Hello #FurrowedMiddlebrowClub! It is up to me to make the March 2022 pick. Please help me decide between these two Margery Sharp options. I‘ll keep the voting open till Friday. Thanks!
rubyslippersreads, quietjenn, erzascarletbookgasm, catebutler, CarolynM, LeahBergen, elkeOriginal, BookNAround, batsy, Tamra, sarahbellum, Cathythoughts, SamanthaMarieBookNAround I don‘t have either of these Sharps but I promptly added both to my wishlist after reading about them so I‘d be happy with either. Helpful, aren‘t I? 😂 3y
catebutler I have both on my TBR, so I‘m perfectly okay with either being read. 💓 3y
LeahBergen Yay for Margery Sharp! 👏👏 I‘ll pick the one that‘s sitting on my shelves (Rhododendron Pie), but you KNOW I‘ll be buying Four Gardens, too. 3y
See All 38 Comments
Tamra I like the descriptions of both! Which do you prefer?! 😆 3y
elkeOriginal Four Gardens! (I already read Pie🤦🏼♀️) (edited) 3y
rubyslippersreads I‘ve read both, but it‘s been ages since I read Four Gardens, so I vote for that one. 3y
LeahBergen @elkeOriginal @rubyslippersreads Well, I see I should just go ahead and order Four Gardens right now. It only seems polite, right? 😉 3y
quietjenn Like @elkeOriginal, I‘m voting for Four Gardens because I‘ve already read Rhododendron Pie. Another reason to place that order. @LeahBergen 😆 3y
elkeOriginal @LeahBergen ORDER IT 3y
elkeOriginal Has the group read Sharp‘s Stone of Chastity?![[tagged book]](https://image.librarything.com/pics/litsy_webpics/icon_taggedBook@3x.png)
Stone of Chastity 3y
Stone of ChastityelkeOriginal Now I see Litsy has no description on Stone…SIGH. 3y
Ruthiella @elkeOriginal Not yet. We‘ll put you on the roster for July 2022 and you can pick after @batsy who has the May 2022 pick. 3y
batsy I've not read either one and both sound lovely, so I'm happy to go with Four Gardens! I'm always eager for a garden-y novel 🙂 3y
LeahBergen @elkeOriginal I haven‘t read it but I have a really cool old edition of it! 3y
LeahBergen @Ruthiella Good plan! 👍 I was just thinking that we should do a reorganization of our voting list after our first cycle ends with @batsy ‘s pick. And we‘ll see who wants to stay or who wants to be added. It will make tagging easier. 😆 3y
elkeOriginal @LeahBergen I have NO doubt your edition will make me wildly jealous 😉 3y
elkeOriginal @Ruthiella I am honored to be on the roster so soon! 😊 I will be on vacation (hopefully) most of July so am happy to take the one after that instead! (edited) 3y
elkeOriginal @LeahBergen @Ruthiella After batsy‘s pick can someone do a post of all the titles you covered so far as a group? Then we will know what is still to be read! 3y
CarolynM I'm very happy with either of the 2. I'm going to order them both, anyway 🙂 I like your plan for the group going forward @LeahBergen I so enjoy reading these over books with everyone. 3y
LeahBergen @elkeOriginal Sure! I can make a post/list as I (nerdily) have them written down in my reading journal. 😆 Oh, and I‘m not sure if I mentioned it but we only do a book every two months. (edited) 3y
LeahBergen @CarolynM I love this group, too! 😊 3y
erzascarletbookgasm I‘m glad to be reading my first Margery Sharp! Both descriptions sound good, I‘ll go for R Pie 3y
Ruthiella @erzascarletbookgasm This‘ll be my first experience of Margery Sharp too! 😃 3y
elkeOriginal @LeahBergen Lists are not nerdy! I started one looking back at the group posts! I just want to be sure it is accurate. Lists are the best! 3y
Cathythoughts My first Margery Sharp too. I‘ll go with Four Gardens...looking forward to our next MiddleBrow adventure 😄 I‘m going to order both as well @CarolynM 📚 (edited) 3y
Ruthiella @elkeoriginal @rubyslipperreads @quietjenn @CarolynM @LeahBergan @batsy @CathyThoughts @BooknAround @SamanthaMarie @Tamra @catebutler @erzascarletbookgasm @sarahbellum 🤓 Just for confirmation, the #FurrowedMiddleBrowClub read in March will beFour gardens 3y
Four gardensTamra 👏🏾 3y
Cathythoughts Great stuff 👍 3y
catebutler Perfect! So looking forward to reading, Four Gardens in March. 3y
quietjenn Sounds great! 3y
CarolynM Excellent! Looking forward to it. 3y
elkeOriginal WooHoo! Ordered! I may have ordered some other Margery Sharp as well since they sounded good 🤦🏼♀️ 3y
batsy Looking forward! 🌱🌷 3y
BookNAround Yay! Off to order now.😁 3y
Tamra I forgot this was an e/o month group! I will read ahead so that I can appreciate everyone‘s comments in March. (I back in a grad class then.) 3y
Kimzey Count me in! 3y
Ruthiella @Kimzey Will do! 3y
Kimzey @Ruthiella Great! Thanks! 3y
53 likes38 comments
