Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#engishliterature
review
CarolynM
The Woods in Winter | Stella Gibbons
post image
Pickpick

Thank you, everyone, for lowering my expectations - I enjoyed this a lot. I loved straight talking Ivy with her witchy connection to wild things (including budding artistic geniuses) and the skewering of the “respectable” for their rigid adherence to social class and accepted behaviour. The final chapter was very satisfying, letting us know how things turned out for everyone. A great finish to our reading year with #FurrowedMiddlebrowClub.

Ruthiella It was an excellent end to the year! Here‘s to many more. ❤️ 6d
LeahBergen My expectations were lowered as well and I ended up liking it 😆 6d
Cuilin I liked it too. I really liked that the boy became a famous artist!!! 5d
67 likes3 comments
blurb
rubyslippersreads
The Woods in Winter | Stella Gibbons
post image

I ended up enjoying this book, although not all the characters were likeable (and I certainly wouldn‘t want to live in Ivy‘s cottage!) This vintage dust jacket is not at all how I picture a woman who‘s had three husbands and could have a fourth if she chose. 🤣

I was also interested to see that one of my favorite authors, Elizabeth Goudge, was a fan of Stella Gibbons. Next I‘m going to try Cold Comfort Farm.

#FurrowedMiddleBrowClub

Tamra Agreed, that image doesn‘t fit what I have in my mind either! 1w
TheEllieMo This is the second time I‘ve seen this book mentioned today…. It must be a sign *adds to TBR pile* 1w
See All 12 Comments
Cuilin @Tamra same @rubyslippersreads I may try Cold Comfort Farm too. And 1w
bookandbedandtea Amazing cover! 😂 Not what I had in mind either! 1w
Suet624 You‘re comment about this woman with the three husbands cracked me up 1w
Ruthiella I agree with you and @tamra and @cuilin and @bookandbedandtea that‘s not how I envisioned Ivy either! 😅I remember liking Cold Comfort Farm, though it has been a few years. (edited) 1w
Tamra @Ruthiella I did too, but it‘s been long enough that I don‘t remember details. 1w
LeahBergen Cold Comfort Farm is good! @Cuilin 1w
willaful Ivy clearly has plenty of sex appeal. This cover cracked me up. 1w
quietjenn I know it's not everyone's cup of tea, but Cold Comfort Farm is one of my favorites. 1w
CarolynM Not my vision of Ivy, either 🤣 I‘m just getting started and enjoying it so far. 1w
54 likes1 stack add12 comments
review
Tamra
The Woods in Winter | Stella Gibbons
post image
Mehso-so

I loved the charming scenes in Ivy‘s cottage, so cozy and sweet, despite the 🪳🪳🪳. The novel would have been better had it focused on Ivy as healer and hadn‘t spun out and around too many other threads that weren‘t very engaging.

I‘m not one for gushing sentimentality, but the final scene with Mike was 😭. #FurrowedMiddlebrowClub

P.S. I‘m still in denial about the season. 🫣

Ruthiella I‘m with you. It lacked focus. I also agree with you on the cockroaches! 🪳😱 😂 2w
LeahBergen That final scene with Mike got me! 😢 2w
CarolynM I‘m about half way through and enjoying it. I‘m a bit worried about where it‘s going given all the less than enthusiastic reviews 😬 1w
See All 6 Comments
Tamra @CarolynM there are some very charming and heartfelt bits, so it‘s worth it. (edited) 1w
Tamra @LeahBergen yea, that was a tear jerker! Ivy was wise enough to know best. 1w
Tamra @Ruthiella the cockroaches were completely unexpected! Definitely gave Ivy a distinct character. 1w
46 likes6 comments
review
swynn
Joseph Andrews | Henry Fielding
post image
Pickpick

