Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Death In Captivity
Death In Captivity | Michael Gilbert
7 posts | 5 read
A suspected informer is found dead in a collapsed escape tunnel in a prisoner-of-war camp in Italy. So as to protect the tunnel the prisoners decide to move the body. But then the fascist captors declare the death to be murder and determine to execute the officer they suspect. It therefore becomes a race against time to find the true culprit.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
Pick icon
100%
review
shanaqui
Death In Captivity | Michael Gilbert
Pickpick

A mild pick here; I found this a bit much in some ways, because even though the description of life in a prisoner of war camp is very light and matter-of-fact... it makes it all the more clear the author experienced it, and is writing from that experience.

Plus, without saying too much, the solution to the mystery is a part of that grimness.

Still, there's something to be said about the power of Gilbert's writing that it made me feel that way!

blurb
shanaqui
Death In Captivity | Michael Gilbert

Well... here I am again. It's been a long time -- exams, health stuff, etc, all have kept me a bit hermitlike for a while. But I'm hoping to find a little more time for Litsy now, at least for a while!

This is my current read, and it feels a bit grim. It's set in a prisoner-of-war camp, presented reasonably cheerfully, but with the grimness of it all never far below the surface. (The intro points out that Gilbert was writing from experience.)

Lindy Welcome back 🤗 1y
Clare-Dragonfly Good to see you here again! 👋🏻 1y
Faranae Oh! This one was on my blog awhile back! Two of his fellow escapees also wrote books about their experiences, both memoirs. “When the Moon Rises“ is by Tony Davies (the person Gilbert traveled with), and “Love and War in the Apennines“ by Eric Newby (same camp, but traveled separately as I recall). It's interesting that Gilbert opted to make a mystery novel out of the same experience.

Also welcome back!!!
1y
See All 6 Comments
rabbitprincess Welcome back! I liked this one. 1y
shanaqui Thanks everyone!

@Faranae I find it really weird how the feel of it makes it super obvious he knew whereof he speaks. Like there's a lot of fiction about this period that tries to be hyper-realistic and includes oh so many details, but... there's something much more convincing about the glib treatment here.
1y
Faranae @shanaqui Yeah, a lot of fiction is sort of... trying too hard at grittiness. About the only time I've found that historical writers and people who lived through the events have any sort of match in tone is the Great War, where often the historical fiction writers are not conveying the sheer exhaustion nor sense of absurdity, only the “mud, blood, and tears“ grimness, but at least that part is true to the memoirists as well. 1y
12 likes6 comments
review
deirdrebeecher
Death In Captivity | Michael Gilbert
post image
Pickpick

This is an interesting one if you read Vintage books as historical documents. Gilbert was a WWII POW in Italy and he brings the camp and characters vividly to life. It's an entertaining read.

However this book also reminds you that Eugenics was invented by the English, and the way Italian are described made me grit my teeth at the Superiority complex. Also at the Classism, officers had orderlies, even in Prison Camp?!

blurb
Bookwormjillk
Death In Captivity | Michael Gilbert
post image

I‘m looking forward to this vintage mystery where the #victim is found in a WWII era tunnel. #scarathlon #photoprompt

quote
charl08
Death In Captivity | Michael Gilbert
post image

He had been invited...

38 likes1 stack add
review
rabbitprincess
Death In Captivity | Michael Gilbert
Pickpick

This was a great read. Murder strikes in a prisoner of war camp in Italy, and one of the POWs turns detective. The plots to outwit the guards and rig up escape tunnels reminded me of Hogan‘s Heroes 😆

blurb
shanaqui
Death In Captivity | Michael Gilbert
post image

I have been trying to ignore lists and guilt trips about "you should be reading X" or "you shouldn't buy new books till you read X number of old ones" (that kind of thing has been killing my love of reading), so today I dropped by Waterstones to grab a pile of British Library Crime Classics, which always seem to suit my mood!

rabbitprincess Smallbone Deceased was great! 5y
shanaqui @rabbitprincess I took that as a recommendation on where to start, and am now halfway through it! 😁 5y
15 likes2 comments