Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
A Study in Honor (The Janet Watson Chronicles, #1)
A Study in Honor (The Janet Watson Chronicles, #1) | Claire O'Dell
26 posts | 19 read | 19 to read
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
CampbellTaraL
post image
Pickpick

A retelling of S. Holmes & Dr. Watson in an alternate reality/near future setting where the protagonists are two black women in the WA DC area. Gritty and dark, with a close look at what returning soldiers of war endure when they don't fit into society (PTSD, disability, etc). The characters are intriguing while the story is kind of clunky at times, like it needed another round of edits. Still, I liked this a lot and looking forward to the next.

review
arlenefinnigan
post image
Mehso-so

I didn't really enjoy this, but that's more a reflection on the fact that political thrillers aren't really my genre than on the writing. I also found the twisty plot hard to follow on audio, it would probably have been better to read it in print. It's well written, and it's an interesting speculation on what a post-Trump New Confederacy dystopia would have been like.

blurb
arlenefinnigan
post image

#ReadHarder challenge 15: a political thriller by a marginalized author (BIPOC, or LGBTQIA+)

25 likes1 stack add
blurb
Branwen
post image

Finished the first book, now I'm excitedly jumping into the next one! 💕📚

DaveGreen7777 😀😀😀 4y
Branwen @DaveGreen7777 I knew you'd be pleased! 😁 4y
46 likes1 stack add2 comments
blurb
Branwen
post image

I'm enjoying this one a lot so far! 💕📚 #catsoflitsy #littenkitten #roxas

DaveGreen7777 YAY!!! 😀🥳🎉 4y
Branwen @DaveGreen7777 Have you read this?! Did you know what kind of treasure you were sending me?! 😲😍 I read almost 160 pages in one sitting because I could not put it down! I also...may have just ordered the sequel! 😶 4y
DaveGreen7777 @Branwen I‘m so happy you‘re enjoying this book so much! 😊 4y
51 likes1 stack add3 comments
blurb
Branwen
post image

@DaveGreen7777

Eeeeeeee! Your holiday boxes arrived today safely and I am overwhelmed by your kindness and generosity, my friend! Thank you so so much, Dave! I love everything so much! My Star Wars Queens! QUEEN JANEWAY! The 13th Doctor! R.A. Salvatore! So much awesomeness! THANK YOU! I am so grateful for our friendship!

Ps-> I'm starting the tagged book first! 😁

DaveGreen7777 I‘m so glad you liked your books (and your sassy Star Wars Funkos)! Merry Christmas, Becky! 🤗🎄🎁 4y
Branwen @DaveGreen7777 I do! I love everything so much! Merry Christmas, Dave! 🤗💖 4y
45 likes2 comments
blurb
KathyWheeler
post image

I want to like this book — I love the world O‘Dell has created with Watson and Holmes as black and queer women and an America during a 2nd Civil War— but I‘m getting bogged down in Watson‘s day. I understand specificity helps make fictional worlds feel real, but O‘Dell is too specific. I feel like I‘m experiencing every second of Watson‘s day. It‘s too much and too boring. Now that we‘ve finally met Holmes, I hope the story picks up. #audiowalk

review
SW-T
post image
Pickpick

A black lesbian retelling of Sherlock Holmes and Watson? It worked. Holmes was harder to get to know, but I liked Watson‘s character from the first line. O‘Dell created an original world while staying true to the spirit of the Holmes canon. Looking forward to the next book.

#lgbtq #queerbooks

27 likes4 stack adds
review
Liatrek
post image
Pickpick

I‘m a huge fan of the Sherlock movies and TV show but I have never read the original source material. I found this Sherlock and Holmes reimagining interesting in some areas and flat in others. I think the author captured Watson well but I just wasn‘t sold on her version Holmes. The mystery doesn‘t really start until about 100+ pages but overall I enjoyed the concept and will read the next book in the series.

70 likes1 stack add
blurb
Liatrek
post image

Slow but interesting and the fact that it‘s set in a future based on worse case scenario of current events makes for an unsettling read.

Reggie When I read the passage and then what you had to say I looked up at the title and for a minute I thought it said A Study in Horror. Which I feel would still be applicable. Lol 5y
Liatrek @Reggie Lol! It would totally fit this book 🤣 5y
64 likes2 stack adds2 comments
blurb
Shaunesay
post image

Some of the books I hope to get through this month.

review
writerlibrarian
post image
Mehso-so

While reading I was getting this vibe of malaise from it. As a Holmes remix it checks a lot of boxes. O'Dell writes a Watson that I could see as a black veteran army doctor woman. Janet has a "life" as a character beyond the Watson boxes. That's about all I liked in this remix.

Holmes is so problematic. This character checked all the Holmes boxes, sure, in a terrible way. It's sad because I had really hoped to get an amazing remix out of it.

blurb
writerlibrarian
post image

A rare night where I will watch my home team and later the team I love. So it's Carter Hart's first game in Montreal and later it's Pens in Vegas with 🌸 #readingandwatchinghockey on a really, really arctic night outside.

writerlibrarian It's so so weird to cheer and laugh as 🌸 steals goals from Sid. Book is done and meh... Phil 🚨 1-0 🐧 Vegas ties on PP. 2 break away later 3-1 Vegas. Well... 🐧 came back in the 2nd with a goal and... finally Sid scored on 🌸 they are tied at 3. (edited) 6y
34 likes1 comment
blurb
writerlibrarian
post image

Finishing this Holmes remix while #readingandlisteningtohockey Pens are in Arizona. Late game. It's so cold 🥶 tonight.

