Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Girl
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
23 posts | 24 read | 26 to read
Girl, Edna OBriens hotly anticipated new novel, envisages the lives of the Boko Haram girls in a masterpiece of violence and tenderness. I was a girl once, but not anymore. So begins Girl, Edna OBriens harrowing portrayal of the young women abducted by Boko Haram. Set in the deep countryside of northeast Nigeria, this is a brutal story of incarceration, horror, and hunger; a hair-raising escape into the manifold terrors of the forest; and a descent into the labyrinthine bureaucracy and hostility awaiting a victim who returns home with a child blighted by enemy blood. From one of the century's greatest living authors, Girl is an unforgettable story of one victims astonishing survival, and her unflinching faith in the redemption of the human heart.
LibraryThing
review
nanuska_153
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Mehso-so

A fictionalised story of one of the school girls kidnapped by Boko Haram. I knew this was going to be a difficult read, but I really struggled. The fist third of the book feels like a collection of gruesome stories about what extreme misogyny and religious fanaticism can take us. It makes difficult to connect with the character since there's no personal details outside the horrors that she's enduring. ⬇️⬇️

nanuska_153 I think Edna O'Brien did a great job researching and interviewing these girls and she didn't want to leave any of their horrors untold,but perhaps it would habe been better as non-fiction.Although if that was the case, probably the girls wouldn't have felt safe sharing their stories with her,specially after seeing how ostracized they are the ones that survived, which is dealt with also in the book.So I respect and understand the author's decision. 2w
nanuska_153 Overall I'm glad I read it, because these stories, or should I say realities, need to be told and we need to listen. Victims deserve their voices to be heard. 2w
Suet624 I seem to remember I started this one but only got halfway through it. 2w
nanuska_153 @Suet624 yeah it's a really difficult book. I read it for a bookclub, don't know if I would have finished it if it was just me 2w
31 likes4 comments
review
HelenaLW
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
Pickpick

5/5

review
ChaoticMissAdventures
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Panpan

Okay. So I have very strong feelings about white women taking the trauma of other cultures and monopolizing on it. I will full on admit I made a mistake and when I bought this I did not realize it was written by a WW. She then was long listed for the Women's Prize so I thought I would give it a chance. I really wish I had followed my instincts.
While some of her language is nice the story line is scattered & overall felt like trauma porn.

Hooked_on_books I reading a book of essays at the moment and the titular essay talks about the idea of white people co-opting the pain of prejudice. The author tells a story in which racial slurs are thrown at her on a train then a white friend with her starts crying, saying that had never happened to her before. It‘s upsetting that people would turn something around and make it about themselves. 4y
ChaoticMissAdventures @Hooked_on_books this looks fantastic. Thank you. I am going to order it. I think it is so hard to get these types of books right, for me the Girls in O'Brein's book are not concepts or far past people, but alive and still suffering women - capable of writing their own story. I don't see a reason for an Irish white woman to write this book. 4y
ChaoticMissAdventures Aa always I forgot! This was my #doublebookspin with @TheAromaofBooks 📚📚📚 4y
TheAromaofBooks Great progress!! 4y
15 likes4 comments
review
JillR
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Mehso-so

A story of the taking of 276 girls by Boko Haram in Nigeria told by Maryam, a fictional character. The writing and style was not really for me and this is not an easy read, but I couldn‘t turn away from the appalling story and how Maryam was then treated after her escape. And the fact many of these girls remain missing.

review
CaroPi
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Pickpick

So here is my #readingwrapup for the month of April. 4 books is not a bad number but I felt I could do better. Let's see how it goes in May....

review
CaroPi
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Pickpick

This is a hard read. All the alerts for sensitive topics. But it has a beautiful writing. I almost read it in one seating. I can see why was nominated for the #womensprizeforfiction. I will try to read as many as I can for the longlist. I tend to like these books.

