Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
#Germany
review
JillR
Good Girl: A Novel | Aria Aber
post image
Pickpick

Set in post-reunification Germany, Nila‘s Afghan parents & Nila struggle to find their cultural place in Berlin. Nila is coming of age in techno clubs and a drug-fuelled lifestyle of self-loathing & an obsession with her older American boyfriend. Her struggle to find her place & the cultural expectation that she be a good girl were all excellent. The messy narrative surrounding Nila & Marlowe less so. Overall this is an intriguing, absorbing read

review
Hooked_on_books
Good Girl: A Novel | Aria Aber
post image
Panpan

I am beyond frustrated by this book. It has such rich material—fish out of water, racism, stranger in your own land—and it‘s just kind of a mess. Plus, there‘s an explosive event near the end that was so gripping, I really wish the book had been set around it, but instead it‘s squandered. What is this doing on the #WP25 short (or long) list?

squirrelbrain I thought that event was a bit deus ex machina - an excuse to bring her home. It would have been much better to have been suggested or signposted earlier in the book. 2d
Hooked_on_books @squirrelbrain If that event had been about a third of the way in after the stage was set about her struggles and the rest of the book explored the aftermath and how it upended her, her community, and her sense of identity, I would have loved that. Instead it was plopped in without really exploring it. I don‘t get it. 2d
53 likes2 comments
review
Centique
Kairos: Roman | Jenny Erpenbeck
post image
Pickpick

This is a soft pick. It is incredibly well written, in parts it was over my head with cultural & historical references, sometimes fascinatingly so & sometimes it began to feel too much & meaningless. It did some truly interesting things with form in the second half of the book - with repetition & alternating pov between paragraphs - giving you real time variances between the two protagonists. But the relationship! I felt so disturbed ⬇️

Centique by how destructive this became. And i can see this is the point - the reader is supposed to be disturbed - but it‘s very hard for me to recc anyone else go on this journey. I wont forget this book - but i feel relieved to close the pages and leave it behind. (edited) 3d
CarolynM Sounds interesting, but I think I‘ll leave it 😬 2d
Centique @CarolynM I think thats a decision i maybe should have made! How are you? Hope everyone is well? Xxx 2d
Reggie I have this stacked or else I would have stacked it after-this relationship! I can‘t believe how destructive this became-lol. Great review, Paula. 1d
Centique @Reggie the first third is absolutely gorgeous but then gird your loins 🤪 I want to know what you think when you get here! 23h
54 likes5 comments
review
BookishTrish
Good Girl: A Novel | Aria Aber
post image
Mehso-so

Read because of the #womensprizeforfiction shortlist, but this one was really not for me. Strong, evocative writing but utter aimless characters and plot.

blurb
Dilara
Le monde nazi: 1919-1945 | Johann Chapoutot, Christian Ingrao, Nicolas Patin
post image

Halfway through this serious overview of nazism & terrified by the parallels that can be drawn between today & the 30s. On AH's bday, let's remember that he was a good public speaker, but a lazy, incompetent statesman w/ a short attention span who relied on a handful of high-ups + everyday Germans as part of an organic whole. They figured out what needed doing to reach the goals he had set out, then carried it out independently & zealously.

Kitta Just finished reading a book about Nazi occupied France and was thinking the same about the parallels. 5d
Dilara @Kitta It is uncanny, isn't it... 5d
34 likes1 stack add2 comments
review
vlwelser
Good Girl: A Novel | Aria Aber
post image
Pickpick

I kind of want this to win the Women's Prize. I do think The Safekeep is better and still have no idea why it didn't win the Booker.

#BookSpinBingo @TheAromaofBooks

TheAromaofBooks Great progress!!! 6d
35 likes1 comment
blurb
kspenmoll
Caspar David Friedrich: The Soul of Nature | Alison Hokanson , Joanna Sheers Seidenstein
post image

Yesterday my son & I enjoyed another #makingmemories day in NYC.The cold,damp,& rain did not deter us! We took a 6:10 a.m. Amtrak train to the Metro North line which let us out at Grand Central Station.Breakfast for me was 2 mini bacon quiches & Starbucks coffee. Perfect start to my day! The MET exhibit was truly breathtaking. I love how the drawings, etchings, & oil paintings took us through Friedrich‘s artistic & spiritual life chronologically.

TheBookHippie Love love love !!!! 2w
Kitta The Met is one of my favourite things about living in NYC! 2w
AnnCrystal 💝💝💝. 2w
See All 6 Comments
kspenmoll @Kitta Lucky you! Is it free because you live in NYC? 2w
Kitta @kspenmoll yes! Just need to bring proof you live here. 2w
kspenmoll @Kitta What an amazing benefit of city living!!! I am so happy we are just 2 train rides away! (edited) 2w
58 likes1 stack add6 comments
review
IriDas
The Trial of Anna Thalberg | Eduardo Sangarca
post image
Pickpick

Won this in a contest. It was a hard read, but not for the way it was written. It‘s about a witch trial in medieval Europe and, unlike my usual fantasy fare, I cannot split my mind and read it dispassionately. This stuff really happened. Anyway, I highly recommend it. Especially if you like creative prose. Sangarcía‘s method really adds to the intensity of a story that we probably think we know well. Also timely, atc.

5 likes1 stack add
review
Chelsea.Poole
Good Girl: A Novel | Aria Aber
post image
Pickpick

Another uncomfortable read from the Women‘s Prize list—this was just shortlisted, while I was in the middle of reading it. Nila is the “good girl” who relocates to Berlin with her Afghani family, both parents successful but forced to work in fast food in their new country. Shes miserable and constantly trying to escape her own skin by engaging in damaging behaviors with substances and unhealthy relationships. A rocky coming of age. Good audio.

88 likes2 stack adds
review
Anna40
Good Girl: A Novel | Aria Aber
post image
Pickpick

Nila,the daughter of doctor refugees from Afghanistan,grows up in poverty in Berlin because both parents cannot work in their profession.she hides her identity,saying she‘s Greek or Israeli&instead of studying for college,goes to raves&techno clubs.One night she meets Marlowe&is mesmerised by the older man whose debut novel made him an Indy celebrity.lots of drugs,sex,art,books,self hate,hate for Germany&its racism,Islamophobia,oppression of women

Anna40 I‘m so not the target audience for this and soon got bored with manipulative Marlowe, self hate, drugs, sex but the writing is good, the characters are compelling and I can see why Aber and this book receive so much praise. 1mo
squirrelbrain Yes, I found it rather repetitive after a while too. 🤷‍♀️ Great review though! 1mo
Anna40 @squirrelbrain it gets boring. It doesn‘t really go anywhere 1mo
charl08 Yeah, I'm not a fan either. Maybe first novel syndrome though: I'd pick up her next book. 1mo
Anna40 Yes @charl08 and @squirrelbrain I wanted to add that too: it‘s her debut and the next books might be very different 1mo
40 likes5 comments