Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Can You Hear the Nightbird Call?
Can You Hear the Nightbird Call? | Anita Rau Badami
35 posts | 4 read | 17 to read
Set against the tumultuous backdrop of a fragmenting Punjab and moving between Canada and India, Can You Hear the Nightbird Call? charts the interweaving stories of three Indian womenBibi-ji, Leela and Nimmoeach in search of a resting place amid rapidly changing personal and political landscapes. Can You Hear the Nightbird Call? weaves together the personal and the politicaland beautifully brings the reader into the reality of terrorism and religious intolerance.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
blurb
LeahBergen
post image
LibrarianRyan ⭐️👍🎅🏻 7y
Soubhiville Well done! 7y
100 likes2 comments
review
shawnmooney
post image
Pickpick

A sweeping narrative of the lives of three Indian women whose lives in Punjab, Delhi and Vancouver gather within the embrace of family, faith, community and friendship yet shatter beneath the fist of hatred and violence. An imperfect, at times somewhat disjointed novel that throbs with feeling. I was heartbroken open.

@Lindy @Mayread @ramyasbookshelf @Skiles @SusanInTiburon @Dragon

Cinfhen Nice thoughtful review 8y
shawnmooney @Cinfhen Thank you. You are always too kind! 💖 8y
Cinfhen Thanks @shawnmooney but I really appreciate the way you approach a novel and the attention and time you devote to your reading! I'm really in awe🙌🏻 I'm more of a speed reader and often miss the beautiful nuances you are so diligent to quote. 8y
Lindy While I adore finely crafted literature, there's also room in my heart for imperfect books that throb with emotion. 👍 8y
shawnmooney @Lindy Mom really loved this one. She told me today she tried another of hers and couldn't get into it at all. It was probably the one you didn't like. It doesn't seem like ARB has written anything lately, right? I think she's got a great, finely crafted novel in her! 8y
43 likes3 stack adds5 comments
review
Lindy
post image
Pickpick

Sometimes the best thing about a novel is how much it teaches me. Badami includes a lot of important historical events over the tumultuous 60-year span of the narrative, and I feel better able to grasp their effects by having them in context with fictional individuals. Her writing is a bit overwrought for my taste, but it's still a pick.

35 likes1 comment
blurb
Lindy
post image

@shawnmooney @mayread @ramyasbookshelf @skiles @susanintiburon @Dragon

Have you all finished the book? One of the things I liked about it was how many other books came to mind as I was reading it. I'm going to mention them in comments so that I can use title links.

Lindy Religious riots in India; south Asian immigrants in BC; finding balance: 8y
Lindy Assassination of Indira Ghandi & riots afterwards; south Asian immigrants in Canada; straddling of multiple cultures: 8y
Lindy Multi-ethnic identity; south Asian immigrants in Canada; alternating viewpoints; Air India bombing: 8y
Lindy 1980s New Delhi from a young woman's POV: 8y
Lindy Partition of India; sweep of history: 8y
28 likes1 stack add5 comments
blurb
Lindy

Oops! Continuity error. Pa-ji wears a suit but not a tie to the interview with Jasbeer's principal. (P. 208). After the meeting, once they are out of the school, Pa-ji loosens his tie and rips it off (p. 212).

ErickaS_Flyleafunfurled Woah! Good catch! 8y
Lindy @ErickaS_Flyleafunfurled.com I'm sure I'm not the only one who noticed, because he made a big deal about refusing to wear a tie to the meeting. 8y
shawnmooney Good eye! 8y
23 likes1 stack add3 comments
quote
shawnmooney
post image

23 likes1 stack add
blurb
shawnmooney
post image

quote
shawnmooney
post image

quote
shawnmooney
post image

quote
shawnmooney
post image

shawnmooney @lindy This resonates rather contrapuntally with the quote you posted about Leela, maps, and home, hey? 8y
ramyasbookshelf I still haven't received my book from Amazon!! :( 8y
shawnmooney @ramyasbookshelf No problem! Please join in whenever you're ready! 8y
26 likes4 comments
blurb
Lindy
post image

"'Take the next left,' she told Balu. Leela felt absurdly pleased with herself. Soon she might not need any maps at all. Soon Vancouver might become a place as familiar as Bangalore or Balepur."

