Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
JillR

JillR

Joined March 2017

review
JillR
The Narrow Land | Christine Dwyer Hickey
post image
Pickpick

I really enjoyed this. An artist couple living in isolation on Cape Cod (the real life artists Jo and Edward Hopper) get drawn into the lives of two boys and the extended family. The boys are heartbreaking and delightful; I loved seeing artist Mr Aitch get drawn out of himself by them. I pretty much hated everyone else, but in the best bookish way. There‘s a lot not told, it‘s left to the reader to interpret. It‘s slow, thoughtful and gentle.

squirrelbrain Love that cover - very Hopper-esque. 4d
sarahbarnes Sounds intriguing! And agree with @squirrelbrain - I was thinking the same thing. 4d
28 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
JillR
Penance | Eliza Clark
post image
Pickpick

This is page-turningly unpleasant, depicts perfectly the mundanity and awfulness of school and teen bullying, brilliantly reflects a Leave-voting town and its hierarchy and residents. Yet I also had issues with it. The pages and pages of the minutiae of teen lives was too much, the characters within the town were so obvious it must have been intentional but felt clunky to me. Yet despite those issues, overall this was an intriguing read 👇

JillR Yet despite the blurbs telling me I haven‘t, I kind of HAVE read something like this before - see Joseph Knox‘s excellent True Crime Story. Anyone else? 7d
23 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
JillR
The Secret River | Kate Grenville
post image
Pickpick

William Thornhill makes a mistake and is shipped to Australia. He and his fellow settlers face up to life on colonised land, as slowly those indigenous to the land push back against them. There‘s a terrible sense of the inevitable, a deep frustration towards the settlers ignorance, a foreboding of what we know must come to pass. I found this incredibly well told and the tension mounts perfectly but to a really awful ending; you can‘t look away.

30 likes1 stack add
review
JillR
State of Wonder | Ann Patchett
post image
Pickpick

“Full of big ideas and marvellously peculiar characters.” Oh I did love this. It was quiet, gentle, crazy, peculiar, completely absorbing. I fell hard for all those characters and it broke my heart 🐍

LeeRHarry It‘s my favourite Ann Patchett - glad you enjoyed it. 😊 3w
JillR I did, it felt very different from the other books of hers I‘ve read. I‘ll be starting Tom Lake soon. 3w
Hooked_on_books This one and Tom Lake are my two favorites of hers so far, though I do have a few on her back list still to get to. 3w
JillR @Hooked_on_books I‘ve got Tom Lake waiting to be read; I‘ve previously read and enjoyed The Dutch House and Commonwealth 3w
29 likes4 comments
review
JillR
post image
Pickpick

I‘d heard good things about this but didn‘t actually know what it was about and went in blind. Ooof, it was NOT what I thought it would be. I got a really great, intriguing, interesting (yet unpleasant and unsettling) story with another layer unfolding just as I thought I‘d got the better of the plot line. I‘m going to say I thought some elements of Sally were perhaps a little heavy handed, however niggles aside this was a great read.

squirrelbrain I did the same as you - no clue when going in and, goodness me, it was dark. 3w
JillR @squirrelbrain wasn‘t it - echoes of Room and Girl A, but with a different edge? Cover bears no resemblance to the story - I thought it might even be historical fiction! 3w
squirrelbrain Yes, I did too - the HF thing. It looks like an old-fashioned maid‘s uniform. I really disliked the ending - he seemed to get free and she regressed - very depressing. 3w
JillR @Squirrel yes good point about the ending, and I had such mixed feelings about him. (edited) 3w
34 likes4 comments
review
JillR
Wandering Souls | Cecile Pin
post image
Pickpick

What a lovely, sad, well-told story. Anh and her two younger brothers are sent away from Vietnam with the rest of the family to follow later. Yet only Anh and her brothers make it and from there they move from refugee camp to camp, before finally being resettled in 1980s Britain. I loved every bit of it; the compassionate storytelling, the clean, clear writing and the simply told and unflinching look at the refugee experience.

