Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Maybe Esther
Maybe Esther: A Family Story | Katja Petrowskaja
2 posts | 4 read | 3 to read
An inventive, unique, and extraordinarily moving literary debut that pieces together the fascinating story of one womans family across twentieth-century Russia, Ukraine, Poland, and Germany. Katja Petrowskaja wanted to create a kind of family tree, charting relatives who had scattered across multiple countries and continents. Her idea blossomed into this striking and highly original work of narrative nonfiction, an account of her search for meaning within the stories of her ancestors. In a series of short meditations, Petrowskaja delves into family legends, introducing a remarkable cast of characters: Judas Stern, her great-uncle, who shot a German diplomatic attach in 1932 and was sentenced to death; her grandfather Semyon, who went underground with a new name during the Bolshevik Revolution in Russia, forever splitting their branch of the family from the rest; her grandmother Rosa, who ran an orphanage in the Urals for deaf-mute Jewish children; her Ukrainian grandfather Vasily, who disappeared during World War II and reappeared without explanation forty-one years laterand settled back into the family as if hed never been gone; and her great-grandmother, whose name may have been Esther, who alone remained in Kiev and was killed by the Nazis. How do you talk about what you cant know, how do you bring the past to life? To answer this complex question, Petrowskaja visits the scenes of these events, reflecting on a fragmented and traumatized century and bringing to light family figures who threaten to drift into obscurity. A true search for the past reminiscent of Jonathan Safran Foers Everything Is Illuminated, Daniel Mendelsohns The Lost, and Michael Chabons Moonglow, Maybe Esther is a poignant, haunting investigation of the effects of history on one family.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
review
ReadingEnvy
Maybe Esther: A Family Story | Katja Petrowskaja
post image
Mehso-so

I enjoy a good research narrative and that's really what this is - more than a memoir, as the author is only barely present in the book, it's the story of Katja's family members, as she traces them through the historical events that forced relocation. Most of her family members were Jewish and lived in Poland, Ukraine, and Russia, with forced moves into Austria and Germany for some. ↘️

ReadingEnvy The research takes her to Soviet archives, concentration camp historians, an old rabbi who knew a family member, a former student of the "deaf-mute" schools her family members were known for establishing, and even a former landlord. ↘️ 3y
ReadingEnvy There is some reflection by the author on places that do not seem to acknowledge the atrocities that occured where they are. Kiev really stood out this way, where 13k+ Jewish people were killed in two days but the statues of commemoration of that period are about local war heroes instead.↘️ 3y
ReadingEnvy While I found the contents and approach unique, the book took a while to get through, largely due to its fragmentary nature and problematic formatting in the Kindle eBook version (which I paid for, not an ARC.) 3y
54 likes1 stack add3 comments
review
tholmz
Maybe Esther: A Family Story | Katja Petrowskaja
Bailedbailed

I feel like I could have stuck this one out, but it couldn‘t hold my attention.