Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Manhattan Girls
The Manhattan Girls | Gill Paul
74 posts | 19 read | 6 to read
NEW YORK CITY, 1921
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
vlwelser
post image
Mehso-so

This book was perfectly acceptable until the last quarter where it seems like the author either got bored or was having a hot flash. Because yikes.

#BookSpinBingo @TheAromaofBooks

#SundayBuddyRead @TheBookHippie

TheBookHippie 💯💯💯🫣🫨😵‍💫🥴🤯 6mo
5feet.of.fury 🤣 6mo
TheAromaofBooks Oh dear haha 6mo
tpixie Oh dear. Starting it now for bookclub. I can‘t wait to see what you mean! 😢 😬😳 5mo
44 likes4 comments
blurb
Read4life
post image

#WorstRead

No surprise here. This was an easy choice. @TheBookHippie 😵‍💫😵‍💫😵‍💫

julesG Oh. It's that time of the month. 😁😁 I'll have to find my stinker of the month then. 6mo
Billypar I have to ask about UPP because it's on my TBR. Was it a writing issue, poorly researched, or both? 😬 6mo
Read4life @Billypar it just wasn‘t anything new for me. I had to force myself to pick it up. Due to health circumstances, I‘ve been educated on UPF and this book just didn‘t keep my attention. Others found it interesting and rated it highly. 6mo
48 likes3 comments
review
Karisa
post image
Mehso-so

Pros: Learned of some cool women from the 1920s like Winifred Lenihan, Margaret Leech, and Jane Grant. Always love dissecting books with #SundayBuddyRead 💗

Cons: The author took way too much liberty with these real lives. Too much fiction to be historical fiction for me. Almost slandered Dorothy Parker whose work I love. Disappointing!

review
Sargar114
This post contains spoilers
show me
post image
Panpan

I don‘t know much about Dorothy Parker and it‘s a shame this was my first introduction. Frankly, even if they were fictional characters I don‘t know that I would have cared for this one still. It was a struggle to finish and really dealt with trigger topics such as sexual assault, abortion, and suicide quite poorly. Finished to continue the discussion with #sundaybuddyread which (as usual) was the best thing to come of this.

review
mcctrish
post image
Pickpick

#sundaybuddyread that I‘d never heard of 🤷🏻‍♀️ it was a fast and easy read ❤️ Dorothy Parker was my least favourite of the bridge club girls, but she lived her life out loud and I am so glad I read this book

review
Read4life
post image
Panpan

This could have been great. Such a fantastic group to base a historical novel on but the author really blew it. It was both disappointing and maddening.

#SUNDAYBUDDYREAD @TheBookHippie

DebinHawaii Ack! I am so far behind from travel last week & being sick all week this week I haven‘t even checked out the discussion. Now I‘m not sure I want to catch up! 🫣😆 6mo
48 likes3 comments
review
IndoorDame
post image
Panpan

JUST, NO

The first 250 pages, a fun historical fiction story, lots of problematic pieces, but I was happily able to put aside my irritation with the author and enjoy the story for what it was.

Last 250 pages, my irritation redoubled and compounded and I can‘t remember the last time I‘ve finished a book quite this angry at the author.

#sundaybuddyread

review
Librarybelle
This post contains spoilers
show me
post image
Mehso-so

This is a little hard to review. On the surface, this is a good story about female friendships in the 1920s and follows them as they navigate Prohibition, depression, suicidal thoughts, and women‘s reproductive health.

I came to this book with a very basic knowledge of Dorothy Parker and her group of friends. The nuances of the 1920s is fun to read. However, after participating in the #SundayBuddyRead ⬇️⬇️⬇️

Librarybelle ⬆️⬆️⬆️there are flaws. And, maybe characterizations that are not accurate to real life. There is a balance that historical fiction authors should follow to capture the essence of the real life character without completely fabricating the character…dialogues are fine, but completely changing a persona is wrong. It seems this is the case for this book. I liked the story, but feels it has to be a so-so rating. 6mo
17 likes1 comment
blurb
DebinHawaii
post image

Playing catch up with #SundayBuddyRead over lunch. (Ginger tataki ahi poke & chips). Having a slow day getting over jet lag & getting ready for the week.

slategreyskies I‘m doing the same thing this afternoon, only not with such delicious treats! Enjoy! 6mo
51 likes1 comment
blurb
BarkingMadRead
post image

Reading at the airport 😍 finishing this today!

Bookwormjillk Did you have a spoon malfunction? 6mo
BarkingMadRead @Bookwormjillk good eye! I snapped it trying to open the wrapping and was too lazy to get another one 🤣 6mo
53 likes1 stack add3 comments
blurb
BarkingMadRead
post image

Hey #sundaybuddyread gang! I‘m reading Taste by Stanley Tucci and he used a Dorothy Parker quote! @TheBookHippie

tpixie 😂 funny quote!!! I love the coinkydink of you reading 2 books with a quote from the same person!!!! The stars align! 🌟 6mo
43 likes1 comment
blurb
mcctrish
post image

Speakeasy vibes for #sundaybuddyread #iykyk that‘s a delightful pink gin fizz in my tea cup, I‘m channeling Jane and her tasty bathtub gin

Tamra I‘ve never had a pink smashed gin, but I want to try it! 💓 (edited) 6mo
mcctrish @Tamra it‘s delicious 6mo
tpixie Oh my! I love gin! I want some. Your cup is delightful! What a great way to enjoy yourself! 6mo
See All 8 Comments
tpixie Is the gin pink? Or is that pink lemonade? 6mo
mcctrish @tpixie it‘s a pink gin fizz : gin, sparkling water, lemon and raspberry and absolutely delicious 6mo
kspenmoll That delicious drink in a teacup sounds splendid! 6mo
tpixie @mcctrish thx!! 6mo
TheBookHippie Love it!!! 6mo
50 likes2 stack adds8 comments
blurb
Sargar114
post image

This week‘s section of #sundaybuddyread was INTENSE! Pretty graphic triggers but I‘m sure will make for quite the discussion. I‘m still wrapping my head around it 🤐

AmyG Oh man, Dottie. 😳 6mo
Read4life Well said. 😳🤔 6mo
14 likes2 comments
blurb
BarkingMadRead
post image

I love when a storm rolls in, I‘m porch sitting until the rain starts. It always seems to soak the porch immediately 🙄 I would love to sit out here in the rain!

IndoorDame The light is spectacular! Thank you for sharing the photo! I wish you could stay out there! 6mo
TheBookgeekFrau Oh good, I'm not the only one with a covered porch that doesn't stay dry 😅😆 6mo
BarkingMadRead @TheBookgeekFrau so frustrating!! As soon as the rain starts, it gets soaked! 6mo
Cathythoughts Looks lovely where you are. ❤️ 6mo
BarkingMadRead @Cathythoughts our neighborhood is really nice, and with all the rain, it‘s also very green! 6mo
48 likes5 comments
blurb
Read4life
post image

That‘s a wrap on #WickedWords for May.

AsYouWish Yay!!! Good job!!!!💙💙💙💙 6mo
45 likes1 comment
blurb
Read4life
post image
blurb
Read4life
post image
blurb
Karisa
post image

Wow! Learned this from #SundayBuddyRead video link from @TheBookHippie today. I didn‘t realize just how cool Dorothy Parker was before! https://youtu.be/ud3-3-SPW-A?si=xHDMJ_2FUWfJiF8F

Jas16 I had no idea. Love her even more now. 6mo
Karisa @Jas16 I know right?! 🥰 6mo
Sargar114 So cool! 6mo
49 likes3 comments