Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Riders of the Purple Sage
Riders of the Purple Sage: A Novel | Zane Grey
12 posts | 25 read | 7 to read
When Lassiter, a gunman with a reputation, rode into the Mormon village he found an angry mob. The object of their anger was the richest woman in town, who was unwilling to give up control of her spring water.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Robotswithpersonality
post image
Mehso-so

It's done! Apparently knowing a book exists outside copyright and can be fetched at any time for free by accessing Project Gutenberg or YouTube audiobooks means I do not make it a priority to actually finish it. With fairly LARGE caveats: the racist stereotypes of indigenous people tossed around in casual speech (no actual indigenous characters), 1/?

Robotswithpersonality 2/? and, despite the frequent attempts to note there are good Mormons, the pretty obvious bias of the writing against Mormons, and occasional condescending, patriarchal view of female characters, I was still rather impressed with this book.
The pacing and storyline is compelling, the characters are well fleshed out.
2d
Robotswithpersonality 3/? Up until the last moment, you don't know for certain whether certain people will manage to stay together or live (happily ever after?), the stakes are heightened by various deaths and losses throughout the story. There are also a number of mysteries in the murky backgrounds of characters so you get dramatic reveals. 2d
Robotswithpersonality 4/? As an atheist, I can only be happy to see a narrative where a woman who generously helped her community, opposed intolerance to aid the less fortunate, and did not surrender her agency to an undesirable partner, then recognizes the corrupt, cult-like, oppressive nature of the religion she was born and raised in, and took steps to separate her faith from observance of religious doctrine, 2d
See All 9 Comments
Robotswithpersonality 5/? especially wrestling with questioning the revering of any religious leader as something more holy and powerful than any human should demand. I could have happily seen the God stuff done away with completely, but it's apparent that wasn't an option that occurred to Grey. I wish I had a better historical idea of whether this book was considered hateful towards a religious sect, 2d
Robotswithpersonality 6/? an example of the prevailing attitude of the time, or groundbreaking in its own right.
While Jane's internal struggle, the discussion of religion, is the primary theme, there was a good deal of exploration around the theme of outcasts/isolation/loneliness (I can only imagine how many Wild West characters really needed a hug) and found family.
2d
Robotswithpersonality 7/? Also, people figuring out where they draw the line in their own personal ethics, outside of scripture, especially in relation to looking after those they care about. Morally grey? 🤔 There did seem to be a lot of shooting at the end there.
I'd also like to take a moment to heap praise on Zane Grey's ability to describe a landscape and the experience of riding a horse. The atmosphere! 😍
2d
Robotswithpersonality 8/? The colour and the light as it falls on rock and sage, reverence for paradisiacal safe havens where things are green and wildlife abounds. There are some lovely illustrations (paintings?) that come even with the Project Gutenberg digital version, but they don't hold a candle to Grey's words. 2d
Robotswithpersonality 9/? And yeah, the way horses are described, the chases and escapes, this is as close as I'll ever come to being a horse girl. Sadly, not every beautiful beastie makes it out. [The dogs live. 🙏🏻]
It may have taken me seven months to get back to it, but I'm glad I read it. Will I pick up another Zane Grey? Maybe. Maybe I'll read the synopsis first, this time. 😅
2d
Robotswithpersonality 10/10 I think it's fair to say my hunch that I could enjoy early Westerns has proved correct.
⚠️Mention of animal cruelty, animal death, period typical racist stereotypes, misogyny
2d
10 likes1 stack add9 comments
blurb
TheSpineView
post image

#Movie2BookRecs @Klou
Movie: Old Henry

Klou Brilliant!! 1y
39 likes2 comments
review
terryduncan5719
Pickpick

I read this book because of my book club. Thank goodness for book clubs! It is definitely dated. It takes place in 1915ish. Zane Grey books were made into TV shows and influenced movies and television long after his death. The author was excellent at describing Utah. The character development was a little over the top for me. Some of the relationship descriptions were a little confusing, but as I kept reading I figured it out!

