Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
In Defence of the Act
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
21 posts | 12 read | 17 to read
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
sarahbarnes
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image
Pickpick

A very good book that‘s been hard to review. Fiction that reads like a memoir and heavy subjects. But I did really enjoy it. The narrative style is matter of fact as Jessica recounts painful life experiences - as it seems a scientist would do. I think this is what makes the book so creatively interesting despite the tough subject matter.

BarbaraBB I agree , that narrative style made the book standing out. 3mo
sarahbarnes @BarbaraBB thank you for recommending I read it! 🩵 3mo
35 likes2 comments
review
Kitta
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image
Pickpick

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I had no idea how to rate this because I thought it was nonfiction, it had me so believing the storyline.

What a gut punch.

Jess is a lesbian and a scientist, studying altruistic suicidal behaviours in spiders (of all things). The novel discusses her personal relationships - touching on mental illness, trauma, queer love, and family dynamics.

Overall a moving and captivating story that will stay with me for a long time.

Kitta Trigger warnings: suicide, abuse, drug use, alcoholism, mental illness. 5mo
squirrelbrain This was my (joint) favourite on the Women‘s Prize list. It was so unusual but compelling. 5mo
Kitta Ooo what was your other favourite #womensprize novel @squirrelbrain? (edited) 5mo
See All 9 Comments
squirrelbrain Brotherless Night. I was a bit disappointed in the list overall this year -usually 5 or 6 would make my overall ‘favourites of the year‘ list, but this year only these two. 5mo
Kitta @squirrelbrain added to my TBR! I was drawn to In Defence for its unusual take on a difficult subject matter, I usually only read 1-2 from the women‘s prize list, and had to stop reading several times because it was overwhelming. I‘ve lost a lot of friends and family members to suicide and her rationalizations made it hard to read, but definitely an interesting and compelling novel. I felt really uncomfortable by the narrator‘s views, but sort of 5mo
Kitta @squirrelbrain understand her logic at the same time. It‘s definitely made me think a lot and will stay with me. (edited) 5mo
squirrelbrain I‘m sorry you‘ve lost people to suicide, Kitta. That must have made it a *really* tough read. BN is also a tough subject matter - the Sri Lankan civil war - but is also very muchworth reading. 5mo
Kitta @squirrelbrain thanks, it was tough but I thought it was a worthwhile read. I‘ll definitely check out 5mo
BarbaraBB This was a five star read for me too. Like you I lost people to suicide which made it a hard read yet so good. 5mo
29 likes9 comments
blurb
sarahbarnes
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image

Weekend book haul. 😁 Lots of my holds came in at the library at the same time (as they do) and I found a couple of books on my TBR at at used bookstore. And I splurged on a copy of the tagged book since I can‘t get it at the library yet.

vivastory Great haul! The Sarah Waters has been lingering towards the top of my TBR for awhile now & I have been wanting to try Penelope Lively 6mo
Ruthiella I loved Fingersmith and Alias Grace. Not read that Lively title, but I loved everything else I‘ve read from her! 6mo
Cathythoughts Great ! I loved Fingersmith and Alias Grace too ( especially Fingersmith ) … and I‘m interested to read In Defence of the Act (edited) 6mo
See All 15 Comments
batsy Great stack! Really want to read the Olga Ravn and Effie Black ones. Loved both Alias Grace and Fingersmith. 6mo
squirrelbrain Great stack! In Defence is likely to be in my top books of the year. I just found Disappearing Earth on Everand, in advance of Bear for #camplitsy24 6mo
BarbaraBB Such a great haul! I loved all the ones I read! 6mo
sarahbarnes @vivastory same on both fronts! I‘ve read Moon Tiger which was very good. (edited) 6mo
sarahbarnes @Ruthiella that‘s great to hear on all fronts! I‘ve only read Moon Tiger and loved it. 6mo
sarahbarnes @Cathythoughts I‘ve wanted to read it for awhile and that‘s very good to hear. 6mo
sarahbarnes @batsy that is great to hear! They‘ve been on my list for awhile. 6mo
sarahbarnes @squirrelbrain that is high praise! I‘m really excited to read it. @BarbaraBB also highly recommended it. 6mo
sarahbarnes @BarbaraBB that is great news! I was convinced to get In Defence of the Act from your review! 6mo
BarbaraBB That one is so good! But so are Fingersmith and Alias Grace and Disappearing Earth 😀. You‘ll love them and need to read a lot before they are due back 😉 6mo
BarbaraBB Oow and What I‘d rather not think about too! 6mo
sarahbarnes @BarbaraBB I know - how am I going to read them all before they have to go back?! 6mo
43 likes15 comments
review
TrishB
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image
Pickpick