Kitta Sounds amazing. Stacked! 4w
25 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
JillR
Hello Beautiful | Ann Napolitano
post image
Pickpick

A lovely book, I thoroughly enjoyed this. I do love a good family saga. This had a similar quiet quirkiness of an Ann Tyler novel (always a good thing). The Little Women analogy was generally lost on me and, I think, unnecessary and occasionally it tipped into being saccharine, but I‘m always hyper-critical of anything being too sweet, so that‘s on me. The final chapters nearly broke me.

review
JillR
1984 | George Orwell
post image
Pickpick

A reread, almost 30-years to the day that I last read it for A-Level English Literature. Wanted to reread before Sandra Newman‘s retelling, Julia. I loved it then and I loved it again now. Can I feel another Orwell deep dive coming on?

Hooked_on_books I read this pairing earlier this year and really enjoyed both. 1mo
37 likes1 comment
review
JillR
Fair Rosaline | Natasha Solomons
post image
Pickpick

“The quick anger of these men was not useful.” I do love a retelling and this one - or rather, an “untelling” - is a good one. For what happens before Romeo meets Juliet? What passes between Romeo and fair Rosaline? Here we find out in all its gory, unpleasant detail. I‘m coming at this as a lover of historical fiction, not a Shakespeare scholar. In that context, great as a retelling, equally good as standalone historical fiction.

26 likes1 stack add
review
JillR
The Garnett Girls | Georgina Moore
post image
Mehso-so

Hmm, on paper everything about this was my sort of book. A close knit family, secrets slowly emerging… Yet something was just a bit off about it. I never quite felt absorbed by the characters, and actively disliked matriarch Margo; I just could not get past her constant self-absorption and didn‘t buy into the great Richard-Margo love affair that the entire story centres around. It‘s readable but forgettable I‘m afraid…

review
JillR
Anatomy of a Scandal | Sarah Vaughan
post image
Pickpick

This got off to an excellent start and I was completely gripped. I do love a good courtroom drama. I enjoyed the switching perspectives and differing timelines too. However! There is a but (see comments). And so, once those doubts hit me, it threw me off and I didn‘t quite get back on track. Still a great rollercoaster of a story however…

JillR Our super-barrister character, Kate, makes a decision that I just could not buy into (despite it making a good story). I just could not accept that this professional, career driven, ruthless and highly skilled barrister, who had spent years honing her craft (for it is a craft), would ever make that decision (no spoilers). 2mo
24 likes1 comment
review
JillR
post image
Pickpick

I thoroughly enjoyed this story of Helena‘s growing love for Greece in the late 60s and 70s, combined with her fear of her Greek grandfather and the slow unravelling of his life and past, intertwined with her growing knowledge of archaeology and appropriation. Easy reading, interesting and completely transports you to Athens and the Greek islands - perfect reading for a sunny end of August weekend.

review
JillR
Drowning | T.J. Newman
post image
Pickpick

A plane crashes, survivors are trapped in it, it sinks into the ocean, where IT LANDS ON THE VERY EDGE OF A SEA CLIFF. With barely any oxygen left. Goodness me, despite being fiction, this is as claustrophobic and terrifying as it sounds, I could barely breathe. I survived it, but was on high alert for every one of the 287 pages and now need a lie down. If you like that vibe, definitely read it, it‘s faced paced and well written.

review
JillR
The Fraud | Zadie Smith
post image
Pickpick

I really enjoyed the premise of this story, and there were parts I whizzed through, but overall I found it long and at times difficult to follow, and very nearly gave up. Similar to how I felt about Wolf Hall in fact. I think this was a little too literary for me and I‘m disappointed as it‘s a story I wanted to hear. I deliberated but am giving it a light pick as I appreciated the quality of writing. Moving on…

review
JillR
The Hike | Lucy Clarke
post image
Pickpick

Not my usual genre, but I really enjoyed this. No eye-rolling, as there often is, just a gripping story that I fully bought into.

