Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
The 21
The 21: A Journey Into the Land of Coptic Martyrs | Martin Mosebach
5 posts | 2 read | 3 to read
Behind a gruesome ISIS beheading video lies the untold story of the men in orange and the faith community that formed these unlikely modern-day saints and heroes. In a carefully choreographed propaganda video released in February 2015, ISIS militants behead twenty-one orange-clad Christian men on a Libyan beach. In the West, daily reports of new atrocities may have displaced the memory of this particularly vile event. But not in the world from which the murdered came. All but one were young Coptic Christian migrant workers from Egypt. Acclaimed literary writer Martin Mosebach traveled to the Egyptian village of El-Aour to meet their families and better understand the faith and culture that shaped such conviction. He finds himself welcomed into simple concrete homes through which swallows dart. Portraits of Jesus and Mary hang on the walls along with roughhewn shrines to now-famous loved ones. Mosebach is amazed time and again as, surrounded by children and goats, the bereaved replay the cruel propaganda video on an iPad. There is never any talk of revenge, but only the pride of having a martyr in the family, a saint in heaven. "The 21" appear on icons crowned like kings, celebrated even as their community grieves. A skeptical Westerner, Mosebach finds himself a stranger in this world in which everything is the reflection or fulfillment of biblical events, and facing persecution with courage is part of daily life. In twenty-one symbolic chapters, each preceded by a picture, Mosebach offers a travelogue of his encounter with a foreign culture and a church that has preserved the faith and liturgy of early Christianity - the "Church of the Martyrs." As a religious minority in Muslim Egypt, the Copts find themselves caught in a clash of civilizations. This book, then, is also an account of the spiritual life of an Arab country stretched between extremism and pluralism, between a rich biblical past and the shopping centers of New Cairo.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
review
DGRachel
post image
Panpan

Mine is a decidedly #unpopularopinion. Despite really wanting to bail, I powered through because I felt it was important to put my review out there, and I needed to finish it to feel that my review could be taken seriously. It is biased Christian propaganda, and I‘m saying that as a Christian. It is not a reliable look at the lives of 21 men slaughtered for their faith. It‘s repetitive and anti-Muslim.

jessinikkip Sometimes unpopular opinions can be the best 5y
Bklover Thanks for your review! 5y
58 likes2 comments
quote
DGRachel
post image

Just started this LibraryThing Early Reviewers Book I won back in February and I fear I‘m going to struggle with the bias already being shown. Martyrs are not exclusive to Christianity or even religion. 😔 But...is the issue the author or the translator? 🤔

GingerAntics I can definitely see having an issue with this book from the little bit you‘ve shown here. Definitely bias, but if a translator is involved then that could just as easily be the issue as the author. 5y
DGRachel @GingerAntics I didn‘t realize when I started that this was translated. I‘m willing to give the author a little leeway to allow for that, so we‘ll see. He claims his intent is to focus on the Coptic martyrs without discussing politics or Islam, but I‘m not sure how he‘s going to manage that. 5y
GingerAntics @DGRachel yeah, I think that‘s only fair, but there is still a limit. I don‘t see how he can do that either. That‘s interesting. I‘m intrigued to see if he can manage to pull that off. If he can, I will be impressed. 5y
See All 7 Comments
DGRachel @GingerAntics I‘m hoping he manages to give a voice to the men who were murdered without unintentionally spreading the ISIS propaganda. I‘m a firm believer in honoring the victims without naming the perpetrators, especially when it comes to things like terror attacks and mass shootings. Fingers crossed! 5y
GingerAntics @DGRachel oh I‘m with you 100% on that. I think we should do what NZ did and vow to never speak the terrorist‘s/mass shooter‘s names. I think the same should be true of serial killers. There is this show that‘s bringing to light a serial killer no one has heard of and I can‘t help wondering why. Let‘s talk about the victims and leave the killer nameless and anonymous. Just refer to him as “him.” 5y
GingerAntics Good luck. Fingers crossed. Keep us posted. 5y
rwmg From the extract, I don't think he's saying that only Christians can be martyred but challenging an assumption that the era of Christians being martyred as Christians is over. 5y
53 likes7 comments
blurb
Rhondareads
post image

A. Sect I really knew nothing about Coptic Martyrs sounds like a very informative look at this group .Thanks

blurb
DGRachel
post image

Big #bookmail day today! I thought the tagged book, a win from LibraryThing‘s Early Reviewers program was going to be an ARC, but it‘s a finished hard cover!🤩🤩 The other two books are for book clubs: #lmpbc and the first pick for my office book club (that I don‘t want to read, but I lead the group so I really don‘t have a choice 🤷🏻‍♀️).

Kayla.Adriena Hey the signups are open if you want to join us again or abandon ship haha it's up to you!! 6y
DGRachel @Kayla.Adriena I haven‘t been through my Litsy feed in a couple of days, so I didn‘t realize sign ups were open. I‘d love to join the group again! 6y
See All 6 Comments
DGRachel @Kayla.Adriena Oops. Looks like I was too slow. Group L is filled. 🤷🏻‍♀️ 6y
Kayla.Adriena @DGRachel aw shoot! I hope that doesn't discourage you from joining another one!! 6y
DGRachel @Kayla.Adriena No worries! 6y
97 likes1 stack add6 comments