WORLD— “What no one will ever understand is that the world belongs to orphans, everything becomes our mother.”

P 65 “She laughs and it paints the room.”

P 25 “Us three, a band of adventurers—making our own rules, deciding what it‘s gonna be.”

review
Pinta
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image
Pickpick

Really loved this. Capturing a convincing child‘s voice is so difficult, and Asghar does it so well in Kausar—the vulnerability, the ferocity, the need for care and the pull of independence. Youngest of three orphaned Muslim American girls taken in by a neglectful uncle, ultimately end up raising themselves. Gorgeous observations in lyrical prose. Found family. Bunk beds. Coming of age. Cultural & sexual identity. Survival. “Make it last.” 2022

review
Hooked_on_books
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image
Pickpick

When three Pakistani-American sisters are orphaned, their lives are thrown into disarray. An uncle is assigned as their guardian but “neglectful” doesn‘t come close to describing it. We mainly hear the voice of the youngest sister as the three support each other as they grow up. This is really good—I hope it gets more widely read.

59 likes5 stack adds
review
Mpcacher
WHEN WE WERE SISTERS | Fatimah Asghar
post image
Pickpick

This is a heartbreaking story of three orphaned American sisters taken in by a greedy uncle. Told in a lyrical style (the author is a published poet), it is beautifully written, but not always easy to follow. We follow the life of the youngest to adulthood and although it has been described as a coming of age story, I felt the character had still not found themselves at the story's end. I enjoyed it, but prefer clear prose to poetry. 3.5/5