23 likes2 stack adds
review
JillR
The Seventh Son | Sebastian Faulks
post image
Pickpick

Very readable, often intriguing, however this also left me a little puzzled. At times it was a family drama, others a coming of age story, it touched on dystopia, and was also quite science-y. Overall I liked it; I enjoyed the writing which had a quiet gentleness to it, “an elegance”, I‘ve seen it described as. I came away sad and feeling slightly muddled, thinking a lot, which isn‘t a bad thing.

emmasm08 I have it to read ! I‘m intrigued now ! 2mo
JillR @emmasm08 do let me know when you get to it, interested what you make of it… 2mo
30 likes2 comments
review
JillR
post image
Pickpick

This follows Min as he struggles to understand his girlfriend Yu-Jin‘s apparent suicide, alternating with chapters from Yu-Jin‘s perspective. The style worked here, I enjoyed the slow unfolding of Yu-Jin‘s story and the pressures she was under. I loved returning to Korea, this time Seoul. My only complaint is that it was so very slow I became impatient with it at times but overall, despite the subject, a sweet, quiet, gentle read.

review
JillR
Mr. Rochester | Sarah Shoemaker
post image
Pickpick

Once again reading retellings of classics, but wait! I have actually read and enjoyed Jane Eyre. As the title suggests, this is the story from Edward‘s perspective. We meet him as a young boy, and follow him up to and through the story we know of him meeting and falling in love with Jane. Your heart will break for him as a boy, you may dislike him as a young man, he may/may not redeem himself; thoroughly enjoyed it.

review
JillR
post image
Pickpick

A book group read; I really liked this lovely, sad, sweet book. I will always fall for a mother/son trope; this one had me 😭

review
JillR
post image
Pickpick

A gripping, page-turning read on first impressions; think 24 vibes, it was going well. However there was eye-rolling and definite overuse of the word evil. Then about two thirds in it takes an unexpected turn and I was like, WHAT book am I now reading?! Not the book I wanted to read! I kept reading - the final section tries to pull it around - and it was gripping in parts, but overall mixed feelings and that “twist” was just bizarre 👇

JillR This is a pick because it kept me reading, but a light one. I can find very few reviews so am wondering whether after the hype/wait for this one it‘s fallen flat? 3mo
22 likes1 comment
review
JillR
post image
Bailedbailed

I don‘t know why I do this. I cannot do clutzy/chaotic girl + dashing/surly man. I eye roll more than swoon, and I cannot do the weird possessive/borderline aggressive vibe that just doesn‘t feel ok. It‘s my own fault, I should know better, I‘ve been here before. Bailing at 100 pages (only got that far because it was all I had to read on the train 😳).

Cathythoughts Oh no 🙈. The train. I still fall into the same traps too sometimes 🙄 onwards and upwards. 3mo
TrishB I think we all do that occasionally. 3mo
BooksNBowls I don‘t get the hype around Tessa Bailey. Her dudes are always so cringe!! 3mo
23 likes3 comments
review
JillR
The Parisian | Isabella Hammad
post image
Pickpick

This was a tough one. It is very literary, I had to really pay attention. It covers a complex period in Palestinian history which I knew little about and rightly the author doesn‘t hand this to you on a plate. It is also a touching love story and family saga and I was really absorbed by those elements. It had the odd effect of being both hard work and relaxing. I persevered and I‘m glad I did as I feel a sense of achievement and I‘ve learned a lot

sarahbarnes I liked Enter Ghost and this one sounds interesting, if challenging. 3mo
28 likes1 comment
review
JillR
post image
Pickpick

So this was making me eye roll a little (still being book-grumpy) and I was on the verge of putting it aside. Then it turned somewhat ridiculous, but actually that snapped me back into it and I ended up being quite moved by it. Still a bit ambivalent about it in parts, but also moved. Ambivalently moved? 😆 A light pick for me.

TheLudicReader I think you can roll your eyes and be moved simultaneously. Happens to me all the damn time. 3mo
JillR @TheLudicReader I agree! 3mo
26 likes2 comments
review
JillR
Tsarina | Ellen Alpsten
post image
Pickpick

This is solid historical fiction and I particularly enjoyed the first half; watching young Marta emerge from poverty to become Peter the Great‘s wife Catherine, the Empress of Russia. The story would be unbelievable were it not true. I admit however that I did tire of the second half; there‘s only so much constant war, mistresses, brutal murders and doomed pregnancies I felt able to take!