A well very written book. A very difficult subject. I would find this hard to recommend. If suicide has touched your life you probably won‘t want to read. It was hard.

sarahbarnes I ordered a copy of this given a strong recommendation from @BarbaraBB. Glad to see you recommend it as well. 6mo
Cathythoughts I have this stacked. I‘m interested to read it too 👍🏻♥️ 6mo
BarbaraBB Suicide has touched my life and yet I found it somehow comforting 🤷🏻‍♀️🩷 6mo
TrishB @BarbaraBB I think it stirred up to many things. But my own fault- I knew what it was about. 6mo
BarbaraBB I can imagine 🩷 6mo
80 likes4 stack adds5 comments
review
squirrelbrain
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image
Pickpick

This is one of those books that you feel you can‘t say you loved, because of the subject matter (suicide). But I did love it.

It‘s very dark but also darkly humorous in places. Looking back on it now I can also see a sense of hope there too.

I can‘t wait to what this author writes next.

#womensprize

slategreyskies There‘s a part of me that wants to read this, but there‘s another part of me that thinks maybe it would hit too close to home and be a dangerous read for me. It does look really good, though. 💕 7mo
squirrelbrain I‘d hate to recommend it @slategreyskies if you think you would find it tough, but it is strangely positive. Check out @leniverse ‘s review today too. 7mo
TrishB I‘ve ordered this one due to everyone‘s reviews 👍🏻 7mo
BarbaraBB Great review Helen. Glad you felt the same as I did about it. 7mo
78 likes2 stack adds4 comments
review
Leniverse
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
Pickpick

Surprisingly funny and entertaining for a book that's also pretty sad. Also very life-affirming for a story that deals with suicide, eating disorders, domestic abuse, depression, generational trauma and more in a completely non-moralising way.

#WomensPrize2024 #WomensPrize

BarbaraBB Great review. My favorite from the longlist 7mo
Leniverse @BarbaraBB Not my favourite, but in my personal shortlist I think. Maybe top 3 even. But I also have a couple of books left 😅 7mo
36 likes2 stack adds2 comments
review
Hooked_on_books
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image
Pickpick

This book slapped me across the face and grabbed me by the lapels at the start, yanking me along with its intensity. It loses some of that in the middle, but the intensity certainly returns by the end. Because of the heaviness of this book, I wouldn‘t say I “liked” it, but it‘s powerful and will stick with me. I definitely appreciated it.

sarahbarnes Great review! I definitely want to read this one. 7mo
BarbaraBB This is my favorite from the longlist. What‘s yours? 7mo
BarbaraBB @sarahbarnes You must 😀 7mo
See All 11 Comments
Hooked_on_books @BarbaraBB I still have 5 to go, but I don‘t think anything will beat Brotherless Night for me. 7mo
BarbaraBB That one will be on my shortlist too! 7mo
dabbe 🖤🐾🖤 7mo
sarahbarnes @barbarabb your recommendation definitely makes it a must read for me! 😁 7mo
Leftcoastzen 🐶👏 7mo
squirrelbrain I‘m about halfway through this (my last one) and it‘s currently vying with Brotherless Night for the top spot. 🤔 @BarbaraBB 7mo
BarbaraBB @squirrelbrain Excited to see your shortlist! 7mo
batsy Great to see the positive reviews for this from you and @BarbaraBB and @squirrelbrain ! 7mo
60 likes1 stack add11 comments
blurb
bookwyrm7
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image

It really should come as no surprise that "In Defence of the Act", by Effie Black is my Book of the Week, although "How to Cook and Eat the Rich" by Sunyi Dean came as a close second: https://tardisgrades.blogspot.com/2024/04/book-of-week-april-1-to-7.html?m=1

#BookOfTheWeek

review
ChaoticMissAdventures
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image
Pickpick

4⭐
I found this to be fairly powerful in topic and writing. Jess was a relatable and realistic main character. The story is multi-layered and heartfelt. This is one of the better Women's Prize Fiction long list books this year.