I love how this passage captures the internal shift that can happen along with a feeling of mastery.

@shawnmooney @mayread @ramyasbookshelf @skiles @susanintiburon @Dragon

shawnmooney I liked that scene too! 8y
Dragon I like the map 🗺 8y
37 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
Lindy
post image

Illegal immigration has come up several times. When an airplane stowaway is mentioned in Can You Hear the Nightbird Call? I thought of a novel by Kate Pullinger, (which has a less tragic fate for the stowaway, as far as I can tell). Have any of you read Landing Gear?
@shawnmooney @mayread @ramyasbookshelf @skiles @susanintiburon @Dragon

shawnmooney No, but if you are recommending it, I will! 8y
Dragon No haven't heard of it . Sounds interesting 😀 8y
Lindy @shawnmooney I haven't read it. Loved another book by Pullinger: 8y
28 likes1 stack add3 comments
quote
shawnmooney
post image

Lindy Identity as a creative act. I like this quote, even though it's a bit flowery. Sometimes Badami's prose is a bit much for my taste, but I'm enjoying this book anyway. 8y
shawnmooney @Lindy I would agree with you on both counts. The writing is uneven, and yet I am deeply invested in the story. I know some awful stuff is coming down the narrative pipeline, and it's going to be so interesting to see how I feel by the end. 8y
24 likes3 comments
quote
shawnmooney
post image

I couldn't find a definition for 'bharoli' but assume it's some sort of large container.

tpixie Yes sounds like a barrel tense 😬 scene 8y
22 likes1 comment
quote
shawnmooney
post image

quote
Lindy
post image

"So what is wrong with being like Trishanku?Was he not a lucky fellow to have a foot in two worlds? It can be an advantage to live neither here nor there, like a frog, comfortable in water and on land. The thing is to understand how to make use of this ability."

shawnmooney Indeed, this quote may well be the heart of the novel! 8y
Lindy @Varshitha @pppooraikul Neither of you signed up for our discussion of this book, but I thought of you when I got to the part about the grandmother telling stories every day from the Mahabbarata, the Ramayana or the Panchatantra. 8y
See All 9 Comments
pppooraikul @Lindy I'm so glad you thought of me! 😊 And though I didn't join the discussion, I've been reading your posts with great interest indeed! They reminds me of familiar stories I loved as a child. ☺️ 8y
Varshitha I am missing in action from Litsy for past week as I'm in my hometown for festival, so I have been missing lots from Litsy,.. Glad you thought of me, would love to be part of the discussion... love all the small tales under Ramayana and Mahabharatha.. 8y
Lindy @Varshitha Is it Navratri? I don't know much about Hindu festivals. 8y
Varshitha Yea it's Navaratri.. I am in Mysore right now, today is the last day.. We have nine days of festivities and today there will be a procession of Goddess Durga.. 8y
Varshitha Today is the day when Goddess Durga slayed the demon Mahishasura after nine days of fight.. Also Rama killed Ravana today.. 8y
Lindy @Varshitha Enjoy the final day of the festival! 🎉 8y
29 likes9 comments
blurb
shawnmooney
post image
Lindy I think you've got it exactly right. The in-between state can be positive or negative, as Venki points out to Leela. 8y
Lindy Being of mixed ethnic background. Being an immigrant. Being from a town that disappeared in the borderlands when India was partitioned. Many examples that have to do with one's physical place or place in society. 8y
Lindy There's a passage about Leela praying fervently twice a day, "her fierce belief in gods that she could neither see nor hear jostling against the empirical truths of the maths and sciences she studied at university. She embraced the erratic gods on one side and rationalism on the other. Half of this and half of that." 8y
shawnmooney @Lindy You've made so many great connections to the Trishanku myth! 👏👏👏👏 8y
24 likes4 comments
blurb
shawnmooney
post image
Lindy While I wouldn't go as far as "deep joy" I was pleased at the way the coincidence was positioned in the story. A satisfying trajectory from the initial introduction, during the ride to the airport, to its culmination at the end of Book 2. 8y
Lindy Bibi-ji as a 6-year-old seemed more like a teenager, loathing "the grating, ever-present irritation in her mother's voice, the heat, the dust, the smallness of Panjaur." Other than that false note, I've been enjoying the characterizations. 8y
Lindy Indian is my favourite cuisine. Yes, it's Thanksgiving today in Canada. I'm going to make Punjabi-style greens, served with rice, dhal, yogurt, and my newest batch of kimchee. 8y
See All 7 Comments
Lindy Food is an important component of culture, especially for immigrants. It makes sense that the grocery store and then the restaurant keep Bibi-ji at the hub of her community. Food also starts her friendship with Leela. I am often influenced by what I'm reading, so I foresee even more Indian meals at my house than usual. 8y
Dragon Coincidentally @shawnmooney and @Lindy my friend gave me some homemade chicken curry for lunch today . Happy 🦃🇨🇦 8y
shawnmooney @Lindy I'm not sure why the coincidence worked for me so deeply, but maybe because of a coincidence anecdote in my family's background – one that didn't have such important consequences, but still. 8y
shawnmooney @Lindy Now that you mention it, I agree: I hadn't taken any notice it at the time but certainly you make a good point about how Sharan was portrayed at the age of 6. 8y
21 likes7 comments
quote
shawnmooney
post image