29 likes1 stack add
review
JillR
Mad Honey | Jodi Picoult, Jennifer Finney Boylan
post image
Pickpick

I don‘t read a lot of Jodi Picoult these days, I feel like I‘ve grown out of her writing style. However this was just what I needed right now - easy, gripping, a great twist, treated with an overall sensitivity. Can‘t say much more without spoiling! I also very much liked the background to the two authors co-writing this book, and feel that was very much the right decision for this particular book too.

review
JillR
Go as a River: A novel | Shelley Read
post image
Pickpick

An immediately absorbing story, but in the large part it was unremittingly bleak. I like bleak, but this was very bleak. With echoes of Where the Crawdads Sing, Victoria is left unmoored by the death of her mother aged 12, left in a household of men who expect her to assume her mother‘s role. When she falls in love with Wilson Moon things unravel. My book group loved this. I enjoyed it but also had some niggles, not sure if I‘m being overly picky…

TrishB Another one sat on my kindle! 4mo
sarahbarnes Someone recently recommended this to me - I was curious but your review isn‘t making me want to rush out and get to it. 4mo
Cathythoughts I‘m glad of your review. I‘m not going to rush to it either.. Crawdads was good , but I was wondering about this one. I‘m in no hurry now. 👍🏻❤️ 4mo
See All 7 Comments
TheLudicReader I loved this one so much more than Crawdads. I found the main character so resilient and I loved her. Bleak, yes, at times, but also beautiful. 4mo
JillR @sarahbarnes @Cathythoughts @TheLudicReader I read this with my book group and they all adored it, I think overall it got one of our highest scores. I was the only one that had some minor issues, and acknowledge I‘m in a very odd reading mood right now! 4mo
TheLudicReader @JillR, isn‘t that the best thing about reading? We don‘t all have love like the same book or have the same reading experience. Like, I hate Colleen Hoover and others love her. 🤷‍♀️ 4mo
JillR @TheLudicReader definitely, and I also find our book group responses to books so interesting. In general I‘d say we all have very similar tastes book wise, but then quite often we have very different, unexpected thoughts! 4mo
34 likes7 comments
review
JillR
The Ferryman: A Novel | Justin Cronin
post image
Pickpick

The first half I loved. A dystopian future; the world building was great, I loved the characters. And then it swerved and I start thinking WHAT am I reading? I can‘t say more without spoiling, but all eventually becomes clear. Well, kind of. The problem was by then it‘d lost me somewhat and I feel like I just drifted to the end. I confess some of my struggle was that I just didn‘t really get the twist 👇

JillR I count Justin Cronin‘s The Passage trilogy as a favourite of all time, so was really looking forward to this and now I feel quite disappointed, though giving it a pick for the first half. 4mo
BethM The middle got slow. This could easily have been cut down by 100 pages. I ended up really enjoying it though. 4mo
32 likes2 comments
review
JillR
post image
Pickpick

Oh no, am I headed for a book slump? Reading this I liked the writing, appreciated the story, yet remained on the surface, not that interested, skim reading parts, although loving the cover. With this one, I‘m not sure whether it‘s me or the book 🤷‍♀️. After deliberating I‘m giving it a light pick, as I suspect it‘s me!

Cathythoughts I‘m sure it‘s not a slump 🤞🏻😘 4mo
33 likes1 stack add1 comment
review
JillR
post image
Pickpick

Love the title, love the cover, love the premise. Elements of this I really liked, but something was holding me back. I think sadly it suffered from being read straight after my last read which I loved and couldn‘t stop thinking about, yet at the same time it‘s a lovely, bittersweet story of love, yearning and the passage of time.

squirrelbrain I really liked this, which surprised me as it‘s not my usual fare. 5mo
JillR @squirrelbrain I remember you liking this one. I didn‘t not like it, but at the same time didn‘t feel very engaged with it, and I can‘t put my finger on why, beyond it being a book hangover situation! 5mo
34 likes2 comments
review
JillR
post image
Pickpick

In the most part I loved this. Such a sad, messy, heartbreaking story of a family unravelling, and why. Told from 4 different perspectives in turn, you don‘t always get the full story, the closure you want, but I loved the twists and turns on the previous perspectives. Both very easy to read, yet one where you need to keep your wits about you! The final 100 pages or so where the pace really ramps up were brilliant and I really loved the ending.