blurb
TheKidUpstairs
post image

#OnThisDay in 1872, American Western author (and dentist) Zane Grey was born in Zanesville (named after founder Ebenezer Zane). Isn't that zany? (Sorry, I had to) A major influence in shaping the mythology of the Old West, Grey wrote more than 90 books which were adapted into 112 films, and became one of the first millionaire authors. #HistoryGetsLIT

wanderinglynn That‘s so interesting. 3y
56 likes1 comment
review
eris404
post image
Pickpick

Book 7. I was dubious about my 1st western. Written in 1912, I expected casual racism but was surprised by deep anti-Mormonism. The elders are kidnappers, murderers, & implied rapists. The protagonist, Jane, a wealthy rancher, is pressured by the elders into marriage to punish her willfulness. Jane loves her church, but also wants to do what‘s right, whether helping poor Gentiles or keeping her freedom. It‘s both hilariously bad & lovely in spots

review
RJHowe
post image
Pickpick

This book was published in 1912 and is considered the start of the traditional western model. As I read I was surprised to discover the plot was built around two love stories and the historical Morman-gentile conflict. It has its fair share of overwriting, exaggerated dialogue and sexism, but it remains an interesting period price. The twist at the end was quite clever.

Bookwomble My Penguin edition had an excellent introduction which provide context for the themes of white slavery and distrust of Mormonism. Incidentally, it helped me to better understand the Conan Doyle's Holmes novels, A Study in Scarlet andThe Valley of Fear, which, I think, between them treat similar themes as Grey. It you've seen the film, Valley of thee Gwanji, I thought its premise of the lost valley similar to the ending of Purple Sage. 7y
Tonton I remember reading this a real long time ago; the title stayed with me though。must reread! 7y
77 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
JulAnna
post image

I hope everyone enjoys Father‘s Day with their Dad this weekend! My Dad loved to read and always had a book ‘in progress‘. He enjoyed military fiction, history, and westerns. Pictured is a small part of his Zane Grey collection, with the tagged book in the middle. Miss you, Dad 💕

blurb
Suelizbeth
post image

I don't have enough to read *hysterical laughter*. Curse you, Serial Reads.

Rachellynnwright Agreed! My physical books are collecting dust thanks to serial reader! 7y
67 likes1 comment
blurb
SerialReader
post image

Often called one of the most popular Western novels of all time and even the work that most shaped the genre. Jane Withersteen - alongside gunslinger avenger Lassiter - struggles against evil members of her Utah town.

This is the first of hopefully many Westerns I add to Serial Reader. I need recommendations for more!

SerialReader @LeahBergen Thanks! Added The Virginian. Don't have the rights to distribute The Ox-Bow Incident unfortunately. 8y
ValerieAndBooks My grandma was a big Zane Grey fan and had a lot of his books. I never tried reading any of them, though! 8y
32 likes2 stack adds4 comments
blurb
JordanGraft
post image

What's a girl gotta do to get a fancy rolling library ladder around here? 😋 #shortgirlproblems

BlueMonday42 Story of my life. 9y
MrBook Lol! Nice shelves 😊👍🏻! 9y
TheLondonBookworm Hehe I feel ya! 9y
See All 14 Comments
LauraBeth Love your shelves! I'm a tall gal so I always lend a hand to others for top shelf items 😀 it's the only thing useful about being tall... 9y
JordanGraft @LauraBeth you are a true saint! 9y
marixa We have step stools in every room lol 9y
Palimpsest Are those books behind you from the Folger Shakespeare library collection? 💜 9y
Megabooks Definitely some short girl problems over here! 🙋🏻🙋🏻 9y
Larnellmays Lol nice 9y
ErickaS_Flyleafunfurled My dream too! 9y
Laalaleighh I wish I had your hair skills! I spend hours attempting to get my hair to look like that and I either look like Shirley temple or one of those American Girl dolls about a year after purchase. There is nothing in between. 9y
MeganAnn Awesome shelves! @LauraBeth that's me too! At least we can do something good with our height... 😄 9y
Lola @Laalaleighh 😂😂😂😂 9y
Lola I know short girl problems-I am constantly asking people if I can "borrow their height" to get things for me that are out of reach. 9y
119 likes3 stack adds14 comments