Delbanco‘s literary criticism is often insightful (it gave me some new elements to think about), and the descriptions of the historical context made me feel even closer to Melville‘s writing (political unrest! megalomaniac leaders! an economy that serves the needs of the wealthy on the backs of the workers! All in Melville‘s work). The biographical portions are weakest - the way he uses Melville‘s work to explain his life sometimes overreaches.