36 likes1 stack add
review
JillR
When He Was Wicked | Julia Quinn
post image
Mehso-so

Investing fully in Bridgerton fever and bridging (ha!) the gap between the new season with this…(Confession, my enthusiasm for the books is waning. Book five was dreadful, and I had issues with some of this one too. Maybe time to leave it to the TV show, which does it so much better?)

review
JillR
Bellies: A Novel | Nicola Dinan
post image
Pickpick

If you feel like the current spate of romance novels give you all the cheesy eye-rolls, my prescription…this book. It really is quite lovely and is as much about the love of friends as romantic love, the friends who hold you close and keep you safe.

squirrelbrain Good to know! I‘ve picked this up a lot in shops but never actually bought it. 5mo
JillR @squirrelbrain I wasn‘t sure it was for me, but overall found it very sweet, and very sad 5mo
33 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
JillR
The Covenant of Water | Abraham Verghese
post image
Pickpick

Just a few pages in that magic book-chemistry was there and I was instantly absorbed into this epic family saga centred around the family estate of Parambil in Kerala, India. The story spans 1900 - 1977, across three generations, many of whom suffer the mysterious “Condition” which makes them avoid water, at risk of drowning. There are so many threads and strands here, such a sad but beautiful story, I loved it.

Cathythoughts Lovely review. I loved it too ❤️ 5mo
squirrelbrain I loved this too! ❤️ 5mo
TrishB Me three!! 5mo
Tamra 💚💚 5mo
JillR @cathythoughts @trishb @squirrelbrain I love that you all loved this too x 5mo
45 likes1 stack add5 comments
review
JillR
post image
Pickpick

The first half felt like I was in the bar on Tatooine in Star Wars, with the crazy music and different species, and that was NOT the book I wanted to read! I stuck with it and ultimately became quite fond of the characters of the Wayfarer tunnelling ship as they made their way through space. It was actually quite a gentle, sensitive read, once I got past the beginning. That said it felt quite simplistic, perhaps YA, and overall I didn‘t love it

monalyisha Same! And I love her Monk & Robot books. 5mo
JillR @monalyisha I haven‘t read any of her other books, and not sure whether I will after this one. Interestingly the rest of my book group loved it. 5mo
39 likes2 comments
review
JillR
Yellowface | R F Kuang
post image
Pickpick

So good, I loved every bit of this despite the toe-curling, car-crash in slow motion. You will love to hate June and her petulant indignation at what befalls her. The author wrote June so well, and forces discomfort in the reader. Funny, gossipy, snarky and very knowing; great fun yet dealing with serious and very current issues including cultural appropriation, own voices and who gets to tell a story.

45 likes1 stack add
review
JillR
Fourth Wing | Rebecca Yarros
post image
Pickpick

LOVED it. By the time Violet‘s dragon bonded her, I was IN. Dragons, magic, numerous gruesome deaths, a bit of daft “sizzling” tension, great fun. I‘m all for the easy reads right now.

review
JillR
Weyward: A Novel | Emilia Hart
post image
Pickpick

A great read that I gulped down in two days (in the garden in the sunshine, what a treat). Three stories about three women across three very different times, with the thread of witchcraft running through each. I enjoyed each story, more so as the connections slowly emerged. I don‘t always enjoy the back and forth style of a dual/multiple timeline, but here it worked perfectly 🐦‍⬛

LeeRHarry This was a great read 😊 (edited) 6mo
42 likes1 comment
review
JillR
The Other Half | Charlotte Vassell
post image
Mehso-so

Oh I‘m really not sure about this one. A murder mystery amongst the wealthy elite of London, with a working class detective tasked to solve it. The blurb says it‘s a satire, but…I found it a little obvious, and more caricature than satire. And the daft character names drove me insane. I did finish it, and I did get drawn into the story, but overall there were too many loose ends and it‘s one I won‘t remember.