ChaoticMissAdventures One thing I disliked is the trope idea of people who don't want kids being given kids and they wake up and realize they do! Amazing! As a child free person this always gets under my skin. 7mo
31 likes1 comment
review
bookwyrm7
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image
Pickpick

Without a doubt one of the best books I've ever read. The subject matter (suic*de) is an incredibly difficult topic to address in any shape or form, but Effie Black manages to talk about it beautifully, with tact, facts, kindness and even humour. The story is captivating and the writing is so light and pleasant that you end up easily reading through a lot more pages in one sitting than you were expecting.

#LGBTQ+ #lesbianlove

BarbaraBB Agree ❤️ 7mo
6 likes1 comment
quote
bookwyrm7
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image

"But if it's all bullshit anyway, I'm choosing the bullshit that will get me through the day."

This has been my motto for a while now. I used to try to form the most accurate, the most correct, the most informed opinions as possible on everything, but some things are just not that simple or even important. Now I just look for what makes me happy and gets me through the day. Because, in the end, most of it is just all bullshit anyway.

quote
ChaoticMissAdventures
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image

"I forgot to bring my book today, so instead I pick up one of the magazines the carer tends to leave lying around. I rarely read women's magazines anymore, and I'm surprised anew by the number of ways it is possible for a woman's body to be wrong."

TheBookHippie 😅😵‍💫 7mo
KadaGul @ChaoticMissAdventures You got that right, Sister!! 7mo
27 likes2 comments
quote
bookwyrm7
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image

Not really the very first line, but

“ 'Feel free to shout out.' Everyone feels free. No one shouts out.“

is possibly one of my favourite passages.

This first page was the page that made me want to read this book and I'm so glad I did so, because I haven't been able to put it down! So, a bit more than a first line but I'm hoping it'll get others to read it too.

#FirstLineFridays

BarbaraBB It will be one of my 2024 favorites I‘m sure. So good! 7mo
bookwyrm7 I feel the same way! 😊 7mo
8 likes2 comments
quote
bookwyrm7
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image

"I hurled it with such incensed vigour that it bounced back and onto the lap of the person next to me, to whom I apologized. Which I probably wouldn't have had to do had they read the book, because they would've surely understood the point I must have reached, and, remembering it, they would quite rightly have thrown the book on the floor in renewed rage themselves."

We've all read a book like that and I just love how she describes this ?

blurb
ChaoticMissAdventures
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image

I have always thought those pages at the end of books that are all "a note about the type" we're a bit weird I have never much noticed the font in a book, but I absolutely hate what was chosen here? I really hope it doesn't cloud my judgement of the book.

BarbaraBB Yes me too. But in the end I didn‘t matter anymore! 7mo
24 likes1 comment
review
Deblovestoread
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image
Pickpick

Tough subject matter but I loved this book so much. I loved how it spoke to chaos and trauma in your growing up years. I loved the journey to growth the MC made. It will stay with me. 5 🌟

#WomensPrizeLonglist

TW: Suicide, Disordered eating

BarbaraBB Great review. I felt the same 💔 8mo
squirrelbrain Great review - I‘m looking forward to this, if that‘s the write thing to say considering the subject matter…. 8mo
Cathythoughts Great review. I have it stacked already 👍🏻 8mo
67 likes1 stack add3 comments
quote
charl08
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image

Her book collection is astounding. It covers two of the living room walls from floor to ceiling, running across the top of two doorways, and is organised entirely by colour.
----

How does anyone find anything when they do this with a big book collection? 🤯

squirrelbrain Has to be alphabetical….🤷‍♀️ 8mo
43 likes1 stack add1 comment
blurb
BarbaraBB
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image

#BookReport 12/24

It seems like I selected my books for their color, well, I didn‘t 😉. I LOVED the tagged one. It won‘t be for everyone (tw suicide ⚠️ ) but I think it will be one of this year‘s favorites for me. I also loved Ordinary Human Failures. Vengeance is Mine was just so-so.