#bookly

16 likes1 stack add
review
Currey
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Pickpick

I had an Edna O‘Brien reading fest here starting with her first book; The Country Girls, her memoir; The Country Girl and finishing up with; Girl her last book. The first two provided delightful insights into Ireland of the 1950‘s and all three give voice to women who had been stripped of all but silence and screams. Girl is the fictionalized story of one of the kidnapped school girls in Nigeria by the Boko Harem. #ReadAroundtheWorld #Ireland

charl08 I loved the memoir, especially her account of her childhood. I'd like to read more by her. 5y
24 likes1 comment
review
EmmaMae
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Pickpick

A compelling story filled with hardship and heartbreak and pockets of love and beauty. A well told fictional retelling of one girl captured by Boko Haram and her escape.

review
nomadreader
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Pickpick

Powerful. Tragic. Devastating. But beautifully written and superb narration 4.5/5 #WomensPrize

review
squirrelbrain
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Mehso-so

This novel is based on the story of the schoolgirls abducted by Boko Haram in Nigeria.

I nearly bailed early on due to the horrific details of rape/violence but it‘s important that we acknowledge and learn about such atrocities so I persevered...HOWEVER the book was written in a very detached manner, which made the whole thing feel very distant and almost clinical - there was no emotion. A shame, as I feel the impact was lessened.

rockpools This was recommended to me on @lele1432 ‘s #NewYearWhoDis list - same topic, different viewpoint. Of course I haven‘t actually read it yet ... 5y
BarbaraBB I often feel this way with O‘Brien. She touches upon important issues yet it feels detached indeed. For example with this one. 5y
See All 13 Comments
squirrelbrain Thanks for the suggestions @RachelO @Suet624 - hopefully one of those will be better..... 5y
squirrelbrain @BarbaraBB - this was my first O‘Brien and at the moment I‘m not inclined to read any more, based on this one. 5y
Suet624 @BarbaraBB I agree about the Red Chairs. 5y
BarbaraBB @Suet624 Maybe I should try Moonless one day since you say that one is better! 5y
Hooked_on_books Thank you for this review. You‘ve definitely convinced me not to read this one. 5y
Suet624 @BarbaraBB it‘s a tough one but it‘s more authentic. 5y
veritysalter I know The Leeds Library is a subscription library, do you know if you have to live in Leeds to buy a membership? 5y
squirrelbrain No, not at all @veritysalter - I worked round the corner when I first joined. Now I‘ve left that job I can‘t go as often (I‘m in Harrogate so not TOO far away). It‘s open on a Saturday morning and until 7pm on a Thursday. The newer books are 3 week loans, but the others are all 12 weeks and you can get up to 30 at once! 😁😮 Whereabouts are you? Let me know if you want to visit - I can take you, or it‘s open to the public Thurs eve. 5y
veritysalter I‘m in Barnsley, I‘m a bit housebound at the moment; but I would love to try it once I‘m back on my feet. Thank you. 5y
squirrelbrain Sorry to hear about your surgery being postponed @veritysalter - a trip to The Leeds Library is something to look forward to when you feel better. 😘 5y
78 likes13 comments
blurb
nomadreader
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image

Next up on audio, from the #WomensPrize longlist

19 likes2 stack adds
review
Dolly
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Pickpick

A gut wrenching brutal novel based on the Boko Haram schoolgirl kidnapping. There‘s emotional uplift at the end so the reader is not left drained and exhausted. Well written.

Sapphire I have it in audio but had to take a brake. It‘s amazingly well written. But brutal is right. 5y
Dolly @Sapphire yes, it‘s hard to say you like a book telling that story. The voices were excellent though. 5y
53 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
AnneCecilie
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Pickpick

I know I remember the news some years ago (2014) about the kidnapping of 276 school girls. The abductors were Boko Haram. Since then, at least in Norwegian news, there have been reports about how hard it‘s for women who have been victims of sexualized violence to be accepted back to their community in certain parts of Africa.