BarbaraBB I bought this one too and I can‘t remember why. Haven‘t read it yet but will temper my expectations 6mo
squirrelbrain I had an ARC of this and, like you, didn‘t love it. I think the second book in the series has just come out, and I won‘t be rushing to read it. 6mo
JillR @squirrelbrain I think I‘ll give it a miss! 6mo
29 likes3 comments
review
JillR
Fifteen Wild Decembers | Karen Powell
post image
Pickpick

This is a fictional take on the three Brontë sisters‘ upbringing in Haworth, told from Emily‘s perspective. This really does have the bleakness of her novel; the illnesses that plagued the family, their inability to hold down suitable work. At times this was quite hard to read; I didn‘t particularly like Emily, nor Charlotte, yet it left me incredibly moved and by the ending I was almost distraught 👇

JillR I‘ve not read or enjoyed a lot of classics, but I did love both Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre, so am wondering now whether to try Anne too? 6mo
Tamra I‘m looking forward to this one - even more after your review. 6mo
29 likes2 comments
review
JillR
Verity | Colleen Hoover
post image
Pickpick

I said I wasn‘t doing this, yet here I am. As always, late to the popularity party 😆. And do you know what, I enjoyed it. Book snobbery aside (there was eye rolling, of course) it‘s a page turner, very quick and easy reading, with a nicely creepy dark side. Yes it‘s daft, but you‘re not going into it looking for a Booker finalist. It was just what I wanted to read right now. I might even go for another, who‘d have thought.

Suet624 I‘m always late too. 6mo
Tamra Sometimes you just want candy. ☺️ 6mo
33 likes2 comments
review
JillR
In Memoriam | Alice Winn
post image
Pickpick

Gaunt and Elwood meet at boarding school. Gaunt taciturn, a boxer. Elwood beautiful, a poet. They adore each other but will not say it. Then the First World War happens and their lives split and collide. Did I need another book about WWI? I did not. Do I like First World War poetry? I do not. Did I love this book anyway? I did indeed. The most beautiful story of hidden love, friendship, privilege and class.

TrishB I loved it too ♥️ 6mo
BarbaraBB I want to read it! 6mo
Amor4Libros Stacking, this sounds so good! 6mo
See All 8 Comments
squirrelbrain I loved this one! ❤️ 6mo
JillR @squirrelbrain @trishb it‘s so good isn‘t it? I wasn‘t sure if I needed another WWI story, turns out I did! 6mo
Deblovestoread One of my favorites from last year. 6mo
emmasm08 It‘s a great read . 6mo
Cathythoughts I have it on the shelf .. must get to it soon ♥️ 6mo
40 likes2 stack adds8 comments
review
JillR
Homecoming | Kate Morton
post image
Pickpick

A sinister murder mystery in the Adelaide hills in 1959 combines with modern day Jess dashing back to Sydney from London to be with her ailing grandmother, whilst slowly trying to unravel the decades old mystery. As much about family, homesickness and belonging as the mystery at its heart; perfect, compulsive easy reading. I‘d steered away from this author for a while as I tired of her dual-timeline style, but very much enjoyed coming back.

31 likes3 stack adds
blurb
JillR
Books Are Magic | Brooklyn, NY (Bookstore)
post image

An explanation to the backdrop of my last post; we just got back from New York! New York Littens, we fell hard for your city ❤️. It was a jam-packed trip - the first visit for our two teenagers - but I managed a *little* book shopping. I was disappointed with Barnes and Noble, but the lovely Books are Magic in Brooklyn made up for that; I spent a wonderful hour or two browsing and buying, so absorbed I missed the earthquake!

squirrelbrain Ooh so jealous! It‘s aaages since I‘ve been to New York and I miss it. (And its bookshops!) 7mo
JillR @squirrelbrain we were last there 22 years ago and loved taking the kids back. Such a great trip (despite near biblical rain, earthquakes etc 😬) 7mo
squirrelbrain I can‘t believe you missed the earthquake! 🤪 7mo
See All 6 Comments
JillR @squirrelbrain we got all the emergency alerts on our phones but didn‘t feel a thing! 7mo
BethM This picture looks magical! 7mo
Kitta Glad you had a good time! I live in Brooklyn but have never been to Books are Magic (I‘ll go soon!!). There‘s a really great feminist bookshop near me called 7mo
38 likes6 comments
review
JillR
Romantic Comedy | Curtis Sittenfeld
post image
Pickpick