writerlibrarian 87 started the game in the 📦 . 4 penalties so far... it's 1-0 Yotes. (edited) 6y
35 likes1 comment
blurb
writerlibrarian
post image

This remix is keeping me interested. I'm up to 60%. Leafs down in Florida to face the ⚡️it's brrrr weather right now. There's wood burning in the fireplace. It's a cozy night of #readingandwatchinghockey

writerlibrarian All tied at 1. Marleau 🚨 but ⚡️ 🚨 and ties it. A few minutes later, Marner 🚨 and it's 3-2 🍁win with an empty net goal.4-2. (edited) 6y
29 likes1 comment
review
Tonton
post image
Pickpick

Set in the near future after a New Civil War in America (with everything wrong in irl newsfeed now,still going strong), this is a queer women homage to Holmes and Watson. There was a Japanese Hulu series recently with women Holmes and Watson (Miss Sherlock)so maybe a trend? I think it could have riffed more on the Sherlockian elements, but would be definitely up for the next one!

34 likes1 stack add
blurb
writerlibrarian
post image

Leafs hockey tonight. Holmes remix is quite good so far. Prince Frederik is back. 💜💜💜💜

#readingandwatchinghockey

Miss_Kim Love this! 🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦 6y
writerlibrarian 🍁 blew their PP. Ditto Avs to open the 2nd period. Leafs score on a slapshot. 1-0 🍁 Fourth line goal called back but... next shift Kappy 🚨Avs score twice and tie the game. 🍁 on PP again and the Avs 🚨 SH. 3-2 Avs. 🍁 get a penalty right at the end of the period. Marner ties the game. Avs pull ahead again. Avs 🚨 an empty netter. 5-3 Avs. Second empty net 🚨 6-3 (edited) 6y
33 likes2 comments
blurb
writerlibrarian
post image

Saturday 🏒. 2 games this evening: one I'll watch aka 🍁 battling Boston then I'll listen until I'll probably fall 😴 to the 🐧 vs the 👑 it's a 10.30 pm game. New nails. ❄️ silver/white.
#readingandwatchinghockey

ItsAngel Pretty nails, are they wraps? 6y
writerlibrarian @ItsAngel they are my nails with gel polish and painted on by the marvellous nail artist I go to. She's amazing. 6y
ItsAngel Very pretty! 6y
writerlibrarian After a slow start and Boston drawing first blood, 🍁 are up a goal 2-1 . Boston starts the 3rd period ahead by 1. (edited) 6y
37 likes4 comments
blurb
writerlibrarian
post image

They are predicting minus 20 celsius but you will feel minus 30 C for tonight and early morning. I plugged my 🚙 so it will start tomorrow. It's the really first blue frost night of the year. Kinda appropriate for a 🍁 game. The Holmes remix so far is good. #readingandwatchinghockey

writerlibrarian Hyman is back and we get a SH 🚨 1-0 🍁Hyman gets an 🍎 on Tavares 🚨 2-0 🍁 91 🚨 again. 3-0. After 2 periods, 2 back to back 🚨 for the 👿 3-2 (edited) 6y
CouronneDhiver Sooo brutal outside today. 🥶❄️☃️ 6y
rabbitprincess Brrrrrrr! 6y
33 likes3 comments
blurb
writerlibrarian
post image

Tuesday hockey is a double Pens at home vs Florida and Dallas in St-Louis.
#readingandwatchinghockey

writerlibrarian 🐧 are already up by 2 🚨Rusty adds another one 3-0 🐧. It's now 4-0. Two headed monster together on the ice and 87 🚨 5-1 🐧. Pens win and are headed to the West Coast. It's gonna be late night games for the coming weel. (edited) 6y
33 likes1 comment
blurb
writerlibrarian
post image

#anewchapter
#newbeginnings
A Study in Honor by Claire O'Dell aka Beth Bernobich is on sale today. It's a dystopian queer women Holmes remix. I had it bookmarked to get when it was affordable. The reviews are split on it. I'll see I guess.
@Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks @vkois88

WanderingBookaneer What is Booked 2019? 6y
writerlibrarian @WanderingBookaneer it's a theme reading challenge organized by @BarbaraTheBibliophage and @Cinfhen and @4thhouseontheleft in four parts aka seasons. You can find the details by searching #booked2019 or #booked19 (edited) 6y
Cinfhen Thanks for sharing @writerlibrarian You should join in @WanderingBookaneer it‘s a low key but fun challenge we run here on Litsy. 24 prompts spread over quarters/seasons ...no pressure!! Also tagging the third cohost @4thhouseontheleft 6y
See All 9 Comments
writerlibrarian @Cinfhen i knew I was forgetting one. ☹️ 6y
Cinfhen No worries 😉 🥰 6y
ChasingOm Oh man, that book sounds amazing. 🤔 Let me know what you think? 🤗 6y
writerlibrarian @ChasingOm will do. There isn't a Holmes remix I won't try. 6y
Alwaysbeenaloverofbooks 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻 6y
vkois88 👍👍👍 6y
43 likes9 comments
review
shanaqui
Pickpick

Didn't always work for me, but I found it an entertaining read. More homage to than retelling of Sherlock Holmes.

blurb
shanaqui

Another of those where I picked it up to try a couple pages and didn't put it down for 100+ pages. Not sure what I think of the Holmes retelling aspect -- I feel like it could be stronger without leaning on that context, which is not really the same story beyond some of the characters' traits. Enjoying it, though.

PickwickPlockPlock I've been thinking about buying it, mainly for the Holmes connection. 6y
RaimeyGallant Good to know. :) 6y
12 likes2 comments
blurb
Batman
post image