This is a fictional story of one of the girls kidnapped by Boko Haram, about her captivity, her escape and life

AnneCecilie afterwards. My only complaint is that the ending might have been a little to happy. I‘m glad this was on your #NewYearWhoDis! list @Pricel101 since I don‘t think I would have read it otherwise. I don‘t think it gripped me the same way as you, but I‘m glad I read it @monalyisha (edited) 5y
AnneCecilie In case anyone wonder 112 of the 276 girls kidnapped on 14-15 April 2014 are still missing. 5y
Butterfinger So so sad. 5y
See All 8 Comments
Texreader Yes I‘ve heard the same thing that the girls are not accepted back into their communities. It‘s dreadful 5y
Pricel101 @AnnCecilie lovely that you read it! ☺️ They say writers should “write what you know” that may be why I was so taken with her captivating narrative from the abducted girls POV. O‘Brien could not be more different than the characters. @monalyisha #newyearwhodis is always so much fun! 5y
monalyisha Thanks for saying so, @Pricel101 🤗! 5y
charl08 This is on my wishlist. I have read Helon Habila's (shoet) account though (non-fiction). Worth the read. 5y
charl08 Argh! Should have said "short". 5y
72 likes3 stack adds8 comments
blurb
AnneCecilie
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image

#WeeklyForcast

📚 Finish Girl
📚 Start the second book about the Vanderbeekers

🎧 continue The Starless Sea

Cinfhen Your books compliment each other so nicely 😁 5y
55 likes1 comment
blurb
AnneCecilie
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image

#BookReport

📚 finished Case Histories and loved it
📚 read an illustrated book “A Place over Thousands of Years” and found it interesting
📚 125p in on the Kepler crime and I‘m DNFing. I‘m just not into this.
📚 started Girl, and while this is a though read, I want to know what happens

🎧 I continued my listen of The Starless Sea. I‘m 5hrs in (30%) and I still don‘t know what is happening, but I‘m intrigued enough to find out

Cinfhen I wasn‘t a fan of Girl / I‘ll be curious to hear your final thoughts 5y
57 likes1 stack add1 comment
blurb
AnneCecilie
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image

Next up.
The first book from my #NewYearWhoDis! list

Pricel101 Looking forward to your thoughts ☺️ 5y
Buechersuechtling Uh, this cover confused me. Needed to peek at the title of the blurb to sort out who is who. 🤭 5y
62 likes2 comments
review
Cinfhen
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Pickpick

A harrowing fictionalized story of the kidnapping and eventual return of Maryam, a Nigerian schoolgirl taken by military extremists on the night of April 14,2014. 276 female students were kidnapped, taken as sexual slaves and traded amongst men as war prizes and spoils. This book is extremely upsetting and many are questioning whether Edna O‘Brien has the right or is the right person to tell this story. My issue was the detachment although I 👇🏼

Cinfhen feel that was a concise decision by the author. This book reads cold, sparse with little emotion or humanity. Maryam‘s return to “home” was equally bleak. I don‘t want to ruin any parts of the book, but it‘s heartbreaking to see how society accepts and welcomes back Maryam. A pick with reservations. #BorrowNotBuy 5y
TrishB Sounds like a tough read! 5y
Cinfhen Very tough @TrishB and it only happened 5 years ago!!!! 😭😭😭😭😭 5y
See All 14 Comments
ferskner I listened to an Edna O'Brien book a few years ago and there are horrible things from it I still can't get out of my head. Part of me admires that she doesn't sugarcoat atrocities but I also wish she showed more fluidity in how she puts it all together. 5y
Cinfhen Yes @ferskner you‘re right, I didn‘t want it sugarcoated but it was just stated, without any sense of surrounding or what the MC was thinking, feeling, experiencing. And 90% of the book was written that way. I‘m sure it was intentional because it‘s such a horrible story, but I was more concerned with WHEN the book would end as opposed to HOW the book would end. 5y
Cathythoughts I think I‘d like to give it a go 👍🏻❤️stacked 5y
rockpools Sounds horrific and sad 😔. I struggled with the fact my last read all happened in my lifetime, so ‘happening now‘ is definitely going to add to the intensity. Not sure I‘m up for this in the near future... 5y
erzascarletbookgasm Horrifying! I read an interview on why the author wanted to write this book..very brave and tough of her, making those trips to Nigeria! 5y
BarbaraBB I felt the same when O‘Brien wrote about Bosnia in 5y
Kalalalatja Thanks for tagging me! I‘m keeping it Stacked, but I‘m not rushing out to get it. Great and insightful review, tho! 5y
Cinfhen Reading the blurb @BarbaraBB I can see the similarities I don‘t think you‘ll regret reading it @Kalalalatja @Cathythoughts it‘s not very voluminous and if you can persevere it could be read in one or two sittings 5y
Cinfhen I agree @erzascarletbookgasm very commendable of Edna O‘Brien to bring this plight to more readers 5y
Suet624 I was about to read this and then I realized I had read a powerful nonfiction book in which the author interviewed a number of folks fighting extremism. One of the women had been kidnapped and later tried to return home with her kidnapper with mixed results. It seemed that I didn‘t need to read a book written by a woman who had never experienced the situation. I recommend the tagged book though. 5y
Cinfhen Tagged book sounds good @Suet624 thanks for the recommendation 5y
102 likes4 stack adds14 comments
blurb
Cinfhen
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image

