With Julia being one of my favorite novels of 2023 I had high hopes for The Men. Granted, while I found the idea intriguing, I knew it would take a decent amount of willing disbelief. That turned out to be less of an issue. What really keeps The Men from being anything other than a novel with a cool idea and some thought-provoking observations is its disjointedness. It goes in too many directions in a very small space and feels hollow by the end.