So far I am very pleased about the #womenPrize longlist with already two winners for me out of the three I read 😀

Ruthiella I‘ve heard from other sources too that the WP longlist is particularly strong this year! 👍 8mo
squirrelbrain A good week! ❤️ 8mo
74 likes2 comments
quote
charl08
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black

... people who grow up surrounded by chaos and fear are more likely to..... suffer cancer, heart disease, and auto-immune disorders. Maybe you think of course they're more likely to be unhealthy if they're more depressed and they're drinking more? Well no. Because these scientists have shown that when you stress out young mice, they go on to have screwed up minds and bodies, and that certainly isn't because they spend too much time in the pub.

TheBookHippie 🎯👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 8mo
35 likes1 comment
quote
charl08
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black

I have never been happier or felt more at home than in this grubby underground world full of people like me, and I experience genuine and instant love for the girl who takes my entrance money and stamps my hand, the girl who checks my coat and bag, the girls who keep my plastic cups filled, girls who touch their fingertips to dripping ceiling as they dance, the girls in the endless queue for the horrible toilets...The girls, the girls, the girls.

BarbaraBB This book 💔❤️💔 8mo
charl08 @BarbaraBB Yes. Quietly devastating. 8mo
36 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
BarbaraBB
In Defence of the Act | Effie Black
post image
Pickpick

The evolutionary benefit of something as dark as suicide. That‘s what this book is about and where Jess is convinced of.
In the book we get to know Jess and learn why she thinks this way. It‘s a short book but it packs a punch. I am left shattered and in awe. My favorite of the #womenprize longlist so far. I‘ve only read three but I am sure this will remain a favorite!

(Photo: Robbie Williams exhibition)

Crazeedi I split up my tagged list because for some reason it tells me it won't post...then I see it posting twice, and it takes forever . 8mo
BarbaraBB @Crazeedi I know, me too… I‘ll split it up next time too! 8mo
See All 21 Comments
sarahbarnes Stacking! 8mo
BarbaraBB @sarahbarnes Please do 🩷 8mo
squirrelbrain Great review - looking forward to getting to this next week. 8mo
BarbaraBB @squirrelbrain It‘s a tough subject but so so good! 8mo
Hooked_on_books And I love that it crosses over with 52 book club! I actually just picked up the ebook for this since the physical one doesn‘t appear to exist in the US. 8mo
Librarybelle Great review!! 8mo
ChaoticMissAdventures Oh this makes me excited for this! I had to order it from Blackwells so waiting for it to come. 8mo
BarbaraBB @Hooked_on_books @ChaoticMissAdventures I hope you‘ll love it. The subject is tough but it‘s a beautiful story. 8mo
charl08 Just managed to get hold of this, have started it and it's so compelling. So many good books! 8mo
Deblovestoread I was unsure about this book until your review. Thanks for the ebook tip @Hooked_on_books. 💜 8mo
Hooked_on_books @Deblovestoread You‘re welcome! 8mo
BarbaraBB @Deblovestoread I hope you‘ll love it. @TheKidUpstairs says the audio is very engrossing too so you should be fine! @Hooked_on_books 8mo
BarbaraBB @charl08 You‘ll love it! 8mo
Caroline2 Ohh I‘m always scared of books about/including suicide but your review may have persuaded me to give it a go! 😊 8mo
BarbaraBB @Caroline2 Suicide is definitely a trigger warning ⚠️ as it is omnipresent in this book! 8mo
Cathythoughts Great review. Sold and stacked. 8mo
TheBookHippie One of the things I‘m most proud of, staying here. I‘m glad books like this exist. Not sure I could read it. 8mo
BarbaraBB @TheBookHippie I‘m not sure either. I guess I wouldn‘t try if I were you. So many good books out there, there‘s no need to. Thanks for sharing 🩷🩷🩷 8mo
89 likes5 stack adds21 comments