quote
shawnmooney
post image

blurb
Lindy
post image

My garden currently looks like this. A good day to stay curled up inside with #diversereads author Anita Rau Badami.

SusanInTiburon That's what I'm reading this morning too, but my scenery is much different. 8y
Dragon Snow already !❄️ 8y
Lindy @SusanInTiburon I have even made notes for our upcoming discussion. 😊 8y
See All 7 Comments
Lindy @dragon I hope it won't stay more than a few days. Still have perennials to cut back and other gardening tasks. 8y
shawnmooney Notes? I'm impressed! 👏👏👏👏 8y
SusanInTiburon @lindy What part of the world do you live in? I'm in California. 8y
Lindy @SusanInTiburon I'm in Edmonton, Alberta. Where we enjoy 8 months of winter. ❄️ 8y
37 likes7 comments
blurb
Lindy
post image

Starting this tonight. My mom read it for her book club, so long ago I can't remember when, then gifted it to me. It's in hardcover, published 2006, so I may have had for 10 years. Yikes!

Riveted_Reader_Melissa So it's new to you and a TBT! 8y
32 likes1 comment
quote
shawnmooney
post image

17 likes1 stack add
quote
shawnmooney
post image

Lindy I plan to start reading this today. I promise to be ready for the first discussion! 8y
shawnmooney @Lindy I had no doubts about that. But great! 8y
22 likes2 comments
quote
shawnmooney
post image

@Lindy @Mayread @ramyasbookshelf @Skiles @SusanInTiburon @Dragon In researching this quote, I stumbled upon an article online that may interest you – I haven't read it in its entirety yet. Title: "Recipe Fiction and the Undercooked Nightbird - Reading Anita Rau Badami‘s Can You Hear the Nightbird Call?" http://kriticulture.blogspot.jp/2008/05/recipe-fiction-and-undercooked.html

shawnmooney Wait! I hereby retract my recommendation of this article, which I had barely skimmed earlier: now that I've read the thesis sentence, I'm about to lose my breakfast: "Badami‘s basic problem in this novel is her inability to confront the constitutive ambivalence of her subject position as a postcolonial-diasporic writer in a specific situation under late capitalism." 8y
Dragon I don't think I understand that sentence 👀 ? 8y
shawnmooney @dragon Exactly. It's the kind of horrible academic writing I used to have to read at grad school. BLECH! 8y
Dragon I think I'll be skipping that article 8y
SusanInTiburon @Dragon @shawnmooney 😂😂 but it has such an enticing title! 8y
16 likes5 comments
quote
shawnmooney
post image

blurb
shawnmooney
post image

@Lindy @Mayread @ramyasbookshelf @Skiles @SusanInTiburon @Dragon

If you have Apple Music or some similar music service, this is a wonderful album to listen to while you're reading the novel. Or do you have some other suggestions? Bring them on!