A perfect holiday book; sharp, snappy, instantly absorbing yet easy to dip in and out of. This had all the elements I might have disliked in a romance; it‘s super cheesy, somewhat unbelievable, eye-rolling dialogue at times. Yet at the same time it just worked and I loved all those things too. I love Curtis Sittenfeld and kind of think she‘s a smarter, more knowing Anne Tyler. Her writing has that simplicity, yet she gets right to the crux of it.

review
JillR
The Makioka Sisters | Jun'ichiro Tanizaki
post image
Mehso-so

Written in the 1940s about the lives of the 4 well to-do Makioka sisters this had all the elements of translated Japanese fiction I enjoy; the gentle style, the formality with which people address each other, the need for rules, politeness and order. And yet, this was just so incredibly slow. Even the drama unfolds painfully slowly. At first I settled into the pace, but around 300 pages in I was getting impatient and it was a struggle to finish.

BarbaraBB This is why I have kept off reading it while I love all the ingredients you mention too! 7mo
JillR @BarbaraBB I deliberated between a pick and so-so as I did finish it (all 600 pages) and there were lots of elements I liked. It was just too long for the very slow pace for me. I‘m glad I read it, just could have done with 200 pages less of it 😆 7mo
34 likes2 comments
review
JillR
Cutting for Stone: A Novel | Abraham Verghese
post image
Pickpick

Marion is born a conjoined twin in Addis Ababa. Family life gets off to a very rough start and from there we follow his life, to adulthood and onwards to New York. The joy of this book is the family love and complexities, against the background of troubled Ethiopia, its own complexities, and its medical world. In summary, I loved this when I first read it 10 years ago, and I then loved it again. Be warned, it will break your heart.

Kitta Loved this 7mo
TrishB A great read 👍🏻 7mo
47 likes2 comments
review
JillR
post image
Pickpick

Wealthy New Yorkers faffing around and complaining? Yes please! I kind of enjoyed this at surface level; it‘s easy reading, it‘s knowing of its characters privilege, although at the same time it was mildly…disappointing? It didn‘t really go anywhere, the snarkiness wasn‘t snarky enough, the dramas not dramatic enough and it didn‘t hit the heights of Fleishman is in Trouble/Succession as I‘d hoped. A pick, but a low-ish one…

squirrelbrain I agree - this was very over-hyped when it came out and I found it OK ish but no more than that. 8mo
batsy I added it to my TBR early on during the hype but seen many reviews say the same about it being just OK. I'll read Fleishman instead (then watch the show!) 8mo
39 likes2 comments
review
JillR
Patsy | Nicole Dennis-Benn
post image
Pickpick

Patsy is desperate to leave Jamaica. Leaving her daughter behind, she heads to New York. It isn‘t the utopia she hopes and she enters an undocumented life barely scraping by doing menial work. As the story progresses you learn more of Patsy‘s motivations and demons. The story explores race, sex, class, gender, immigration and the life of an undocumented migrant in a hostile country. A great, thoughtful and thought-provoking read 👇

JillR I should say however I found this incredibly hard to get into, more or less for the first 200 pages, and very mainly bailed before something clicked. It also took most of the book to not actively dislike Patsy. 8mo
39 likes1 comment
review
JillR
The Outcast | Sadie Jones
post image
Pickpick

This is beautiful historical fiction; Lewis loses his beloved mother at 10 years old, not long after he had to get to know his father who had been away fighting in WWII for four years, during which time it was just him and Lizzie. As I‘ve said before a mother/son story is going to get me every time! This then takes a turn towards the dark, then gets darker, and you hate it yet can‘t look away at the same time. As good as I remembered 👇

JillR I‘m a big fan of Sadie Jones and often compare her to Maggie O‘Farrell and Kate Atkinson. I‘ve gone right back to the beginning with a reread of her debut here. 8mo
33 likes1 comment
review
JillR
post image
Pickpick

A quiet story, the sort that makes me a bit fidgety at the start, but still it drew me in and was really quite lovely. Ruth is reeling from IVF and the possible end of her marriage. Pen is coming of age against the painful backdrop of first love, learning how to manage her autism as she emerges into adulthood. I loved how their stories spanned only one day and gently crossed yet never got tangled.