Not the lightest of reads or for the faintest of hearts - this book is ROUGH. I‘m having to read in small doses because the horror and violence is really upsetting.

CafeMom I know her books can be raw. I have read a couple but none with violence and horror. 5y
LeahBergen This DOES sound harsh. 😬 5y
Cinfhen I think knowing that this is based on actual girls stories and these atrocities took place in THIS decade makes it even harder to read @CafeMom @LeahBergen 5y
See All 8 Comments
Megabooks I could not read this! 5y
Sace I don't have the courage to read this. 😔 5y
Chrissyreadit I think if I were to read this topic I would want non fiction so I could have more facts about the plight and emotion. It‘s so crazy that we live in the best of times and the worst of times. 5y
Cinfhen This book reads like a memoir @Chrissyreadit but it is fictionalized, which makes it better in some ways or worse. It‘s true/ we do live in troubling times 😭😭😭 I‘m not sure why I picked this book up @Sace @Megabooks because this is a topic that really guts me. I‘m taking it slow and hoping the end will see some sort of redemption for this young girl. 5y
Kalalalatja I wasn‘t aware of this book, but it sounds intense! I‘m interested to see what you end up feeling about it 5y
73 likes2 stack adds8 comments
review
jouleian
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
Pickpick

This is a mentally taxing book. A good one and an in formative one. It is also not for everyone.

review
Pricel101
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Pickpick

This is the story of the abducted Nigerian school girls in 2014. Insurgents disguised as soldiers break into the school to loot it. Finding no guns or supplies, they decide that “Girls will do”.. this shock sets the tone for the terrifying story of Maryam, “bush wife”, a reward, for one of the fighters. Best read of the year! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Edna O‘Brien knows how to write about women, no matter the time, place or culture.

#womenreadingwomen

review
SoManyBooksNotEnoughTime
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Pickpick

A haunting, harrowing envisioning of what happened to one of the schoolgirls kidnapped by Boko Haram in the middle of the night. While this book isn't necessarily a factual recounting and the content was extremely tough at times, I forced myself to continue reading because these girls deserve to have their story told. This story really puts things into perspective & shows how someone's life can be completely altered due to no fault of their own.

64 likes2 stack adds
review
keepingupwiththepenguins
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Panpan

A terrific premise, with so much promise, but I'm afraid the execution let it down for me. The prose was very blunt, to the point of sounding detached, and given the horrific subject matter (kidnapping of Nigerian girls by Boko Haram in 2014)... I also really struggled with the friction of a privileged older white woman writing from the perspective of a traumatised young woman of colour. Best read alongside #ownvoices narratives and non-fiction.

26 likes1 stack add
review
Bookalong
Girl: A Novel | Edna O'Brien
post image
Pickpick

4/5🌟 It's absolutely horrifying what happened to these girls. That this is based on true events is very disturbing. Reading this you can tell O'Brien did her research. The storytelling and writing is exquisite but I did struggle in some parts with Maryam's character. This story is filled with ghastly violence, only writers as fantastic as O'Brien could take on such an ambitious story. Out Oct 15th!
#bookreview #bookstagram #bookblogger

TheNerdyProfessor This sounds so interesting and heartbreaking. Did you find the violence described to be very graphic? I read Girls Burn Brighter last year and it was hard to read at times but such an important story. 5y
Bookalong @TheNerdyProfessor Yes I did. I loved Girls Burn Brighter, its definitely similar. 5y
15 likes2 comments