Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Becoming a Man
Becoming a Man: The Story of a Transition | P. Carl
12 posts | 3 read | 4 to read
A memoir that is jolting, honest, passionate, and beautifully written (Claudia Rankine), Becoming a Man explores one mans gender transition amid a pivotal political moment in America. Becoming a Man is the striking memoir of P. Carls journey to become the man he always knew himself to be. For fifty years, he lived as a girl and a queer woman, building a career, a life, and a loving marriage, yet still waiting to realize himself in full. As Carl embarks on his gender transition, he takes us inside the complex shifts and questions that arise throughoutthe alternating moments of arrival and estrangement. He writes intimately about how transitioning reconfigures both his own inner experience and his closest bondshis twenty-year relationship with his wife, Lynette; his already tumultuous relationships with his parents; and seemingly solid friendships that are subtly altered, often painfully and wordlessly. Carl blends the remarkable story of his own personal journey with incisive cultural commentary, writing brilliantly about gender, power, and inequality in America. His transition occurs amid the rise of the Trump administration and the #MeToo movementa transition point in Americas own story, when transphobia and toxic masculinity are under fire even as they thrive in the highest halls of power. Carls quest to become himself and to reckon with his masculinity mirrors, in many ways, the challenge before the country as a whole, to imagine a society where every member can have a vibrant, livable life. Here, through this brave and deeply personal work, Carl brings an unparalleled new voice to this conversation.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
blurb
JenniferEgnor
post image

To all my trans friends & family, it‘s an honor to know you. My life is richer because you are in it. I see you, I celebrate you!!! #TransDayofVisability

IndoorDame 🏳️‍⚧️💗💙 2y
TheBookHippie 🏳️‍⚧️💕💙 2y
14 likes3 comments
blurb
JenniferEgnor
post image
IndoorDame Terrifying 2y
9 likes1 comment
review
JenniferEgnor
post image
Pickpick

Shown: Carl and his wife, Lynette.

I loved this book. I felt joy for him in some moments, and heart break in others. This is the story of Carl. He transitioned during the Trump years, during the time of ‘#metoo‘. He transitioned at 50 years old, experienced both misogyny and privilege; lost who he thought were friends, and discovered how strong his marriage really was. Highly recommend. Also recommend: stand up for your trans friends and

JenniferEgnor family. Hug them, tell them you love them. Don‘t wait. #transrightsarehumanrights #intersectionalfeminismistheonlyfeminism 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈🖤🤎 (edited) 2y
13 likes1 stack add1 comment
quote
JenniferEgnor
post image

The time it takes to transition a life, just a single life. We know there is never enough time to transition a country to become its best self. The shock of living through this time is feeling all the ways that people do not change, do not want you to change, and do not want the very thing they have pledged since their earliest school days, right hand over their heart: “liberty and justice for all.”

quote
JenniferEgnor
post image

Multiple truths and bodies are possible.

Shown: the pansexual flag. This means, one is attracted to personality, not gender. Carl‘s statement above, is how I feel as a pan person.

quote
JenniferEgnor
post image

It was a conversation that disappeared into my body, a body preferring to risk sickness or death rather than have a vaginal ultrasound.

(This is how Carl felt when he was told he had a cyst on his left ovary). 💔

quote
JenniferEgnor
post image

In the rare moments I have thought about my female anatomy, it‘s only to consider how to make it disappear. I yearned for my mother‘s breast cancer to be the genetic kind so I could have a preventive double mastectomy, and was disappointed when she called me gleefully to tell me it wasn‘t.

quote
JenniferEgnor
post image

Transitioning for a time is like pushing Polly off the top of a mountain. I have to burn down the house of Polly so that Carl can come out. It is an origin story, a state of creation, an unearthing of the him who has spent his whole life locked up, shape-shifting, sticking his head out periodically, but mostly living in a fight-or-flight state, just trying to survive. Polly was my friend and protector, but I wasn‘t her and she wasn‘t me. The

JenniferEgnor stories of him, of the ways he came to assert himself, are the stories of going crazy. He was my madman in the attic, confined like the women in nineteenth-century gothic novels; he was looking for a storyline to set him free. Carl was Polly‘s mental illness. She locked herself up to keep him safe. 2y
9 likes1 comment
quote
JenniferEgnor
post image

Why would anyone insist on mourning Polly? The joy of knowing you can finally see what I have always felt is a euphoria I never want to let go.

Shown: me and Amber, on the day she finally got her new DL, after her name was finally changed & legally recognized! She was so happy. She never told me her dead name, and I never asked. Why would I need to know? She‘s always been ‘Amber‘ and I love her so much. 🏳️‍⚧️

Riveted_Reader_Melissa Congratulations Amber! 2y
12 likes1 comment
quote
JenniferEgnor
post image

Transphobia isn‘t simply a fear of transgender people, or a misunderstanding of the interactions between nature and culture; it is the inability to inhabit what another body feels and properly link those feelings to thoughts and words.

review
lovelybookshelf
post image
Pickpick

Carl conveys all the messy (and joyful!) feelings and experiences that come with transitioning, especially doing so while married. I did find myself wishing he'd spent more time talking about toxic masculinity, though. Loved his writing style.

review
Floresj
post image
Pickpick

I don‘t know how to rate this book. Carl‘s memoir is about his family, his marriage, his struggle with gender roles, and the effects of his transition to becoming a man. It‘s completely out of my wheelhouse but, as a teacher, I‘ve noticed a growing number of students asking to be called a different gendered name and I wanted to understand it more. I still have a ways to go, and this book had more to offer than just gender transitions.

Suet624 It‘s great that you wanted to learn more about it. 💕 5y
12 likes1 comment