SusanInTiburon Ooo, good suggestion! 8y
30 likes1 comment
quote
shawnmooney
post image

quote
shawnmooney
post image

22 likes2 stack adds
quote
shawnmooney
post image

quote
shawnmooney
post image

Gora: Indian slang for a white person
It's not a spoiler to direct you to a synopsis of the fate of this ship, the Komagata Maru, but it is one of Canada's deepest shames: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Komagata_Maru_incident

quote
shawnmooney
post image

quote
shawnmooney
post image

LeahBergen I need to get to this one. I love Badami. 8y
shawnmooney @LeahBergen If you are interested, join in the Litsy discussion some of us are having this month - the details including reading schedule are in my August blurb - we are going to start the first chunk on Oct 10. 8y
12 likes2 comments
quote
shawnmooney
post image

blurb
shawnmooney
post image

I'm back in Canada for a week, now at my parents' house in the city of Saskatoon. Here's a book from my mom's shelf that she loves and has urged me to read for years, even buying me my own copy which remains unread in a box somewhere. I must get to it someday… I once found myself seated beside Badami at a literary event in Vancouver and had a lovely chat.

Lindy My mom gave me a copy too. Still haven't read it. 8y
shawnmooney @lindy Interested in finally reading it and discussing it together on Litsy later this fall? 8y
Lindy Yes! Good idea. 8y
See All 19 Comments
shawnmooney @Lindy Great! I'll take Mom's copy back to Tokyo with me. I'd be ready to do this in October at the earliest. Sounds fun! 8y
Lindy @shawnmooney I hope it's more like Tamarind Mem (loved) and not like Tell it to the Trees (disliked). 8y
shawnmooney @Dragon and @Skiles and anyone else please feel free to join in our discussion later in the fall if you'd like! 8y
Mayread October onward sounds great! I'm in! 8y
ramyasbookshelf This sounds really awesome. I'll try to get my hands on a copy too! 8y
SusanInTiburon May I? Any book so highly recommended by two mothers can't be all bad. 8y
SusanInTiburon @shawnmooney Got my copy! Saving it for October or so. 8y
shawnmooney @Lindy @Mayread @ramyasbookshelf @Skiles @SusanInTiburon @Dragon Looking forward to our discussion beginning next month. Because I won't be able to start reading until October 1 I suggest one of two options:

Option A: We begin discussing the entire novel, which we will all have finished reading, on November 1.

Option B: we discuss the novel in chunks, beginning in October. Something like this breakdown:

Parts I & II: Week of Oct 10-16
8y
shawnmooney @Lindy @Mayread @ramyasbookshelf @Skiles @SusanInTiburon @Dragon

Parts III & IV: Week of Oct 17-23

Part V & Epilogue: Week of Oct 24-31

What do you think? Please suggest other ideas or a different breakdown. I look forward to your thoughts!

(If anyone wants to be removed from the tag list, please let me know…)
8y
SusanInTiburon Either plan works for me but Option B sounds more fun and interactive. Looking forward to this. 8y
ramyasbookshelf I'm leaning towards discussing the books in chunks as well! Thanks for your reminder.. I need to get this book soon :)) 8y
Lindy Plan B sounds good because I've never discussed a novel in chunks before and I'd like to try it. 8y
shawnmooney @Lindy @Mayread @ramyasbookshelf @Skiles @SusanInTiburon @Dragon Okay! Let's do it in chunks. I'm looking forward to discussing parts 1 and 2 starting on October 10! :-) 8y
SusanInTiburon Looking forward to it! 8y
Dragon I really liked 8y
50 likes5 stack adds19 comments