(1742) Fielding's follow-up to Shamela continues his critique of Pamela. It's a gender-swapped comedy in which Pamela's brother Joseph resists his female employer's advances. Compared to Shamela, JA has more nuance, more satirical targets, and more than one joke. Of course jokes that worked for his audience often don't work for me: much of it is slapstick, some based on SA. But the humor of character, manners, and wordplay still get laughs from me

blurb
LeahBergen
The Woods in Winter | Stella Gibbons
post image

Here is our “master list” of what we‘ve read together as a group (to help out those of you who will be nominating our 2026 reads). Sorry for the small print; I threw it together quickly! 😆

#FurrowedMiddlebrowClub

catebutler @LeahBergen You are amazing!! Thank you! 2w
Tamra You are quick as a 🦊 2w
LeahBergen @catebutler No problem! It needed to be done. 😆 2w
See All 24 Comments
LeahBergen @Tamra Haha! Oh, and you are now bumped up to March. 😀 2w
Tamra @LeahBergen ok, I‘m ready! Just let me know when it‘s time to launch. 2w
CarolynM What a lot of great books we've read together! Such a pleasure to be part of this group 🥰 2w
Cuilin This is fantastic. 2w
Amiable That‘s impressive! 2w
LeahBergen @CarolynM @Cuilin @Amiable We‘ve had such a good time! 😄 2w
LeahBergen Okay, @willaful and @Tamra ! You two can post your two selections for January and March (respectively). Two voting posts should eliminate any overlap in nominations. 🤞 Don‘t forget to use our hashtag and tag everyone on this ⬆️ post. There was one more person added today. 😄 2w
Kimzey Great to see all the titles. Sorry I was late in responding earlier. Thanks for adding me back! Looking forward to seeing our new selections! 2w
bookandbedandtea I'm ready with a couple nominations 😊 2w
LeahBergen @Kimzey No problem at all! 😊 2w
LeahBergen @bookandbedandtea Great! You‘ll be nominating for our July read but I‘ll let you know when to post. We are waiting for our January and March people to post right now and then I‘ll ask for May and July (you! 😆) to put up your nomination. We‘ve found that posting two months at a time saves us from any duplication in nominations. 2w
Tamra @LeahBergen I will wait for @willaful to post January to avoid potential duplication. 😊 2w
LeahBergen @Tamra Sounds good! 👍 2w
bookandbedandtea @LeahBergen That makes so much sense! 😉 2w
willaful @Tamra should have it up tomorrow. 2w
Tamra @willaful 👍🏾 2w
rubyslippersreads Looking forward to a whole year of delightful reading! 2w
LeahBergen @rubyslippersreads I am, too! 😄 2w
LeahBergen @rubyslippersreads There‘s been a slight change and you‘re now up to select our November voting choices. Is that okay? If so, post away! 😄 1w
rubyslippersreads @LeahBergen That‘s fine. I‘ll start researching my choices. 😊 1w
LeahBergen @rubyslippersreads Awesome! Thank you. 😊 1w
51 likes1 stack add24 comments
quote
swynn
Joseph Andrews | Henry Fielding
post image

It is a trite but true Observation, that Examples work more forcibly on the Mind than Precepts: And if this be just in what is odious and blameable, it is more strongly so in what is amiable and praise-worthy.

#FirstLineFridays
@ShyBookOwl

blurb
willaful
Woods in Winter | Stella Gibbons

I started this with a “four chapters a day“ plan and then read it straight through so I was definitely engaged. Set in the 30s, it started out with two interesting characters: Ivy, a thrice-widowed charwoman with an incredibly strong sense of self, and poet Helen, who's kind of lost herself in an affair with a man who won't marry her.

cont.

