Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Fallen Idols
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
16 posts | 3 read | 5 to read
Over the past three years, the world has witnessed the huge social and media discussions of what figures from the past one should, or should not celebrate and commemorate with a statue. The recent removal of the statue of infamous slave transporter Edward Colston in Bristol still resonates in the UK as debates rage on race, inequality, politics and gender. The conversations, demonstrations and petitions for the removal of statues to men and women whose lives and careers are in question is not a new phenomenon, but one that has been going on for generations. Only with the arrival of online media outlets has it now come to the fore in 'real time'. Fallen Idols will be a nuanced and constructive appraisal of the current issues facing many towns and cities as they struggle to decide how the commemoration and adoration of statues that they hold dear (or despise) can be resolved. Von Tunzelmann focuses on key statues across the USA, the UK, Africa and to the old USSR to show the reader how the march of history can be unkind to leaders we sometime venerate at one point, and then cast aside at another - what they achieved, why their memory was celebrated in stone, and why they were then removed. A hugely informative read, supported with line-drawn illustrations of the statues chosen - that will educate and entertain in equal measure.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image
Pickpick

A fascinating look at why statues are erected, why they're later pulled down, and whether or not it should matter.

quote
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image

quote
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image

quote
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image

(Continued)...worry about people "rewriting" history--that, after all, is what historians do all the time, incorporating new evidence and new interpretations. We should worry if people stop asking questions about the stories they are told.

quote
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image

True. The only problem is that a lot of people who are interested in statue removal aren't too keen on free speech either.

Susanita Putting up the statues was itself an act of rewriting history. 2y
SamAnne @Susanita yes so true. I was surprised to learn that most were put up during Jim Crow with the clear intention to create fear in Black communities. Decades after the Civil War. 2y
2 likes2 comments
quote
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image

DebbieGrillo Maybe no mortal is worth memorializing in this way. 2y
keithmalek @DebbieGrillo Lincoln is. Of course, the Woke Left had a problem with him too. 2y
DebbieGrillo Meh, I'm not American. Lincoln was good in his time. I would have probably identified myself as "woke" before it became an insult. Now, I identify as just left of moderate. Statues, to me, are just not interesting. I think all people have an inherent equal value. Of course, there are people who do things that make that no longer true for themselves. 2y
keithmalek @DebbieGrillo "Woke" only became an insult once they became absurd. Good for you for not being an American. I wish I could say the same. 2y
DebbieGrillo There is nothing wrong with being American. The harm is in being an extremist, left or right. We have them in Canada, too. 2y
2 likes5 comments
quote
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image

Trump does the exact same thing, which is bizarre considering the fact that he's six-foot-two. Of course, he claims to be six-foot-three since he can't even tell the truth about something as simple as that.

1 like1 stack add
quote
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image

(Continued)...legitimate, people will usually accept it.

quote
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image

quote
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image

quote
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image

quote
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image

(Continued)...some kind of sense of people's often-times senseless actions."

quote
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image

quote
keithmalek
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image

review
catiewithac
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN
post image
Pickpick

I loved this enjoyable history of how 12 statues of “Great Men” were toppled. It‘s a wondrous examination of how history is alive and an open discourse on meaning and values! ⭐️

67 likes2 stack adds
blurb
shanaqui
Fallen Idols | ALEX VON. TUNZELMANN

This book discusses various toppled statues by placing them in their historical context, both their raising and their toppling. Some corners of history I knew comparatively little about are covered!

I'm finding it surprisingly slow going for something I'm enjoying, though. Oh well.