Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The Perfect Heresy
The Perfect Heresy: The Revolutionary Life and Death of the Medieval Cathars | Stephen O'Shea
14 posts | 5 read | 5 to read
Eight hundred years ago, the Cathars, a group of heretical Christians from all walks of society, high and low, flourished in what is now the Languedoc in Southern France. Their subversive beliefs brought down on them the wrath of Popes and monarchs and provoked a brutal 'Crusade' against them. The final defeat of the Cathars was horrific with mass burnings of men, women and children in the village of Montaillou in the Pyrenees.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
Texreader
post image
Pickpick

Catharism was a Christian sect in south France that defied most everything the “Church” required of its believers. Christians should strive to be like Jesus, a poor man who respected men and women. Cathars reincarnated until they are “Perfect” and finally are released from their corporal bodies to join Christ. This heresy in the 11-1200s was so antithetical to the Church that it called on a crusade to kill them all, ultimately succeeding. ⬇️

Texreader O‘Shea is an excellent writer and historian, making ancient primary sources accessible. I was confused by the first few chapters but as the story of the crusade developed it was almost impossible to put down. I learned so much about a fascinating Christian sect I knew nothing about and which predated Protestantism. Trigger warnings: the Church and its henchmen were cruel and brutal. Many thousands died cruel, painful deaths. #foodandlit #France 2y
Catsandbooks Wow! 😱😬 2y
52 likes2 comments
blurb
Texreader
post image

I remembered to complete my July #readingbracket. Another close decision between the tagged book & Chimpanzee Whisperer. This one won out because I love O‘Shea‘s writing style. And dang did I ever learn a lot about the medieval Christian sect of Cathars, and French and crusader history in Europe. I thought the crusades all occurred to retake Jerusalem over and over. And who knew there were Christians who believed in reincarnation? Review to come.

quote
Texreader
post image

“His Franciscan kinsman, also ahead of his time, hit upon the medieval equivalent of wearing a wire.”

This author just has a way with words I love, making historical footnotes accessible for the modern reader. Here, the inquisition is fereting out those blasphemous heretics (also Christians, but who didn‘t follow the Church‘s money-grubbing approach to being saved).

#foodandlit #France (yes I‘m behind) @Catsandbooks @Butterfinger

quote
Texreader
post image

It‘s time to reach for google again. “By then the donnybrook was on.” A new word to work into conversation this coming week!

This author always makes me chuckle!

#France #foodandlit @Catsandbooks @Butterfinger

MaureenMc Our local PBS station has a long-running political talk show called Donnybrook. 😊 2y
Texreader @MaureenMc 😂😂 2y
44 likes2 comments
blurb
Texreader
post image

Hey y‘all, I found a way to use this unusual phrase (see my previous post for the tagged book). Tonight I got to see my son‘s photos from his trip to Ireland, England, and France. He cocked a snook at Cambridge when he visited the university there a few days ago, wearing the T-shirt we bought when we visited Oxford a few years ago.

That‘s my kid! Im pretty sure I used it correctly. Yes? 😂😂😂

AshleyHoss820 Cocked a snook! You did it!! 🤣🤣🤣 2y
Prairiegirl_reading That is hilarious!!! 2y
marleed That‘s great! 2y
See All 10 Comments
TrishB We definitely don‘t use it everyday though 😁 2y
Amandajoy Love it! 2y
rabbitprincess 🤣🤣🤣 I like his style! 2y
julesG You did it!!! Also, can't believe the shirt still fits. That must have been 5 years when we met at Foyles. 2y
Texreader @julesG 😂😂😂 We bought the smallest size at the time. He‘s now grown into it. Can you believe that‘s the same little boy you met when we were in London? 2y
Texreader @AshleyHoss820 @Prairiegirl_reading @marleed @TrishB @Amandajoy @rabbitprincess So I tried “cocked a snook” out in a client meeting today. I‘m now on a single person crusade to bring this term into common usage in the USA! 😂😂😂 2y
julesG It's hard to fathom. 😁 But they all grow up. My son is turning 17 in a few weeks and he's taller than me; he was only a baby yesterday. 2y
63 likes10 comments
quote
Texreader
post image

I now know what “cocking a snook” means even though I had to google it. Hmmm…

How can I fit this phrase into my everyday life? Hmmm…

Prairiegirl_reading I have never heard that before! 2y
marleed Oh I just googled to - trusting that it didn‘t send you to questionable websites! That‘s a great phrase, and I‘m going to see if I can fit it in conversation this week. Funny because last week I went googling and you-tubing what the British Beans on Toast was all about. 2y
Amandajoy And this thread just sent me to Google. That‘s a fun phrase. 2y
43 likes3 comments
quote
Texreader
post image

“Whereas the hubbub of café debate in say, Normandy, sounds like a mellifluous exchange between articulate cows, the tenor of the same discussion in Languedoc is akin to a musician tuning a large, and very loud, guitar. This, the echo of old Occitan, can be heard everywhere.”

I wonder how the French feel about this description of their tone of speech! ??

#foodandlit #France @Catsandbooks @Butterfinger

GingerAntics 😂🤣😂 2y
GingerAntics I think the title sums it up. 2y
Dilara This French person is annoyed! Also, Occitan is very much not dead... 2y
43 likes3 comments
quote
Texreader
post image

The author is looking on at a cathedral built by Bishop Castanet in the 1200s to crush any “heretical” Cathars remained alive following the crusade aimed to kill fellow Christians. I love this author‘s way with words:

“Only a disagreement over something as fathomless as the soul of a civilization could elicit a shout so loud that it was still audible across the chasm of 700 years.“

#foodandlit #France

blurb
Texreader
post image

To set the stage for this French history book here‘s a map of Europe in the 1200s. #foodandljt #France @Catsandbooks @Butterfinger

Catsandbooks Love a map! 2y
GingerAntics Love a map. Love what is now English, Wales, Scotland, and Ireland just hanging out there on their own, minding their own business, hardly involved at all. (edited) 2y
55 likes3 comments
blurb
Texreader
post image

I‘m very excited to start this one for #foodandlt #France. I read O‘Shea‘s book The Alps about his travel in the Alps. I enjoyed it immensely and I immediately ordered everything he‘d written (and sent him a fan email which he answered). So I‘m looking forward to some French history!

53 likes1 stack add
blurb
Texreader
post image

Did I mention I liked this author so much after reading The Alps, I bought all his other books (4 of them)? The first one‘s arrived! 😍

GingerAntics Oh wow. I‘m excited to see what you think of them all. 4y
Texreader @GingerAntics Yea...I can‘t wait! 🥳 4y
GingerAntics This one just sounds fun based on the title. Is it fiction or nonfiction? 4y
Texreader @GingerAntics Nonfiction. 4y
GingerAntics Oooooh 💙💙💙 4y
55 likes2 stack adds5 comments
review
Classic_Wirginia
Pickpick

I've been reading into medieval and antiquated religions for a few weeks now. O'Shea did not disappoint. It's an easy to follow non-fiction book with information that will hopefully entertain at some dinner party. If nothing else, I feel smarter for reading it :)

2 likes1 stack add
quote
Classic_Wirginia
post image

...the bishop of Amalfi dropped dead...
O'Shea says from suffocation, I say from fangirling all over the Pope.

quote
Classic_Wirginia
post image

"I'm gonna get medieval on yo' ass" if only more nonfiction authors got readers' attention like this.