willaful When Ivy inherits a house (sort of? It's apparently a rental, yet willed to her?) she can finally live exactly the way she wants to, with animals and birds and even cockroaches freely sharing her space. And somehow a lot of other people in the neighborhood find themselves throwing off visions of what their lives should be and doing what they want instead. It's all kind of a muddle though, and I would rather have found out more about Helen's life. 3w
Ruthiella Good review. A muddle is accurate. There wasn‘t any focus. Not unpleasant but not great either, IMO. 3w
See All 9 Comments
willaful @Ruthiella yeah, I definitely enjoyed it more than some but it was lacking. 3w
LeahBergen @Ruthiella @willaful I‘m approaching the middle point (and the muddle, I think 😆). 3w
Faranae @willaful If it's set in the UK, there is in fact a legal thing where someone can have the right to live on a property while the actual ownership is held by someone else, and they can't be evicted. It used to be a way that rich people pensioned off favourite servants, or discharged responsibility for favourite/hated relations. I don't remember the legal term though! 3w
willaful @Faranae It's mentioned in the book that it's not a “freehold“ and though he could leave it to her, she couldn't leave it to anyone. Which is so confusing! Those British are crazy. 😂 3w
Faranae @willaful But they didn't give what it actually is? Eg, copyhold (abolished in 1925), life estate, leasehold (you could do a leasehold where the rent is 0)... I think a lot of people also don't know that “freehold“ is often shorthand for “perpetual freehold“, and there are other types of freehold... 3w
willaful @Faranae I think it did say leasehold, and presumably rent free. 3w
40 likes9 comments
review
Ruthiella
The Woods in Winter | Stella Gibbons
post image
Pickpick

#FurrowedMiddlebrowClub
#37by37

A very soft pick. It was a bit of a meandering hodgepodge. Taciturn, middle aged, and slightly witchy charwoman, Ivy Gover, inherits her uncle cottage outside the village of Nethersham in 1930 or so. There are a few village romances, a poignant foster son situation, a mean girl, class consciousness and class clashes. And then there‘s an epilogue 40 years later. It felt a little unfinished.

LeahBergen I‘m still reading and almost at the halfway point. I‘m wondering if the “unfinishedness” is a product of this being her last book? I‘ve saved the introduction to read until after I‘m done! 3w
Ruthiella @LeahBergen I think that might have played into it. 3w
LeahBergen I‘m going to make our post in the next day or two, calling for next year‘s voting. Is that okay with you, my fellow host? 😆 3w
See All 9 Comments
Ruthiella @LeahBergen Yes. Perfect. Should we also do a roll call of sorts? I think the core participants have changed and some are no longer active on the platform. 🤔 3w
Tamra I‘m only a third in and enjoying it, but based on reviews so far I should lower my expectations. Starts out strong! 3w
Cuilin @Tamra yes I thought it started strong, now I may need to adjust my expectations too. 3w
Ruthiella @Tamra @Cuilin It was overall enjoyable but no one storyline felt entirely fleshed out, IMO. 3w
LeahBergen @Ruthiella We should! I was going to drop a couple of names from the list that haven‘t been on Litsy for a year or two (they‘ll find us if they come back 😄). Do you want to do the roll call and then I‘ll check our picking order and organize that bit? 3w
Ruthiella @LeahBergen Yes, will do! 3w
74 likes1 stack add9 comments
blurb
willaful
Woods in Winter | Stella Gibbons
post image

I was really enjoying this, but halfway though it suddenly started focusing on all these extraneous characters. I'm baffled.

#FurrowedMiddlebrowClub

LeahBergen Oh no. I haven‘t got to that point yet! 😆 4w
Ruthiella Agree! I‘m at 80% and there‘s still no plot to speak of! 😆 3w
27 likes2 comments
blurb
LitsyEvents
The Woods in Winter | Stella Gibbons
post image

Happy Halloween 🎃
via @Ruthiella
#FurrowedMiddlebrowClub readers!
Reminding y'all that our last title in 2025 is the tagged in November. I've started it and I will say, if you are a dog lover, you will appreciate it.
#JusticeforMrJones&JimJams (!)
Read at your own pace and make sure to tag us in your review and any related posts.
This buddy read is open to anyone. If you would like to be added to or removed from the tag list, say the word.

Ruthiella Thank you! 🙏 1mo
Tamra Oh, how fun! Thanks for the reminder! @Ruthiella (edited) 1mo
24 likes2 comments