Home Feed
Home
Search
Search
Add Review, Blurb, Quote
Add
Activity
Activity
Profile
Profile
Genuine Fakes
Genuine Fakes: How Phony Things Teach Us About Real Stuff | Lydia Pyne
2 posts | 1 to read
Is the distinction between "real" and "fake" as clear-cut as we might think? From fake fur and fake diamonds to art forgeries and staged nature documentaries, history is full of things that are considered fake. However, the concept of a fake is not as clear-cut as we might believe. We come into contact with "genuine fakes" every day without even realizing it, and the social history, scientific background, and cultural context of these genuinely fake objects have played significant roles in helping to develop and spread very real knowledge about the world and have done so in curious and unexpected ways. In this thought-provoking and surprising book, historian Lydia Pyne looks at nine things that fall into the realm of "genuine fakes," including art forgeries, fake fossils, nature documentaries, and synthetic flavors. Using research from historical archives, interviews with a variety of experts--from flavor scientists at the Jelly Belly Bean company to the memorial diamond start-up company offering a service of turning the cremated ashes of loved ones into diamonds--as well as her own experiences to put together each unique story, Genuine Fakes makes readers think about all the genuinely fake things that they engage with every day. Amid worries of "fake news" and "alternative facts," the question of authenticity and how it shapes our view of the world has taken on particular urgency in this century, and this book will encourage readers to take a more open-minded view of fakes. Should we be outraged that some of those famous scenes in Blue Planet were filmed in a lab? Why is the British Museum currently exhibiting a known fake? Would you be upset if you were proposed to with a lab-grown diamond? Fakes such as this can represent an ethical choice on the part of the consumer, demonstrating that not all fakes are necessarily bad. Authenticity is a continuum, one thats told story after story. Genuine Fakes is a collection of stories about how science and society come together to create genuinely fake things, and the knowledge that is created because of them.
Amazon Indiebound Barnes and Noble WorldCat Goodreads LibraryThing
blurb
shanaqui

I'm finding some of the “it was a fake, but it was a GENUINE fake!“ language a bit tiresome. No, it was a fake fossil created to mislead, even if it was cobbled together from bits of real ones and was intended to confuse commercial buyers rather than scientists; let's try not to confuse the issue here.

Still a surprisingly engaging book, but the genuine fake thing is not working for me.

Clare-Dragonfly Huh, I would think a “genuine fake” would be like… an actual Feejee Mermaid, not a 21st-century object purporting to be one. 4y
shanaqui @Clare-Dragonfly Some of the objects discussed are like that -- fakes, but with their own history and afterlife that make them desirable *as* fakes! But then it had the Archaeoraptor as one as well, which... No, that's just a fake. 4y
9 likes2 comments
blurb
shanaqui
post image

I got this book somewhat on a whim, but it's actually very engaging. I'm really curious to look up some more of the works of the “Spanish forger“, who created a lot of fake medieval work and whose style is apparently really recognisable. Their work is now often worth more than genuine medieval work!